Lesson 8 of 10 · 18 min
Comparative genomics and the molecular clock
Explain how comparing genomes provides evidence for evolution, use conserved sequences as a molecular clock to date divergence, and describe how BLAST and sequence databases are used.
What you will be able to do
- Describe a scientific theory and the lines of evidence that support the theory of evolution.
- Explain how comparative genomics provides evidence for common ancestry.
- Explain what a conserved sequence is and why it changes slowly.
- Calibrate a molecular clock and use it to estimate when two lineages diverged, stating its assumptions.
- Describe how BLAST and sequence databases are used, including to track viruses and human migration.
Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace proposed evolution by natural selection in 1858, without knowing what genes were. Every new kind of evidence since then could have contradicted them. When DNA sequencing arrived, it gave the strongest test yet: if all life shares common ancestors, then species should share DNA sequences, and the more recently two species diverged, the more alike their sequences should be. That is exactly what genomes show.
Definition
A scientific theory
A scientific theory is an explanation of the natural world that has been repeatedly tested and corroborated by evidence. It is not a guess. Theories are contested, refined or replaced when new evidence challenges them, or when a new theory explains more.
The theory of evolution has been refined many times: Mendel's genetics were joined to natural selection in the "modern synthesis" of the 1930s and 1940s, and molecular biology later showed that many DNA changes are neutral and spread by drift. The core idea, descent with modification from common ancestors, has survived every test.
| Field | What it shows | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Palaeontology | Fossils in rock layers show change over time and transitional forms | Fossil whales with legs; the 3.5-billion-year-old stromatolites of the Pilbara |
| Biogeography | Species are distributed where their ancestors could reach; island species resemble the nearest mainland | The marsupial radiation in isolated Australia |
| Developmental biology | Related animals share embryonic stages and the genes that control them | Pharyngeal arches in all vertebrate embryos; HOX genes setting the body plan |
| Morphology | Homologous and vestigial structures reveal shared ancestry | The pentadactyl limb; fused hind toes in kangaroos, koalas and possums |
| Genetics | All life shares DNA and the genetic code; sequence similarity matches relatedness | Human and chimpanzee DNA about 99 % identical base by base |
Comparative genomics compares whole genomes, or the same genes, across species. Three findings support common ancestry:
- Every organism uses DNA and almost the same genetic code. A gene from a jellyfish can be read correctly by a bacterium. One code, shared by all life, is what you would expect if it was inherited from one ancestor.
- Species share genes, and closer relatives share more similar sequences. Aligning the human and chimpanzee genomes shows about 1.2 % of bases differ; adding the stretches inserted or deleted in one lineage brings the difference to about 4 % (Chimpanzee Sequencing and Analysis Consortium, 2005). Human and mouse sequences differ far more.
- Shared mistakes. Humans, apes and monkeys carry the same broken copy of a gene for making vitamin C (a pseudogene), with the same disabling mutations. A shared error is very hard to explain except by inheritance from a common ancestor.
Definition
Conserved sequences
A conserved sequence is a DNA, RNA or protein sequence that has changed very little over long periods of evolution. Conserved sequences are usually in genes whose products are essential, such as cytochrome c (in the electron transport chain), histones, ribosomal RNA and the homeobox of HOX genes. Most mutations in them make the product fail, so individuals carrying those mutations die or reproduce less: negative selection removes them. The few changes that persist build up slowly and steadily.
Human cytochrome c, 104 amino acids long, is identical in chimpanzees, and yeast cytochrome c is still recognisably the same protein, though it differs from ours at more than 40 positions.
Why does the sequence of a histone gene change much more slowly over evolutionary time than most non-coding DNA?
The molecular clock. If changes in a sequence build up at a roughly constant rate, the number of differences between two species is proportional to the time since they diverged. To read the clock you need a calibration: a pair of species whose divergence date is known from fossils.
Dating a divergence with a molecular clock
Calibrate the rate
Count the differences for the pair you want to date
Divide by the rate
Check it is reasonable
More differences should give an older date. Round to the precision of the data, and state the assumption of a constant rate.
Worked example
Date a divergence with a molecular clock
Fossils show that species A and B diverged from a common ancestor 30 million years ago. The two species differ at 18 positions in a gene. Species A and species C differ at 42 positions in the same gene.
(a) Calculate the rate of change of the gene. (b) Estimate when species A and C diverged. (c) State two assumptions of this method.
Step 1: Calibrate the rate
Rate differences per million years.
Step 2: Estimate the divergence time
Time million years.
Step 3: Check it is reasonable
A and C differ at more positions than A and B (), so they should have diverged earlier: 70 is older than 30.
Step 4: State the assumptions
The gene changes at a constant rate over time and in all three lineages; the fossil date of 30 million years is accurate (and no positions have changed twice, hiding a difference).
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 0.6 differences per million years. (b) About 70 million years ago. (c) A constant rate of change in all lineages; an accurate fossil calibration date.
Method
Rate calibration differences calibration time.
Time differences rate.
More differences means an older divergence; state the constant-rate assumption.
Watch out for
Multiplying the differences by the rate instead of dividing.
Halving the time because there are two lineages, after calibrating with a pair.
Two species of frog whose ancestors were split by a mountain range that fossils date to 25 million years ago differ at 20 positions in a gene. A third species differs from the first at 52 positions in the same gene. Estimate how long ago the third species and the first diverged.
Why not halve anything?
After two lineages split, mutations build up in both of them, so the differences between them grow at twice the rate of change in either one. Some books therefore quote a rate "per lineage" and double it when they compare a pair. If you calibrate with the differences between a pair and use the rate on another pair, the factor of 2 cancels, and you can ignore it. Just never mix a per-lineage rate with a between-pair count.
Common mistake
Assumptions of the molecular clock
A molecular clock estimate is only as good as its assumptions:
- the rate of change is constant over time and the same in both lineages (it varies with generation time and between genes);
- the fossil calibration date is accurate;
- differences have not been hidden by two changes at the same position (more likely over very long times).
Use fast-changing sequences (mitochondrial DNA) to date recent splits, and conserved sequences (cytochrome c, ribosomal RNA) for very old ones, before the fast clock "saturates".
The calibration pair sets the slope of the line. Compare a fast gene and a conserved gene in the second view.
BLAST and the databases. Sequencing is now so cheap that public databases such as GenBank hold hundreds of millions of DNA sequences, free to anyone. The Basic Local Alignment Search Tool (BLAST) takes a query sequence and searches the database for the most similar sequences, ranked by how many positions match (percentage identity) and how unlikely the match is by chance. Biologists use it to identify the species a sample came from (fish fillets sold under the wrong name, ivory, bushmeat), to find the same gene in other species, and to collect sequences for building trees. Bioinformatics, the computing that handles all this data, has turned up evidence for evolutionary relationships that anatomy alone never could, such as whales being most closely related to hippopotamuses.
Tracking viruses. RNA viruses mutate quickly, so each infection chain accumulates its own differences. During the COVID-19 pandemic, laboratories around the world sequenced SARS-CoV-2 genomes and shared them within days. Building phylogenetic trees from those genomes showed where new variants arose, how they spread between countries, and which clusters of cases were linked, which guided public health responses. Influenza viruses are tracked the same way each year to choose the strains for the next vaccine.
Tracking human migration. Human genetic diversity is highest in Africa and falls with distance from it, a pattern of repeated founder effects as small groups moved on. Mitochondrial DNA (inherited from the mother), the Y chromosome (from the father) and whole genomes, including DNA from ancient remains, trace these movements. Genomic studies of Aboriginal Australians indicate that their ancestors were part of an early migration out of Africa and have lived in Sahul (Australia and New Guinea) for about 50 000 years or more, with populations across the continent then diverging from each other over tens of thousands of years (Malaspinas and colleagues, 2016).
Summary
A scientific theory is a repeatedly tested explanation, refined as evidence grows. Evolution is supported by palaeontology, biogeography, developmental biology, morphology and genetics.
Comparative genomics supports common ancestry: one genetic code, shared genes whose similarity matches relatedness, and shared mutations such as pseudogenes.
Conserved sequences change slowly because negative selection removes most mutations in essential genes.
Molecular clock: rate = differences ÷ calibration time; time = differences ÷ rate. It assumes a constant rate and an accurate fossil calibration.
BLAST searches sequence databases for similar sequences; bioinformatics identifies species, tracks virus variants and traces human migration.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.