Lesson 10 of 10 · 18 min
Paradoxes: twins, flashlights and a ladder in a barn
Explain the twins' paradox, the flashlights on a train and the ladder in the barn, showing that each apparent contradiction disappears once you apply the postulates carefully.
What you will be able to do
- Explain the twins' paradox and why the travelling twin ages less.
- Explain the flashlights on a train scenario from two frames.
- Explain the ladder in the barn paradox using the relativity of simultaneity.
- Calculate the ages and lengths involved in these scenarios.
Relativity says each inertial observer sees the other's clocks running slow and the other's rulers shortened. That symmetry sounds like it must lead to contradictions. Physicists have spent a century inventing scenarios to try to break the theory. Each one, examined carefully, turns out to be consistent. These "paradoxes" are the best way to test whether you really understand the postulates.
Key idea
The twins' paradox
Ava stays on Earth. Her twin Ben flies to a distant star at high speed and returns. Ava sees Ben's clocks run slow, so Ben should come back younger. But Ben sees Ava moving, so shouldn't Ava be younger? They can't both be younger when they meet again.
Resolution. The situation is not symmetric. Ava stays in one inertial frame the whole time. Ben does not: he must accelerate to leave, turn around at the star, and decelerate to land. When he turns around he changes from an outbound inertial frame to a return one, and his idea of "now on Earth" jumps forward. Only Ava's single-frame calculation can be applied to the whole trip, and it shows that Ben ages less. The travelling twin is younger when they reunite.
The travelling clock records years. Change the speed to see how much time passes on Earth. At , Earth's clocks record years.
Worked example
How much younger is the travelling twin?
Twins are 20 years old when one of them flies to a star light-years away (in Earth's frame) at and immediately returns at the same speed. Ignoring the brief accelerations, calculate the age of each twin when they reunite.
Step 1: Earth frame time
The round trip is ly at : years.
Step 2: Identify the proper time
On each leg, departure and arrival happen at the spacecraft, so the traveller's clock measures the proper time.
Step 3: Traveller's time
years
Step 4: Ages at reunion
Earth twin: . Travelling twin: .
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The Earth twin is 40 and the travelling twin is 32 when they reunite.
Method
Earth frame: time = (round-trip distance) ÷ speed.
Traveller: proper time .
Only the twin who stays in one inertial frame (Earth) can apply time dilation to the whole trip.
Watch out for
Arguing that each twin is younger than the other. The traveller changes frames, so the situation is not symmetric.
Forgetting the return journey.
A star is light-years from Earth (measured in Earth's frame). An astronaut flies there and straight back at . Ignoring the short periods of acceleration, by how many years does the astronaut age during the round trip?
Why is it the travelling twin, not the Earth twin, who is younger when they meet again?
Note
Flashlights on a train (recap)
A passenger at the centre of a carriage flashes torches towards both ends. In the train frame, the light reaches both ends at the same time. In the platform frame, the light travels at both ways, but the back wall moves towards it and the front wall away, so the back wall is lit first. The contradiction disappears once you accept that simultaneity is relative for separated events. The same experiment also shows that the light from a moving torch travels at , not .
Key idea
The ladder in the barn
A farmer runs with a ladder towards a barn with a door at each end. The ladder's proper length is ; the barn's proper length is . The farmer runs at , so .
Barn frame: the ladder is contracted to . It fits, just, and both doors can be shut at the same moment with the ladder inside.
Ladder frame: the barn rushes towards the farmer and is contracted to . A ladder can't possibly fit inside.
Resolution: "both doors shut at the same moment" is a statement about simultaneity. The door closings happen at different places, so events simultaneous in the barn frame are not simultaneous in the ladder frame. In the ladder frame, the far door closes (and reopens) first, before the back of the ladder has entered; then the near door closes after the front of the ladder has already left through the far door. Both frames agree about what physically happens to the ladder; they disagree only about the order of separated events.
The ladder in the barn at . Each observer sees the other object contracted.
Worked example
Will the ladder fit in the barn?
A ladder has a proper length of . A barn with doors at both ends has a proper length of .
(a) Calculate the speed at which the ladder just fits inside the barn, in the barn's frame.
(b) At that speed, calculate the length of the barn in the ladder's frame.
(c) Explain how both frames can be correct.
Step 1: Barn frame condition
Step 2: Solve for the speed
Step 3: Barn in the ladder frame
The barn moves at relative to the ladder: , far shorter than the ladder.
Step 4: Resolve with simultaneity
In the barn frame both doors can be closed at the same instant with the ladder inside. The two door closings happen at different places, so they are not simultaneous in the ladder frame: there, the far door closes first (before the back of the ladder enters) and the near door closes later (after the front has passed the far door). Only in the barn frame are both doors ever closed around the ladder at the same instant.
Disagreement about simultaneity of separated events is exactly what special relativity predicts.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) . (b) . (c) The doors closing "at the same time" is simultaneous only in the barn frame; in the ladder frame the far door closes first, so there is no contradiction.
Method
Set the contracted length equal to the space available and solve for .
Each frame sees the other object contracted.
Resolve with the relativity of simultaneity.
Watch out for
Saying the ladder is "really" . Length depends on the frame.
A pole with a proper length of is carried towards a barn with a proper length of . Calculate the minimum speed, as a fraction of , at which the pole fits inside the barn in the barn's frame.
Exam tip
Explaining a paradox
- State the apparent contradiction in one sentence.
- Describe what each observer measures, using the correct proper quantities.
- Name the idea that resolves it: acceleration / change of frame (twins) or relativity of simultaneity (ladder in the barn, flashlights on a train).
- Conclude what actually happens, which every observer agrees on.
Summary
Twins: the travelling twin changes inertial frames, so the situation isn't symmetric; the traveller measures the proper time and ages less.
Flashlights on a train: light reaches both ends together in the train frame but the back end first in the platform frame.
Ladder in the barn: each frame sees the other object contracted; door closings simultaneous in the barn frame are not simultaneous in the ladder frame.
Every relativity paradox dissolves once you track proper quantities and the relativity of simultaneity.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.