Lesson 12 of 12 · 18 min
Elastic and inelastic collisions
Tell elastic from inelastic collisions by comparing total kinetic energy, solve collision and explosion problems with both momentum and energy, and analyse a trolley collision investigation.
What you will be able to do
- Discuss the differences between elastic and inelastic collisions, with examples.
- Decide whether a collision is elastic by comparing before and after.
- Calculate the kinetic energy transformed in inelastic collisions and released in explosions.
- Analyse data from an investigation of a linear elastic collision.
A Newton's cradle clicks back and forth for a long time; two cars in a crash crumple and stop. In both, momentum is conserved, because the objects push each other with equal and opposite forces. The difference is what happens to the kinetic energy, and that is what separates elastic collisions from inelastic ones.
| Type | Total kinetic energy | What happens | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Elastic | Conserved | Objects bounce apart with no permanent deformation, heat or sound | Gas molecules; very nearly, steel or pool balls and magnetic bumpers on trolleys |
| Inelastic | Decreases | Some kinetic energy becomes thermal energy, sound and deformation | Most real collisions: a bat hitting a ball, a tackle |
| Perfectly inelastic | Decreases the most possible | The objects stick together and move off with one velocity | Car crashes where vehicles lock, a dart hitting a board |
| Explosion | Increases | Stored (chemical or elastic) energy pushes the objects apart | Fireworks, recoil, skaters pushing apart |
Key idea
The test for an elastic collision
Find any unknown velocity with conservation of momentum first. Then compare total kinetic energy:
If the total after is less, the collision is inelastic. Kinetic energy is a scalar, so add the terms without signs: is positive whichever way the object moves.
Switch between elastic, inelastic and perfectly inelastic. The total momentum never changes. The total kinetic energy stays the same only in the elastic case, and drops the most when the carts stick together.
Worked example
Is this collision elastic?
A 2.0 kg trolley moving at collides with a stationary 1.0 kg trolley on a level track. Afterwards the 2.0 kg trolley continues in the same direction at .
(a) Determine the velocity of the 1.0 kg trolley after the collision.
(b) Determine whether the collision is elastic or inelastic.
Step 1: (a) Conservation of momentum
Original direction positive: , so and in the original direction.
Step 2: Total kinetic energy before
.
Step 3: Total kinetic energy after
.
Step 4: (b) Compare and conclude
Kinetic energy falls from to , a loss of about (8%). Kinetic energy is not conserved, so the collision is inelastic. The missing energy has become sound, heat and deformation of the bumpers.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) in the original direction (b) inelastic: total kinetic energy drops from to .
Method
Momentum conservation for the unknown velocity.
Total kinetic energy before and after.
Equal means elastic; less after means inelastic; more after means stored energy was released (an explosion).
Watch out for
Calling it elastic because momentum was conserved. Momentum is conserved in both kinds.
Two trolleys collide on a level track. Which quantity is conserved whether the collision is elastic or inelastic?
A special case. When two equal masses collide elastically head-on and one starts at rest, they swap velocities: the moving one stops and the other moves off at its speed. That is the pool shot from the last lesson, and the Newton's cradle.
A 1.0 kg cart moving at hits a stationary 3.0 kg cart. Afterwards the 1.0 kg cart rebounds at and the 3.0 kg cart moves forwards at . Calculate the total kinetic energy after the collision.
Perfectly inelastic collisions lose as much kinetic energy as momentum conservation allows. In the trolleys that stuck together (2.0 kg at joining 1.0 kg at rest, moving off at ), the kinetic energy fell from to .
Explosions run the other way. The skaters who pushed apart had zero kinetic energy before and after: chemical energy from their muscles, transformed by the push.
A 0.40 kg ball of putty moving at hits and sticks to a stationary 0.60 kg trolley. Determine the kinetic energy transformed into other forms in the collision.
Note
Investigation: a linear elastic collision
Fit two trolleys with repelling magnets or spring bumpers on a level track. Measure each trolley's velocity just before and just after the collision with light gates or slow-motion video. Calculate the total momentum and total kinetic energy before and after.
Expect momentum to agree within uncertainty, and the kinetic energy after to be a few per cent lower, because of friction with the track, sound and a little heating in the bumpers. To improve the result, level the track carefully (or slightly tilt it to cancel friction), measure velocities as close to the collision as possible, and repeat trials to estimate uncertainty.
In a magnetic-bumper trolley investigation, the total kinetic energy after the collision is 4% less than before, while total momentum agrees within uncertainty. What is the most likely explanation?
Worked example
Measuring a throw with a hanging block
To measure how fast a student can throw, a 60 g lump of modelling clay is thrown horizontally into a 1.14 kg wooden block hanging on long strings. The clay sticks and the block swings up, rising 12 cm above its lowest point.
(a) Determine the speed of the clay just before impact.
(b) Calculate the percentage of the clay's kinetic energy that is transformed into other forms in the collision.
Step 1: Plan the two stages
Stage 1: the collision, a perfectly inelastic collision in which momentum is conserved but kinetic energy is not. Stage 2: the swing, in which kinetic energy becomes gravitational potential energy. Work backwards from the swing.
Step 2: Speed just after the collision
During the swing, , so .
Step 3: (a) Momentum across the collision
Total mass after: . , so .
Step 4: Kinetic energy before and after the collision
Before: . After: .
Step 5: (b) Percentage transformed
of the kinetic energy becomes thermal energy, sound and deformation of the clay.
This is why you cannot use energy conservation from the throw straight to the top of the swing. Only momentum survives the collision.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) about (b) about of the kinetic energy is transformed in the collision.
Method
Split the event at the collision.
Energy conservation for the swing: .
Momentum conservation for the collision.
Compare kinetic energies before and after to measure the loss.
Watch out for
Setting the clay's kinetic energy equal to the potential energy at the top, which gives about 1.5 m/s instead of 31 m/s.
Forgetting to convert 60 g and 12 cm.
Common mistake
Energy does not survive an inelastic collision
In a two-stage problem (a collision followed by a swing, a slide or a fall), you cannot use kinetic energy conservation across the collision unless it is elastic. Use momentum across the collision and energy before or after it.
Exam tip
Discussing elastic and inelastic collisions
"Discuss the differences" needs both sides: in both types total momentum is conserved; in elastic collisions total kinetic energy is also conserved, while in inelastic collisions some is transformed into thermal energy, sound and deformation. Give an example of each and, if data are given, show the kinetic energy calculation that decides it.
Summary
Momentum is conserved in every collision and explosion of an isolated system.
Elastic: total kinetic energy conserved. Inelastic: total kinetic energy decreases. Perfectly inelastic: the objects stick together.
Test with before and after; kinetic energy is a scalar, so add the terms.
In explosions total kinetic energy increases, supplied by stored energy.
In two-stage problems, use momentum across the collision and energy for the motion before or after it.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 4 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.