Lesson 5 of 10 · 16 min

Divergent, convergent, parallel and coevolution

Describe how accumulated microevolution produces macroevolution, and identify divergent, convergent and parallel evolution and coevolution from examples and evidence.

What you will be able to do

  • Describe how macroevolution results from the accumulation of microevolutionary changes.
  • Describe divergent evolution and adaptive radiation, with homologous structures as evidence.
  • Distinguish convergent from parallel evolution using relatedness and starting point.
  • Describe coevolution between interacting species.

Microevolution is a change in allele frequencies you can measure in a decade. Macroevolution is the origin of kangaroos, whales and flowering plants. There is no separate mechanism linking them: once two populations stop exchanging genes, mutation, selection and drift act on each separately, and the small differences add up generation after generation. Over thousands of generations they become separate species; over millions of years the lineages descended from them become different genera, families and orders.

Looking back at those lineages, biologists see four recurring patterns.

Definition

Divergent evolution

Divergent evolution: related species become more different from each other as their populations adapt to different environments and ways of life. When a single ancestral group diverges rapidly into many species filling many niches, it is an adaptive radiation.

Divergent evolution produces homologous structures: the same basic structure, inherited from the common ancestor, modified for different functions.

The marsupial radiation. As Australia separated from Antarctica and drifted north, its marsupials evolved in isolation. From a common ancestor they diverged into grazing kangaroos, browsing koalas, burrowing wombats, gliding and climbing possums, insect-eating bandicoots and carnivorous dasyurids such as the quolls and the Tasmanian devil. Their shared ancestry shows in homologous structures. Kangaroos, wallabies, koalas, wombats and possums all have the second and third toes of the hind foot fused together (syndactyly), used for grooming, although the feet themselves are built for hopping, climbing or digging.

A simplified cladogram of the Australian marsupial radiation, with two placental mammals as the outgroup. Many species diverged from one ancestral marsupial lineage.

Definition

Convergent evolution

Convergent evolution: distantly related species evolve similar traits independently, because they face similar selection pressures in similar ways of life. The similar traits are analogous structures: they do the same job but were not inherited from a common ancestor that had them.

The thylacine (Thylacinus cynocephalus), the marsupial predator driven to extinction in Tasmania mainly by hunting (the last known animal died in 1936), had a skull remarkably like a wolf's: long snout, large canines, shearing cheek teeth. Yet marsupials and placental mammals last shared an ancestor about 160 million years ago. The thylacine's closest relatives are the Tasmanian devil and the quolls, not dogs. Similar selection pressures (hunting large prey on open ground) produced similar skulls from different starting points.

Other Australian examples: the sugar glider and the northern hemisphere's flying squirrels, the marsupial moles and the golden moles of Africa, and the echidna and placental anteaters (long snout and sticky tongue). Wings in birds, bats and insects are analogous on an even larger scale.

The thylacine and the wolf (highlighted) look alike but sit in different clades. The similarity is convergent, not inherited.

Definition

Parallel evolution

Parallel evolution: related lineages that start from similar ancestral traits independently evolve the same changes in the same direction, often through the same genes.

When the ice retreated at the end of the last glacial period, marine three-spined sticklebacks (Gasterosteus aculeatus) colonised many separate freshwater lakes. Marine sticklebacks have a full row of bony armour plates. In lake after lake, the freshwater populations independently evolved reduced armour, in most cases through the same allele of one gene (Eda), which was already present at low frequency in the sea.

Convergent

  • Species are distantly related.
  • They start from different ancestral traits.
  • Similar traits arise by different developmental routes.
  • Example: thylacine and wolf skulls; bird and bat wings.

Parallel

  • Species (or populations) are closely related.
  • They start from similar ancestral traits.
  • The same change happens independently, often in the same genes.
  • Example: armour loss in lake sticklebacks.

Note

Where to draw the line

Convergent and parallel evolution are ends of a continuum, and textbooks place some examples differently (some call the marsupial and placental look-alikes parallel, because both start from a mammal). In an answer, justify your choice: how closely related are the species, and how similar were their starting points?

Five lakes were colonised separately by one species of marine fish. In every lake, the population independently evolved a paler body, each time through a mutation in the same pigment gene. Which pattern is this?

Choose one answer

Definition

Coevolution

Coevolution: two or more species evolve in response to each other. Each is a selection pressure on the other, so a change in one selects for a change in the other: predator and prey, host and parasite, flowering plant and pollinator.

Rabbits and myxoma virus in Australia. Myxoma virus was released in 1950 to control European rabbits. At first it killed more than 99 % of infected rabbits. Within a few years, strains that killed more slowly had taken over in the field. A rabbit that lives longer with the infection is bitten by more mosquitoes, so a less lethal strain is passed on more: selection on the virus. At the same time, rabbits with alleles for resistance survived and bred, and the population's resistance rose: selection on the host. Frank Fenner and his colleagues tracked both sides for decades, and later work found that the virus then evolved new ways to overcome the rabbits' resistance. Each species keeps changing because the other does.

Flowers and their pollinators coevolve too. Many Australian plants pollinated by honeyeaters, such as some grevilleas and kangaroo paws, have red or orange tubular flowers with plenty of nectar, matched to the birds' long beaks and brush-tipped tongues.

Interactive

Four patterns

Step through the four patterns. For each, ask: are the species closely or distantly related, and are they becoming more alike or less alike?

Match each example to the pattern of evolution it shows.

Worked example

Rabbits and myxoma virus as coevolution

  • Complex unfamiliar

Myxoma virus was released in Australia in 1950 to control European rabbits. Biologists sampled the virus in the field and tested wild rabbits with a standard strain of the virus each year. The data below are illustrative, following the pattern Frank Fenner's team recorded.

YearField samples that were the most lethal strain (%)Wild rabbits killed by the standard test strain (%)
195110090
19533085
19551060
1958530

The virus is spread between rabbits by mosquitoes, which bite live rabbits. Use the data to explain why this is an example of coevolution. (5 marks)

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Describe the trend in each species with figures from the data.

  2. Explain each change as natural selection with the other species as the pressure.

  3. Conclude: reciprocal change between interacting species is coevolution.

Watch out for

  • Explaining only one side. Coevolution needs both species to change in response to each other.

  • Saying the virus "chose" to become less lethal to keep its host alive.

Common mistake

Similar does not mean related

Do not use a shared appearance as evidence of close relationship. Analogous structures (similar function, independent origin) come from convergence; only homologous structures and shared DNA sequences show common ancestry. The thylacine looks like a wolf but is genetically far closer to a kangaroo.

Summary

  • Macroevolution is microevolution accumulated: once populations stop exchanging genes, small changes add up to new species and new groups.

  • Divergent evolution: related species become more different; a rapid burst of it is an adaptive radiation (the Australian marsupials). It produces homologous structures.

  • Convergent evolution: distantly related species become alike under similar selection pressures (thylacine and wolf). It produces analogous structures.

  • Parallel evolution: related lineages from similar starting points make the same changes independently (stickleback armour).

  • Coevolution: interacting species evolve in response to each other (rabbits and myxoma virus; flowers and pollinators).

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 5 of 100% read

Save your progress with a free account