Lesson 7 of 10 · 13 min

Genetic diversity and the risk of extinction

Explain why populations with reduced genetic diversity face a higher risk of extinction, with the Tasmanian devil, the northern hairy-nosed wombat and genetic rescue as cases.

What you will be able to do

  • Describe how small population size, bottlenecks and isolation reduce genetic diversity.
  • Explain how reduced genetic diversity raises the risk of extinction through inbreeding and a reduced ability to adapt.
  • Apply these ideas to Australian cases, and describe how managers restore diversity.

In 1996 a photographer in north-east Tasmania took pictures of Tasmanian devils with large tumours on their faces. The disease, devil facial tumour disease (DFTD), turned out to be a cancer that spreads from devil to devil as living cells when they bite each other. It has since spread across most of the island, and devil numbers have fallen by roughly three-quarters or more in many areas.

A cancer that passes between individuals like an infection is extremely rare. Part of the reason it works in devils is that devils are genetically very alike.

Definition

Genetic diversity

Genetic diversity is the variety of alleles and genotypes in a population or species. It is measured by how many genes have more than one allele, how many alleles each has, and what proportion of individuals are heterozygous.

How diversity is lost. Three things you already know remove alleles from a population:

  • Genetic drift in a small population loses alleles by chance each generation, and lost alleles do not come back.
  • A bottleneck or a small founder group keeps only a sample of the original alleles.
  • Isolation cuts gene flow, so alleles lost by drift cannot be brought back from other populations.

Once a population is small, it also becomes inbred: relatives mate because there is little choice, so offspring are more often homozygous.

Expected heterozygosity remaining under genetic drift alone, as a proportion of the starting value, for three population sizes. The smaller the population, the faster diversity is lost.

Key idea

Why low diversity raises the risk of extinction

  1. Less ability to adapt. Natural selection can only act on existing variation. If a new disease, predator or climate arrives and no individual carries alleles that help, the whole population is vulnerable at once.
  2. Disease spreads more easily. Genetically similar individuals tend to be susceptible to the same pathogens, so one disease can affect almost all of them.
  3. Inbreeding depression. More homozygous offspring means harmful recessive alleles are expressed more often, lowering fertility, survival and growth.
  4. A vicious circle. Lower survival and reproduction make the population smaller still, which speeds up drift and inbreeding. Small, uniform populations can spiral down to extinction.

Select all the reasons a population with low genetic diversity is at greater risk of extinction.

Select all that apply.

Tasmanian devils. Devils have very low genetic diversity, probably because of population crashes long ago, including isolation in Tasmania when the sea level rose at the end of the last ice age. Diversity is especially low in the MHC genes, which code for the cell-surface markers the immune system uses to tell "self" from "non-self". Normally, cells from another individual would be recognised as foreign and destroyed. Because devils' MHC markers are so alike (and the tumour cells also display few MHC markers), the tumour cells are not rejected, and the cancer spreads.

Since 2003 the Save the Tasmanian Devil Program has kept disease-free insurance populations in captivity, on the mainland and on Maria Island, managed to keep as much genetic diversity as possible. There is good news too: studies of devil genomes before and after DFTD arrived found allele frequencies changing in genes linked to immune function, which suggests that natural selection is already acting on what diversity remains.

Interactive

A bottleneck

Twelve populations of 200 crash to 6 individuals for four generations, then recover. Look at how many lines lose or fix the allele during the crash.

The northern hairy-nosed wombat (Lasiorhinus krefftii) is one of the world's rarest mammals. Its only natural population, in Epping Forest National Park in central Queensland, fell to about 35 animals in the early 1980s. A predator-proof fence, supplementary water and food, and a second population started in 2009 at the Richard Underwood Nature Refuge near St George have helped it recover to more than 300 (Queensland Government, 2021). Its genetic diversity, however, stayed low: the bottleneck had already removed alleles that numbers alone cannot bring back.

Genetic rescue. The mountain pygmy possum (Burramys parvus) population at Mount Buller in Victoria had become small, isolated by ski-resort development and inbred. Conservationists moved a few males from a larger, more diverse population into it. The hybrid offspring were larger and survived and bred better, and the population grew rapidly (Weeks and colleagues, 2017). Bringing in new alleles is deliberate gene flow, which is exactly what green corridors provide naturally.

Worked example

Why devil facial tumour disease threatens Tasmanian devils

  • Complex unfamiliar

Tasmanian devils have very low genetic diversity, especially in their MHC genes, which code for the markers the immune system uses to recognise foreign cells. Devil facial tumour disease (DFTD) is a cancer passed between devils as living tumour cells when they bite.

(a) Explain why low genetic diversity has made devils especially vulnerable to DFTD. (b) Explain why low genetic diversity increases the long-term risk of extinction of the species. (c) Evaluate the strategy of keeping disease-free insurance populations in captivity. (6 marks)

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Link the specific gene (MHC) to the specific threat.

  2. General risks: reduced ability to adapt, shared susceptibility, inbreeding depression.

  3. Evaluate: strengths, limitations, then a judgement.

Watch out for

  • Saying the devils "cannot evolve resistance" at all. Selection is acting on the variation that remains.

Note

Uniform crops

The same risk applies to crops grown as clones. Every Cavendish banana plant is genetically identical, so a strain of the soil fungus that causes Panama disease (tropical race 4) can kill any of them. It was found on a farm in north Queensland in 2015 and is managed by strict quarantine, because ordinary Cavendish plants, all genetically identical, have no resistance to it.

The northern hairy-nosed wombat population has grown from about 35 to more than 300. Why does it still have low genetic diversity?

Choose one answer

Summary

  • Genetic diversity is the variety of alleles and genotypes in a population.

  • Drift in small populations, bottlenecks, founder events and isolation all reduce it; a recovered population does not regain lost alleles.

  • Low diversity raises extinction risk: less variation for selection to act on, shared susceptibility to disease, inbreeding depression, and a spiral of decline.

  • Tasmanian devils lack MHC diversity, which lets devil facial tumour disease spread as a transmissible cancer.

  • Managers restore or protect diversity with insurance populations, translocations (genetic rescue) and green corridors.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 7 of 100% read

Save your progress with a free account