Lesson 4 of 12 · 20 min
Market concentration: the ACCC, the courts and competition policy
Analyse the private and social costs and benefits of concentrated markets, explain how the ACCC and the courts deal with anticompetitive conduct, and evaluate strategies to increase competition from several perspectives.
What you will be able to do
- Analyse the private and social costs and benefits of concentrated markets.
- Explain how the ACCC, the courts and the Australian Competition Tribunal reduce anticompetitive behaviour.
- Evaluate government strategies to increase competition in banking, grocery and petroleum from different perspectives.
If concentrated markets can cost consumers and the economy, what should governments do about it? Before choosing a strategy, weigh what concentration costs and what it gives.
Costs of concentrated markets
- Higher prices for consumers (a private cost), and a transfer of consumer surplus to profit.
- Under-provision: output below the level where price equals marginal cost, a deadweight loss to society.
- Monopsony power over suppliers: the ACCC found in 2025 that Coles and Woolworths have monopsony power with many fresh produce growers, which "typically leads to undersupply" and less investment by growers.
- Weaker pressure to cut costs and innovate.
- Systemic risk: a few very large banks are "too big to fail", so their failure would harm the whole economy, a negative externality the community bears.
Benefits of concentrated markets
- Economies of scale: lower cost per unit in industries with large fixed costs (refineries, national networks, distribution centres).
- Funds for investment and innovation: supply chains, online shopping, payment systems.
- National pricing: Coles and Woolworths told the ACCC in 2024 that pricing most packaged groceries the same nationally lets shoppers in towns with few rivals benefit from competition elsewhere (the ACCC noted exceptions, especially fresh produce and meat).
- Stability: large, well-capitalised banks may weather shocks better.
- Positive spillovers: new technology and training adopted by a large firm can spread to the rest of the industry.
Classify each effect of a concentrated supermarket market as a private cost (borne by the buyers or sellers in the market) or a social cost (borne by society beyond the market's private costs).
The law. Australia's competition law is the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). Its Part IV prohibits conduct that harms competition:
- Cartel conduct: competitors agreeing to fix prices, share markets, restrict output or rig bids. Serious cartel conduct is also a criminal offence.
- Misuse of market power: a firm with substantial market power engaging in conduct that has the purpose, effect or likely effect of substantially lessening competition (section 46).
- Exclusive dealing and other agreements that substantially lessen competition.
- Mergers and acquisitions that would be likely to substantially lessen competition (section 50).
How a competition case usually runs. The ACCC investigates and prosecutes; only a court can decide that the law was broken and order a penalty.
Key idea
Who does what
- The ACCC (Australian Competition and Consumer Commission) is an independent statutory authority. It monitors markets, runs inquiries (supermarkets 2024–25, retail deposits 2023, petrol each year), investigates conduct, assesses mergers, and takes cases to court.
- The courts, chiefly the Federal Court of Australia, decide whether the law was broken and impose penalties. For anticompetitive conduct on or after 28 March 2026, the maximum penalty for a company is the greater of $100 million, three times the benefit it gained or, if the court cannot work out the benefit, 30% of its adjusted turnover during the breach; an individual can be fined up to $2.5 million. (Earlier conduct faces the lower maximums that applied at the time.) In 2007 the Federal Court ordered Visy to pay $36 million for a cardboard packaging cartel; in 2014 it ordered Coles to pay $10 million for unconscionable conduct towards its suppliers.
- The Australian Competition Tribunal reviews certain ACCC decisions. It can disagree: the ACCC refused to authorise ANZ's purchase of Suncorp Bank in August 2023, the Tribunal authorised it in February 2024, and ANZ completed the purchase in July 2024.
The ACCC believes three fuel retailers in a regional town have agreed to set the same price. Which statement about what happens next is correct?
Open each conduct card to see what a firm with market power might do and how the ACCC and the courts respond.
Government strategies to increase competition. Enforcement deals with bad conduct. Other strategies change the market itself.
| Strategy | Example in Australia |
|---|---|
| Inquiries and price monitoring | ACCC supermarkets inquiry (final report 2025, 20 recommendations); petrol price monitoring |
| Stronger merger control | Mandatory notification of mergers to the ACCC for deals completed from 1 January 2026 |
| Codes of conduct | Food and Grocery Code of Conduct, mandatory from 1 April 2025 for grocery businesses earning over $5 billion |
| Price transparency | Fuel price reporting schemes in every state and territory, feeding price apps |
| Lower switching costs | The Consumer Data Right ("open banking") lets customers share their banking data with another provider |
| Easier entry | The ACCC recommended changes to planning and zoning so new supermarkets can find sites |
| Breaking up firms (divestiture) | Proposed by some for the supermarkets in 2024; the ACCC did not recommend it in 2025 |
Key idea
Evaluate from more than one perspective
The same strategy looks different to different groups. Consumers want lower prices and more choice. Farmers and suppliers want fair dealing and stable prices. Shareholders, including the superannuation funds of millions of workers, want profits. Workers and regional communities care about jobs and local stores. The firms point to their investment and economies of scale. Government weighs efficiency, equity and cost. A strong evaluation names the criterion it uses to decide between them.
Worked example
Market concentration: evaluating divestiture for supermarkets
Source 1. In 2022–23 Woolworths had 38% and Coles 29% of supermarket sales (ACCC, 2025). They held 88% of supermarkets larger than 2,000 m².
Source 2. The ACCC found Coles and Woolworths have "limited incentive to compete vigorously with each other on price", that ALDI is "an important source of price constraint", and that both chains have monopsony power with many fresh produce suppliers. It did not recommend breaking them up.
Source 3. A farmers' group argues the chains should be forced to sell stores so that growers have more buyers.
Evaluate the proposal to give the courts power to force the largest supermarkets to sell some stores, using allocative efficiency as your criterion. Plan a full response.
Step 1: State the criterion and the issue
Criterion: allocative efficiency, whether prices are close to marginal cost and output matches what consumers and suppliers value. Issue: a tight oligopoly (, 2022–23) with weak price rivalry and monopsony power over suppliers.
Step 2: Analyse how divestiture would work
Selling stores, especially the large ones (88% of supermarkets over 2,000 m² are Coles or Woolworths), to new owners would create rivals with full ranges. More sellers raise the pressure to cut prices towards cost, and more buyers of fresh produce reduce monopsony power, so growers' prices and supply rise.
Link the policy to concentration, then to conduct, then to price and output: that chain is the analysis.
Step 3: Weigh the costs
Smaller chains may lose economies of scale in buying and distribution, raising costs per unit (productive efficiency), which could offset lower margins. Divestiture is slow, legally complex and costly, and buyers for the stores may be hard to find. ALDI already constrains prices on the products it sells.
Step 4: Consider perspectives
Consumers gain if prices fall; growers (Source 3) gain bargaining power; shareholders, including super funds, lose value; the ACCC judged the measure unnecessary given its other 20 recommendations and new merger laws.
Step 5: Decide and justify
Judgement: on allocative efficiency, divestiture could help, but its benefit is uncertain while its costs are large and immediate. Stronger merger control, the mandatory grocery code and planning changes that let rivals open large stores target the same problem at lower cost, so the proposal is not justified now; it should remain a backstop if those measures fail to lower margins.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
A strong response states the criterion, uses the data (CR₂ 67%, 88% of large stores), explains how divestiture would change prices and supplier bargaining, weighs lost economies of scale and legal cost, presents at least two perspectives, and makes a justified decision (here: not justified now, as a backstop).
Watch out for
Listing advantages and disadvantages without a criterion or a decision.
Using data without its date and source.
A proposal would force Coles and Woolworths to sell some of their stores to new owners. Which is the strongest argument against it, judged on productive efficiency?
Exam tip
Structuring an evaluation
- Criterion: say what you will judge by (allocative efficiency, productive efficiency, equity, cost to government).
- Analyse how the strategy changes concentration, conduct and prices, using the stimulus data with its source and date.
- Weigh costs and benefits for at least two perspectives.
- Decide and justify, noting what evidence would change your judgement.
Summary
Concentrated markets bring higher prices, under-provision, monopsony power over suppliers and weaker pressure to innovate; they can also bring economies of scale, investment and stability.
The Competition and Consumer Act 2010 prohibits cartel conduct, misuse of market power, anticompetitive exclusive dealing and anticompetitive mergers.
The ACCC investigates and prosecutes; the courts decide and impose penalties; the Australian Competition Tribunal reviews some ACCC decisions.
Strategies to increase competition include merger control, codes of conduct, price transparency, lower switching costs, easier entry and, more rarely, divestiture.
Evaluate against a stated criterion, with evidence, from more than one perspective, and make a decision.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.