Lesson 4 of 10 · 17 min
Selection pressures and allele frequency data
Analyse data on allele and genotype frequencies to decide the effect of a selection pressure, whether selection on an allele is positive or negative, and what a gene-pool simulation shows.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the effect of a selection pressure from a table or graph of allele frequencies.
- Recognise positive selection (an allele's frequency rises) and negative selection (it falls), and that the same allele can experience either.
- Analyse the genotypic changes in a gene-pool simulation with a selection pressure.
- Explain how human activities and changes in climate act as selection pressures.
Spray a crop with an insecticide and you kill most of the pests, but not all. If a few carry an allele that lets them survive, the spray has just become a selection pressure for that allele. Data on allele frequencies over time show it happening, and the shape of the data tells you which way and how fast.
Definition
Positive and negative selection
Positive selection for an allele: individuals carrying it survive and reproduce better, so its frequency rises over generations.
Negative selection against an allele (also called purifying selection): individuals carrying it survive and reproduce less well, so its frequency falls.
For a gene with two alleles, positive selection for one is negative selection against the other. Whether an allele is favoured depends on the environment: the same allele can be under positive selection in one place or time and negative selection in another.
Resistance allele (dominant) in a population of insects. Spraying stops at generation 40. Watch the slope of the graph before and after.
Frequency of an insecticide-resistance allele in a diamondback moth population (illustrative data). Spraying stopped after year 5.
Read the graph in two phases.
- Years 0–5 (spraying): the frequency of rises from 0.02 to 0.79, a change of . That is strong positive selection for . The rise is slow at first because there are so few resistant moths to breed, and fastest in the middle.
- Years 5–10 (no spraying): the frequency falls from 0.79 to 0.67, a change of . With no insecticide, resistance gives no advantage, and the resistance mechanism has a small cost, so is under weak negative selection. The fall is much slower than the rise, so resistance does not disappear quickly when spraying stops.
From the graph, calculate the change in the frequency of during the five years of spraying.
Worked example
Positive and negative selection for a resistance allele
Diamondback moths on a farm were genotyped for an insecticide-resistance gene ( resistant, dominant; susceptible). The farm sprayed for four years, then stopped.
| Year | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 (spraying starts) | 1 | 6 | 193 |
| 4 (spraying stops) | 72 | 88 | 40 |
| 10 | 58 | 92 | 50 |
Use the data to determine the effect of spraying on the moth population, and whether selection on was positive or negative before and after spraying stopped.
Step 1: Frequency of in each year
Each sample has , so . Year 0: . Year 4: . Year 10: .
Step 2: Changes
Years 0–4: . Years 4–10: .
Step 3: Interpret the spraying period
While spraying, the frequency of rose sharply: positive selection for (and negative selection against ). Susceptible moths were killed; moths carrying survived and bred.
Step 4: Interpret after spraying
After spraying stopped, fell slightly and slowly: weak negative selection against , suggesting resistance has a small cost when no insecticide is present.
Step 5: Comment on the conclusion
The trend is clear, but each figure is one sample of 200 from one farm. Repeated samples or more farms would show whether the small fall after year 4 is real or sampling variation.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The frequency of rose from 0.02 to 0.58 during spraying (positive selection for ), then fell to 0.52 over six years without spraying (weak negative selection against ). Spraying was a strong selection pressure for resistance.
Method
Calculate the allele frequency for each sample.
Find the change between samples and its sign.
Rise = positive selection for that allele; fall = negative selection.
Link each change to the selection pressure and comment on reliability.
Watch out for
Comparing the number of moths alone, which ignores the alleles in heterozygotes.
Calling the slow fall after spraying "no selection" without looking at the data.
A gene-pool simulation. You can model selection in the laboratory with beads. Each bead is an allele: say red beads are and white beads are . Drawing two beads at random makes one individual. To model a selection pressure that kills individuals before they breed, remove every white–white pair, put the alleles of the survivors back, and draw the next generation from them. Recording the genotypes each generation lets you analyse the change.
| Generation | Frequency of | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 13 | 25 | 12 | 0.49 |
| 1 | 22 | 23 | 5 | 0.33 |
| 2 | 28 | 19 | 3 | 0.25 |
| 3 | 31 | 17 | 2 | 0.21 |
| 4 | 34 | 15 | 1 | 0.17 |
Worked example
Analyse a bead simulation of selection
A class models selection against a recessive phenotype. Red beads are allele and white beads allele . Each generation, 50 "individuals" (pairs of beads) are drawn; every individual is removed before the survivors' beads are used to make the next generation. The results are in the table in the lesson (generation 0: 13 , 25 , 12 ; generation 4: 34 , 15 , 1 ).
(a) Calculate the frequency of in generations 0 and 4. (b) Describe the trend in the frequency of over the five generations (0.49, 0.33, 0.25, 0.21, 0.17). (c) Explain why is not eliminated. (d) Suggest one way to improve the reliability of the results.
Step 1: Frequency of in generation 0
. Copies of : . Frequency .
Step 2: Frequency of in generation 4
Copies of : . Frequency .
Step 3: Describe the trend
The frequency of falls every generation, from 0.49 to 0.17, but by less each time: , , , . Selection against is negative selection on allele .
Step 4: Explain why persists
Only individuals are removed. Most remaining alleles are in heterozygotes, which survive because is recessive, so they pass on.
Step 5: Improve reliability
Drawing 50 pairs gives large chance variation (drift). Pool the results of several groups, or repeat the simulation several times and average the frequencies each generation; or use a computer simulation to run many more generations and replicates.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 0.49 and 0.17. (b) It falls each generation, rapidly at first then more slowly. (c) Heterozygotes carry but survive, so selection cannot reach those copies. (d) Repeat the simulation (or pool class results) and average, to reduce the effect of chance.
Method
Count alleles out of for each generation.
Describe the direction and the rate of change, with numbers.
Link the shape to dominance (recessive alleles hide in heterozygotes).
Reliability: repeats and larger samples reduce random error.
Watch out for
Expecting to reach 0 within a few generations.
Confusing reliability (repeatable results) with validity (testing what you meant to test).
Key idea
Recessive alleles hide in heterozygotes
When selection acts against a recessive phenotype, it can only remove the allele from individuals. As becomes rare, almost every copy sits in an individual that looks like , out of reach of selection. That is why the frequency of falls quickly at first and then more and more slowly: in the table it drops by in the first generation and by only in the last. A harmful recessive allele is very hard to remove from a population completely.
In the bead simulation, why does the frequency of fall by less each generation?
Human activities and climate as selection pressures. Much of the fastest evolution happening now is driven by people:
- Antibiotics select for resistant bacteria such as methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA).
- Herbicides select for resistant weeds. Annual ryegrass (Lolium rigidum) in Australia was the first weed anywhere found to be resistant to glyphosate, in 1996.
- Insecticides and baits select for resistant pests, and introduced species become new pressures: cane toads selected for smaller relative head size in some Australian snakes.
- Harvesting selects too: fishing that takes the largest fish favours fish that mature earlier and smaller.
- Climate change shifts which phenotypes survive: warmer, drier conditions favour individuals with heat or drought tolerance, and earlier springs favour earlier breeding or flowering.
Exam tip
Analysing selection data
In a data question, quote values: "the frequency of rose from 0.02 to 0.79 over five years ()". Name the direction as positive or negative selection for the named allele, link it to the selection pressure, and describe the shape (fast or slow, levelling off). If the data are a simulation or a small sample, say how that limits the conclusion, and suggest repeats or a larger sample.
Summary
A selection pressure changes allele frequencies by changing who survives and reproduces.
Positive selection for an allele raises its frequency; negative selection lowers it. Positive selection for one allele of a pair is negative selection against the other.
The direction depends on the environment: resistance alleles are favoured with spraying and slightly disfavoured without it.
Selection against a recessive phenotype slows as the allele becomes rare, because most copies hide in heterozygotes.
Bead or computer simulations model a gene pool under selection; analyse them by calculating the allele frequency each generation and the change.
Antibiotics, herbicides, insecticides, harvesting and climate change are selection pressures acting now.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.