Lesson 3 of 10 · 15 min
Natural selection and the three types of selection
Explain natural selection as a chain from heritable variation to changed allele frequencies, and identify stabilising, directional and disruptive selection from phenotype distributions.
What you will be able to do
- Explain natural selection in terms of variation, inheritance, a selection pressure, differential survival and reproduction, and changing allele frequencies.
- Define fitness and selection pressure.
- Identify stabilising, directional and disruptive selection from graphs of a phenotype before and after selection.
Cane toads have spread across Queensland and into northern New South Wales since 1935, and their skin toxin kills many native snakes that swallow one. Ben Phillips and Richard Shine compared museum specimens of the red-bellied black snake (Pseudechis porphyriacus) from areas toads had occupied for decades with snakes from areas toads had not reached. In the toad areas the snakes had smaller heads relative to their bodies (Phillips and Shine, 2004). A snake with a small gape cannot swallow a toad big enough to kill it.
No snake shrank its head on purpose. The pattern is what natural selection predicts.
How natural selection works
Variation
Individuals in a population differ in their phenotypes (here, head size relative to body size). The variation comes from different alleles, made by mutation and shuffled by meiosis and fertilisation.
Inheritance
Some of that variation is heritable, so offspring tend to resemble their parents.
More offspring than can survive
Populations produce more young than the environment can support, so not all survive to reproduce.
A selection pressure
Something in the environment affects survival or reproduction: here, a toxic prey animal. Snakes with large heads that swallow large toads die.
Differential survival and reproduction
Individuals with the favoured phenotype (small relative head size) survive and reproduce more. They have greater fitness.
Changed allele frequencies
They pass on the alleles for that phenotype, so those alleles become more common in the next generation. Over many generations the population becomes adapted.
Definition
Selection pressure and fitness
A selection pressure is any factor that affects which individuals survive and reproduce: a predator, a disease, food supply, climate, a toxin, an insecticide, competition for mates.
Fitness is an individual's ability to survive and reproduce in its environment, compared with others in the population. An individual that lives long but leaves no offspring has a fitness of zero.
Insecticide resistance evolves in a population of cotton aphids. Put the stages in order.
Common mistake
Organisms do not change because they need to
"The aphids became resistant to survive the spray" and "the snakes grew smaller heads so they would not eat toads" describe an individual changing in response to need. That is not how it works. The resistant aphids already had the allele; the spray killed the others. A characteristic acquired during life, such as a muscle built by exercise, is not passed on in the DNA.
Three types of selection. Plot the number of individuals against a phenotype that varies continuously, such as body mass or beak depth, and you usually get a bell-shaped curve. Selection changes the shape of that curve in one of three ways, depending on which phenotypes are favoured.
Stabilising selection: both extremes are selected against, so the curve narrows around the same mean. Human birth mass is the classic case: very small and very large babies historically had lower survival.
Directional selection: one extreme is favoured, so the mean shifts in that direction. Here larger values are favoured, as deeper beaks were in ground finches after a drought; in toad-invaded areas, selection on snakes ran the other way, towards smaller relative head size.
Disruptive selection: both extremes are favoured and the intermediate phenotype is selected against, so the curve can split into two peaks. In the African black-bellied seedcracker, birds with small bills crack soft seeds and birds with large bills crack hard seeds; intermediate bills do neither well.
| Type | Favoured | Selected against | Effect on the distribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stabilising | Intermediate phenotypes | Both extremes | Same mean; narrower (less variation) |
| Directional | One extreme | The other extreme | Mean shifts towards the favoured extreme |
| Disruptive | Both extremes | Intermediate phenotypes | Same overall centre; wider, often two peaks |
Worked example
Identify the type of selection from a graph
Medium ground finches on a Galápagos island eat seeds. During a severe drought, small soft seeds ran out and only large, hard seeds remained. The graph shows the beak depth of the population before the drought and of the next generation (illustrative values). Identify and justify the type of selection.
Beak depth before the drought (dashed) and in the next generation (solid).
Step 1: Describe the change
The curve keeps the same shape and spread, but its peak (the mean) moves from about 9.4 mm to about 9.9 mm.
Step 2: Match the pattern
A shift of the mean towards one extreme, with no narrowing or splitting, is directional selection.
Step 3: Link to the selection pressure
Only large, hard seeds were available. Birds with deeper beaks could crack them, survived and reproduced; birds with shallow beaks starved. Beak depth is heritable, so the next generation had deeper beaks on average.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Directional selection: the mean beak depth shifted from about 9.4 to 9.9 mm because the drought favoured deep beaks that could crack the remaining hard seeds.
Method
Same mean, narrower: stabilising. Mean shifted: directional. Two peaks or wider with the middle lost: disruptive.
Link the favoured phenotype to the selection pressure in the context.
Watch out for
Saying individual birds grew deeper beaks during the drought. The change is between generations.
A population of grasshoppers lives on a hillside covered in a mix of pale dry grass and dark burnt patches. Birds easily spot grasshoppers of intermediate colour, but both pale and dark grasshoppers are well camouflaged. Which type of selection is acting on body colour?
Worked example
Explain the evolution of antibiotic resistance
A patient with a Staphylococcus aureus infection is treated with an antibiotic. Within the patient, the infection at first clears, then returns, and the returning bacteria are resistant to the antibiotic. Explain, using the theory of natural selection, how the bacterial population became resistant. (4 marks)
Step 1: Variation already existed
Before treatment, the bacterial population varied. A few bacteria carried an allele for resistance, produced earlier by a random mutation (or gained from another bacterium on a plasmid).
The resistance did not arise because of the antibiotic. It was already present at low frequency.
Step 2: The selection pressure
The antibiotic is the selection pressure: it kills susceptible bacteria.
Step 3: Differential survival and reproduction
Resistant bacteria survived and divided, while most susceptible bacteria died, so the resistant bacteria had greater fitness.
Step 4: Inheritance
Bacteria reproduce by binary fission, so the daughter cells inherit the resistance allele.
Step 5: Change in allele frequency
Over many generations (bacteria can divide every 30 minutes or so), the frequency of the resistance allele rose until almost the whole population was resistant.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
A random mutation had already given a few bacteria a resistance allele. The antibiotic killed susceptible bacteria (selection pressure), while resistant ones survived and reproduced, passing the allele to their offspring. Over many generations the resistance allele frequency rose until the population was resistant.
Method
Variation from mutation, before the pressure.
Selection pressure kills or reduces reproduction of some phenotypes.
Favoured individuals survive, reproduce and pass on the allele.
Allele frequency rises over generations.
Watch out for
Writing "the bacteria became resistant to survive" or "the antibiotic caused the mutation".
Saying the patient became resistant. The bacterial population evolved.
Exam tip
An "explain natural selection" answer
A full-marks answer names the trait and the selection pressure, then runs the whole chain in the context given: variation in the trait exists (from mutation), the trait is heritable, the selection pressure removes some phenotypes, individuals with the favoured phenotype survive and reproduce more, they pass on the allele, so its frequency increases over generations. Missing the last two links is the most common way to drop marks.
Summary
Natural selection needs heritable variation, more offspring than can survive, and a selection pressure.
Individuals with favoured phenotypes have higher fitness: they survive and reproduce more and pass on their alleles, so those alleles become more common over generations.
Variation comes first, from random mutation; the selection pressure does not cause the mutation.
Stabilising selection favours the intermediate and narrows the curve; directional selection favours one extreme and shifts the mean; disruptive selection favours both extremes and can split the curve in two.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.