Lesson 9 of 10 · 18 min
Cladograms, phylograms and sequence data
Read relatedness from cladograms and phylograms using most recent common ancestors, and infer relationships from molecular sequence data by counting differences.
What you will be able to do
- Identify the parts of a phylogenetic tree: tips, nodes, root, branches, clades and sister groups.
- Infer relatedness from a cladogram using most recent common ancestors and shared derived traits.
- Read divergence times or amounts of change from a phylogram.
- Count differences between aligned sequences and use a difference table to infer relatedness.
A phylogenetic tree is a hypothesis about who is descended from whom. Every tree is read the same way: follow the branches back from the living species at the tips to the points where they join. Those points are common ancestors, and how recently two species share one is what "closely related" means.
A cladogram of eight chordates. Each numbered tick marks a derived trait shared by every species whose branches lead on from it. The lancelet is the outgroup.
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Tip (terminal taxon) | A species or group at the end of a branch, usually living today |
| Node | A branching point: the most recent common ancestor of everything above it |
| Root | The common ancestor of every taxon on the tree |
| Clade | A common ancestor and all of its descendants; cut one branch and everything above it is a clade |
| Sister taxa | Two taxa whose closest relative is each other: they share a node no other taxon shares |
| Outgroup | A taxon outside the group being studied, used to tell ancestral traits from derived ones |
| Derived trait | A trait that appeared in the common ancestor of a clade and is shared by its members (a synapomorphy) |
Key idea
Reading relatedness
Two taxa are more closely related the more recent their most recent common ancestor: the closer to the tips their branches join. On a cladogram this also means they share more derived traits.
In the cladogram above, the kangaroo is more closely related to the human than to the platypus, because the kangaroo and human share a more recent common ancestor (marked by live birth). The platypus is equally related to the kangaroo and the human.
Using the cladogram, which statement is correct?
Worked example
Read a cladogram of land plants
The cladogram shows five land plants and the derived traits that define their clades.
(a) Which derived trait evolved first? (b) Which plant is most closely related to the eucalypt? (c) How many of the derived traits shown does the pine share with the eucalypt? (d) A student says the fern is more closely related to the pine than to the wattle, because the fern and pine are next to each other. Evaluate the claim.
A cladogram of five land plants, with the moss as the outgroup.
Step 1: (a) Earliest trait
The trait closest to the root is shared by the most taxa: vascular tissue (fern, pine, wattle, eucalypt).
Step 2: (b) Closest relative
The eucalypt's branch joins the wattle's at the most recent node, the one defined by flowers.
Step 3: (c) Shared traits
The pine and eucalypt share vascular tissue and seeds: 2 of the traits shown. Flowers evolved after the pine lineage branched off.
Step 4: (d) Evaluate the claim
The claim is wrong. The fern's branch joins the pine, wattle and eucalypt all at the same node (vascular tissue), so the fern is equally related to the pine and the wattle. Names next to each other mean nothing; only where branches join counts.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Vascular tissue. (b) The wattle. (c) Two: vascular tissue and seeds. (d) Incorrect: the fern shares one common ancestor with the pine, wattle and eucalypt, so it is equally related to the pine and the wattle.
Method
Traits nearer the root evolved earlier and are shared by more taxa.
Relatedness is set by the most recent common ancestor.
Ignore the left-to-right order of names.
Watch out for
Reading relatedness from the order of the names.
Counting traits on branches that lead away from one of the two plants.
Common mistake
Rotating a node changes nothing
The branches at any node can be swung around like a mobile without changing the tree. Drawn as (Human, Kangaroo) or (Kangaroo, Human), the relationships are identical. Never infer relatedness from which names sit side by side, or think a species near the top of the list is "more evolved". Every living species at the tips has been evolving for exactly as long as every other.
Each derived trait defines a clade. Tap taxa to see their most recent common ancestor and the traits they share.
Phylograms. On a cladogram, branch lengths mean nothing: only the branching order counts. On a phylogram, branch lengths are drawn to scale, showing the amount of genetic change or, when calibrated, time. A scale bar or axis says which. (Specialists call a tree scaled to time a chronogram; this course, like the syllabus, calls both phylograms.)
A phylogram of the apes with branch lengths in time (approximate divergence dates).
From the phylogram, how many million years ago did the most recent common ancestor of humans and gorillas live?
Trees from sequences. Modern trees are built mostly from DNA and protein sequences. The sequences are first aligned so that the same positions line up. Then you count the positions where each pair differs: fewer differences means a more recent common ancestor. The illustrative sequences below are 20 bases of the same gene in four species.
| Species | Positions 1–20 |
|---|---|
| W | ATGTC ACAAG TTCCG ACTGG |
| X | ATGTC ACAAG TTCCA ACTAG |
| Y | ATGGC ACAAA TTCCA ACCGG |
| Z | ATAGC TCTAG TGCGA ATTGA |
How many positions differ between species W and species Y?
Worked example
Infer relatedness from aligned sequences
The table gives 20 aligned bases of the same gene in four species (illustrative).
| Species | Positions 1–20 |
|---|---|
| W | ATGTC ACAAG TTCCG ACTGG |
| X | ATGTC ACAAG TTCCA ACTAG |
| Y | ATGGC ACAAA TTCCA ACCGG |
| Z | ATAGC TCTAG TGCGA ATTGA |
(a) Construct a table of the number of differences between each pair. (b) Identify the two most closely related species. (c) Describe the tree the data support.
Step 1: Compare W and X
They differ at positions 15 (G/A) and 19 (G/A): 2.
Step 2: Compare the other pairs
W–Y: positions 4, 10, 15, 18: 4. X–Y: positions 4, 10, 18, 19: 4. Z differs from each of W, X and Y at 9 positions.
Work one group of five at a time and mark each difference, so none is missed.
Step 3: Write the difference table
W X Y Z W – 2 4 9 X 2 – 4 9 Y 4 4 – 9 Z 9 9 9 – Step 4: Identify the closest pair
W and X differ at only 2 positions, fewer than any other pair, so they share the most recent common ancestor.
Step 5: Describe the tree
W and X are sister species. Y joins them next (4 differences from each). Z joins last (9 from each), so Z diverged first. In Newick form: .
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) W–X 2, W–Y 4, X–Y 4, W–Z 9, X–Z 9, Y–Z 9. (b) W and X. (c) W and X are sisters, Y is their closest relative, and Z branched off first: (((W, X), Y), Z).
Method
Count differences for every pair, position by position.
Join the pair with the fewest differences first.
Add each remaining species in order of increasing difference.
Watch out for
Counting a position twice or skipping one: compare in small groups.
Saying W evolved from X. They share a common ancestor.
Exam tip
Justify with the data
When a question asks which species are most closely related, quote the evidence: "W and X differ at only 2 of 20 positions, fewer than any other pair, so they share the most recent common ancestor." On a tree, name the node or the shared derived trait. Say "share a more recent common ancestor", never "X evolved from W".
Trees and viruses. Because RNA viruses accumulate differences so quickly, a tree built from genomes collected during an outbreak shows who infected whom almost in real time. Samples on the same short branch belong to one chain of transmission; a new long branch with many changes flags a new variant. Public health teams used SARS-CoV-2 trees this way to tell whether a new case came from an existing cluster or a new arrival.
Summary
Tips are taxa, nodes are common ancestors, and a clade is an ancestor with all its descendants.
Relatedness is read from the most recent common ancestor: the more recently two branches join, the more closely related the taxa. On a cladogram they share more derived traits.
Rotating branches at a node changes nothing; the order of names is not evidence.
A cladogram shows branching order only; a phylogram's branch lengths show change or time to scale.
From aligned sequences, count the differences for each pair; the pair with the fewest shares the most recent common ancestor.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.