Lesson 12 of 12 · 20 min
Inequality: taxes, transfer payments and the welfare state
Explain the welfare state, progressive taxation, transfer payments and subsidised merit goods, and evaluate their private and social costs and benefits as strategies to reduce inequality and raise living standards.
What you will be able to do
- Define transfer payments and the welfare state, and describe Australia's.
- Explain how progressive taxation, transfer payments and subsidised merit goods redistribute income.
- Analyse the private and social costs and benefits of redistribution.
- Evaluate a strategy to reduce inequality against a stated criterion, from more than one perspective.
The market pays people according to what they own and what their work earns. Governments in every rich country change that result: they tax some income and wealth and use it to support people and pay for services. How much they should do so is one of the oldest debates in economics and politics.
Definition
Transfer payments and the welfare state
A transfer payment is money paid by the government to a person for which no good or service is given in return: the Age Pension, JobSeeker Payment, Disability Support Pension, Family Tax Benefit, Parenting Payment and Commonwealth Rent Assistance.
A welfare state is one in which the government takes responsibility for people's basic well-being through social security, health, education and housing, funded mainly by taxation. Australia's is targeted: most payments are means-tested (reduced as income and assets rise) and funded from general taxation, rather than from contributions as in many European systems. Universal services include Medicare (since 1984) and public schools; the National Disability Insurance Scheme began in 2013.
The three main tools.
- Progressive taxation. The average rate of tax rises with income, so high earners pay a larger share of their income. Australia's personal income tax is progressive.
- Transfer payments. Cash paid mainly to people with low incomes raises the bottom of the distribution.
- Subsidised merit goods and other assistance. Education and health care are merit goods: people tend to under-consume them in a free market, and they bring external benefits. Free public schooling, Medicare, childcare subsidies, public housing and concession cards give low-income households services they could not otherwise afford.
| Taxable income | Tax on this income |
|---|---|
| $0 – $18,200 | Nil |
| $18,201 – $45,000 | 15c for each $1 over $18,200 |
| $45,001 – $135,000 | $4,020 plus 30c for each $1 over $45,000 |
| $135,001 – $190,000 | $31,020 plus 37c for each $1 over $135,000 |
| Over $190,000 | $51,370 plus 45c for each $1 over $190,000 |
Quick check
2 marks
Use the table (ignore the Medicare levy and offsets). Calculate the income tax on a taxable income of $60,000, and the average tax rate as a percentage, to one decimal place.
Income tax payable, in dollars.
Average tax rate, in per cent.
Five illustrative households, one for each fifth. Compare the Lorenz curves before and after tax and transfers.
Benefits of redistribution
- Less poverty and hardship: ACOSS and UNSW found poverty fell in 2020 when JobSeeker was temporarily doubled during COVID, and rose again after the extra payments ended.
- More opportunity: subsidised education and health build human capital, with external benefits for everyone.
- Social cohesion and a safety net for everyone against unemployment, illness and old age.
- Stable spending: transfers support demand in a downturn (automatic stabilisers).
Costs of redistribution
- Weaker incentives: high tax rates and payments withdrawn as income rises can reduce the reward for working more, saving or investing (high effective marginal tax rates).
- Opportunity cost: money spent on transfers is not available for other spending, or must be raised by taxes or borrowing.
- Administrative costs, and avoidance as high earners rearrange their affairs.
- Targeting problems: means tests can miss people in need or support people who are not.
A parent receiving a means-tested payment takes on an extra shift earning $200. Their income tax rises by $30 and their payment falls by $100. What is their effective marginal tax rate on the extra $200?
Evidence for an evaluation: are payments enough? The Melbourne Institute compares maximum payments with its Henderson poverty lines each quarter. In the June quarter 2026 a single adult on JobSeeker Payment with the maximum Rent Assistance received $518.45 a week, against a poverty line of $708.86: $190.41 below it. A single pensioner received $710.15 against a line of $574.78. The payments for people expected to look for work are set well below those for people who are not.
Key idea
Two perspectives on raising JobSeeker
For: the payment is below every common poverty line; poverty fell sharply when it was raised in 2020; people in deep poverty find it harder to search for work (to afford transport, a phone, clothes for interviews); spending by low-income households flows quickly back into local businesses.
Against: a higher payment costs the budget each year; a larger gap between payments and wages is said to encourage people to take a job; and some argue the money would do more good spent on training, employment services or housing.
An evaluation chooses a criterion (equity, efficiency, cost to the budget), weighs evidence for both views, and makes a judgement.
Worked example
Inequality: evaluating a higher JobSeeker Payment
Source 1. In the June quarter 2026 a single adult on JobSeeker Payment with maximum Rent Assistance received $518.45 a week; the Henderson poverty line for a single person in the workforce was $708.86 (Melbourne Institute).
Source 2. Poverty fell in 2020 when JobSeeker was temporarily doubled during COVID, and rose after the extra payments ended (ACOSS and UNSW, 2025).
Source 3. An employer group argues that a higher payment would reduce the incentive to take available jobs and cost the budget billions of dollars each year.
Evaluate a proposal to raise JobSeeker Payment to the Henderson poverty line, using equity as your criterion. Plan a full response.
Step 1: Criterion and the gap
Criterion: equity, a fair distribution of income and the ability of everyone to take part in community life. The payment is a week below the line, about 27% short of it.
Step 2: Analyse the benefit
A transfer payment raises the incomes of the lowest-income households directly. Source 2 shows the payment level has a large, quick effect on poverty. Recipients spend most of the extra income on essentials, and are better able to search for work.
Step 3: Analyse the costs
A higher payment narrows the gap between payments and low wages, which may weaken some people's incentive to take low-paid work (Source 3), and it has an opportunity cost for the budget. The employer group represents businesses that want a large pool of workers, a perspective to note.
Step 4: Weigh the perspectives
Recipients and community organisations stress hardship; employers and some economists stress incentives and cost; taxpayers bear the cost; the wider community gains from less poverty and its social costs.
Step 5: Decide and justify
Judgement: on equity, raising the payment towards the poverty line is justified, because the current payment leaves recipients $190 a week below it and the 2020 evidence shows payment levels strongly affect poverty. The incentive concern can be addressed by letting recipients keep more of what they earn before the payment is reduced.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
A strong response measures the gap ($190.41 a week, June quarter 2026), explains the mechanism, uses Source 2 as evidence, weighs incentive and budget costs and the employer perspective, and makes a decision against equity. Judged on a different criterion, such as the cost to the budget or the incentive to work, a different decision can be just as well justified: the marks are for the reasoning, not for one answer.
Watch out for
Choosing equity as the criterion and then deciding on cost alone.
Treating the employer group's claim as fact without noting its perspective.
Which policy redistributes income mainly through the provision of a merit good?
Exam tip
Analysing and evaluating redistribution
Explain the mechanism (how the policy changes disposable income or access to services), say who gains and who pays, use data with its date and source, name the private costs and benefits (to the recipient, the taxpayer) and the social ones (cohesion, human capital, the budget), then make a decision against a criterion.
Summary
Transfer payments are paid by the government with nothing given in return; Australia's welfare state is targeted and means-tested, funded from general taxation.
Progressive income tax (average rates rising with income), transfer payments and subsidised merit goods all reduce inequality of disposable income and access.
Benefits: less poverty, more opportunity and human capital, cohesion, automatic stabilisers. Costs: weaker incentives, opportunity cost, administration and avoidance.
In the June quarter 2026 a single adult on JobSeeker with Rent Assistance received $518.45 a week against a Henderson poverty line of $708.86.
Evaluate against a stated criterion, with dated evidence, from more than one perspective.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.