Lesson 6 of 10 · 18 min

Isolation, gene flow and speciation

Explain how geographic, temporal and spatial isolation reduce gene flow, and how that leads to allopatric, sympatric and parapatric speciation, including the role of green corridors.

What you will be able to do

  • Explain why speciation needs gene flow between populations to be reduced or stopped.
  • Describe geographic, temporal and spatial isolation and how each reduces gene flow.
  • Distinguish allopatric, sympatric and parapatric speciation and classify examples.
  • Evaluate green corridors as a way to maintain gene flow between habitat fragments.

A species, in the biological species concept, is a group of populations whose members can interbreed in nature to produce fertile offspring, and cannot do so with other groups. New species form when one group of populations splits into two that no longer exchange genes.

The key word is gene flow. While alleles move freely between two populations, they stay one gene pool. Cut the flow, and each population's allele frequencies change independently by mutation, drift and selection. Given enough time they become so different that, even if they meet again, they cannot or do not interbreed: they are reproductively isolated, and speciation is complete.

The general route to a new species

  1. Isolation

    Something reduces or stops gene flow between parts of a population.

  2. Independent change

    Each group accumulates different mutations, drifts by chance, and is selected by its own environment.

  3. Divergence

    Allele frequencies, then phenotypes (body form, breeding season, courtship, chromosomes), become different.

  4. Reproductive isolation

    The groups can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring, even if they come into contact. They are separate species.

The syllabus names three kinds of isolation that reduce gene flow in the first place.

Isolation that reduces gene flow
IsolationWhat separates the populationsExample
GeographicA physical barrier: a sea, a mountain range, a river, a desert, cleared landSnapping shrimp on the Pacific and Caribbean sides of Panama, separated when the isthmus closed about 3 million years ago
TemporalBreeding at different times (season, time of day or year) in the same placeTwo palms on Lord Howe Island that flower weeks apart
SpatialNo barrier, but distance or different habitats within the range mean individuals mostly mate with near neighboursA grass growing on contaminated mine soil next to ordinary pasture

Key idea

Three types of speciation

  • Allopatric speciation ("other homeland"): populations are separated by a geographical barrier, so gene flow stops completely, and they diverge on either side.
  • Sympatric speciation ("same homeland"): a new species arises within the range of the parent species, with no barrier. Gene flow is cut by something other than geography: a sudden change in chromosome number (polyploidy, common in plants), different breeding times, or a shift to a new habitat or host within the same area.
  • Parapatric speciation ("beside homeland"): populations are next to each other along an environmental gradient, with a narrow zone of contact. Gene flow is reduced but not stopped, and strong selection in the different habitats drives divergence across the boundary.
Interactive

Cut the gene flow

A barrier forms at generation 20. Watch the gene flow between the groups fall and their mean trait values drift apart. Then try temporal and spatial isolation.

Allopatric speciation is the most common route in animals. When the Isthmus of Panama closed about 3 million years ago, it split populations of snapping shrimp (Alpheus) into Pacific and Caribbean halves. Nancy Knowlton and her colleagues found that when shrimp of these sister pairs from opposite sides are put together today, they mostly fail to mate. Closer to home, rising seas at the end of the last ice age flooded the land bridge between Tasmania and the mainland, and many Tasmanian populations have been geographically isolated since.

Sympatric speciation by temporal isolation. Lord Howe Island, 600 km off the New South Wales coast, is only about 15 km² in area, too small for populations of a palm to be separated geographically. Yet it has two endemic sister species of Howea palm. Howea forsteriana, the kentia palm, grows mainly on lime-rich calcareous soils and flowers several weeks earlier than Howea belmoreana, which grows on volcanic soils. Because their flowering times barely overlap, pollen rarely passes between them. Savolainen and colleagues (2006) concluded that the two diverged on the island itself: sympatric speciation, with the flowering-time difference cutting gene flow.

Sympatric speciation by polyploidy can happen in a single generation. If an error in meiosis makes diploid gametes and two of them fuse, the tetraploid offspring cannot produce fertile offspring with the diploid parents (their hybrids are triploid and sterile), but can with other tetraploids. Many flowering plants arose through polyploidy; bread wheat, for example, is a polyploid descended from hybrids of three wild grass species.

Parapatric speciation. Sweet vernal grass (Anthoxanthum odoratum) grows over the boundary between the toxic soil of old metal-mine workings and normal pasture in Wales. Plants on the mine soil are heavy-metal tolerant; plants a few metres away in the pasture are not. Pollen still blows across the boundary, but strong selection keeps the two apart: non-tolerant plants die on the mine soil, and tolerant plants grow less well than non-tolerant ones in the pasture. The tolerant plants near the boundary have also evolved to flower at a slightly different time, which reduces gene flow further. The populations are diverging side by side.

A population of beetles feeds on one species of tree. A mutation lets a few beetles feed on a second tree species growing in the same forest. Beetles mate on the tree they feed on, and over many generations the two groups stop interbreeding. Which type of speciation is this?

Choose one answer

Worked example

Classify three cases of speciation

  • Complex familiar

For each case, identify the type of isolation and the type of speciation, and explain how gene flow was reduced.

(a) A river changes course and splits the range of a flightless beetle. After 100 000 years, beetles from the two sides no longer mate when brought together. (b) Two populations of a frog live in the same swamp. One population breeds in early spring and the other in late summer. Over time they become separate species. (c) A grass grows across the boundary between salty coastal soil and ordinary soil. Salt-tolerant plants on the coast and non-tolerant plants inland become separate species, with a narrow zone of hybrids between them.

3 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Barrier between them: geographic, allopatric.

  2. Same area, cut by breeding time, habitat or polyploidy: sympatric.

  3. Neighbouring populations along a gradient, contact zone: parapatric.

  4. Always say how gene flow is reduced.

Watch out for

  • Calling (b) allopatric because the frogs are "separated". They are separated in time, not space.

  • Stopping at "isolation" without saying reproductive isolation evolved.

Common mistake

Isolation is not the end point

Geographic isolation alone does not make a new species. Two populations of a frog on either side of a river are still one species if they can interbreed when they meet. Speciation is complete only when reproductive isolation has evolved. In an answer, describe the whole chain: isolation → no gene flow → different mutations, drift and selection → divergence → reproductive isolation.

Green corridors. Clearing land for farms, roads and suburbs breaks habitat into fragments. To a koala or a squirrel glider, a cleared paddock or a six-lane road can be a barrier as effective as a river. Each fragment's population becomes small and isolated: gene flow stops, genetic drift erodes diversity, and inbreeding rises.

A green corridor reconnects fragments with a strip of native vegetation, or a crossing structure such as an underpass, a vegetated overpass, rope bridges and glider poles. In Brisbane, the Compton Road fauna crossings link bushland on both sides of a busy road and have been monitored for years with cameras and track pads.

Showing that animals use a corridor is not the same as showing it maintains gene flow. The strongest evidence is genetic: individuals that breed on the far side, or allele frequencies that stay similar in connected fragments while those in unconnected fragments drift apart.

Which observation would be the strongest evidence that a corridor maintains gene flow between two fragments of forest?

Choose one answer

Summary

  • Speciation needs gene flow between populations to stop; then mutation, drift and selection make them diverge until they are reproductively isolated.

  • Geographic isolation: a physical barrier. Temporal isolation: breeding at different times. Spatial isolation: distance or different habitats within the range limit who mates with whom.

  • Allopatric speciation follows a geographical barrier (Panama snapping shrimp).

  • Sympatric speciation happens within one area, through polyploidy, different breeding times or a habitat shift (Lord Howe Island Howea palms).

  • Parapatric speciation happens in neighbouring populations along a gradient with reduced gene flow across a contact zone (mine-soil grass).

  • Green corridors reconnect habitat fragments; genetic data, not just sightings, show whether they maintain gene flow.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 6 of 100% read

Save your progress with a free account