Lesson 7 of 12 · 18 min

Environmental economics: costs, benefits and the social optimum

Explain why external costs and benefits are hard to value and missing from market prices, and find the socially optimal quantity, the over-production and the welfare loss in words, numbers and diagrams.

What you will be able to do

  • Explain why externalities are hard to value and are not reflected in market prices.
  • Distinguish private and social costs and benefits.
  • Find the market and socially optimal quantities where MPB = MPC and MSB = MSC.
  • Calculate and explain the welfare loss from over-production, and the Pigouvian tax that removes it.

A paper mill on a Queensland river pays for wood, chemicals, energy and wages. It does not pay for the damage its wastewater does to fishing, swimming and drinking water downstream. Its owners decide how much paper to make by comparing their costs with the price. Society bears a larger cost. That gap is the problem this lesson measures.

Private and social costs and benefits
TermMeaning
Marginal private cost (MPC)The cost to the producer of one more unit: the supply curve
External costA cost of producing or consuming borne by third parties, such as pollution damage
Marginal social cost (MSC)MPC + external cost per unit
Marginal private benefit (MPB)The benefit to the buyer of one more unit: the demand curve
External benefitA benefit to third parties, such as habitat restored by planting trees
Marginal social benefit (MSB)MPB + external benefit per unit

Key idea

Two equilibria

The market settles where the people deciding compare their own costs and benefits: MPB=MPCMPB = MPC, at quantity QmQ_m.

Society is best off where the benefit of the last unit to everyone equals its cost to everyone: MSB=MSCMSB = MSC, the socially optimal quantity Q∗Q^*.

With an external cost, MSCMSC lies above MPCMPC, so Qm>Q∗Q_m > Q^*: the good is over-produced.

A negative production externality: the market produces QmQ_m, more than the social optimum Q∗Q^*. The shaded triangle is the welfare loss.

Interactive

Add the social cost

Electricity from coal, with illustrative numbers. Start with the private curves only and add the external cost.

Working with numbers. Suppose the paper mill's market has these straight-line curves, with quantity QQ in thousand tonnes a year and price in dollars per tonne (illustrative figures):

MPB=100−2Q,MPC=20+2Q,external cost=$20 per tonneMPB = 100 - 2Q, \qquad MPC = 20 + 2Q, \qquad \text{external cost} = \$20 \text{ per tonne}

so MSC=MPC+20=40+2QMSC = MPC + 20 = 40 + 2Q, and with no external benefit MSB=MPBMSB = MPB.

The paper mill (illustrative). Market: Qm=20Q_m = 20, P=$60P = \$60. Social optimum: Q∗=15Q^* = 15, P=$70P = \$70. Welfare loss shaded.

Worked example

Environmental economics: the optimum, the tax and the welfare loss

  • Complex familiar
  • Technology free

For an illustrative paper mill, MPB=100−2QMPB = 100 - 2Q and MPC=20+2QMPC = 20 + 2Q, with QQ in thousand tonnes and costs in dollars per tonne. Waste in the river imposes an external cost of $20 per tonne.

(a) Find the market quantity and price. (b) Find the socially optimal quantity. (c) State the Pigouvian tax that would achieve it. (d) Calculate the welfare loss of the market outcome.

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Market: MPB = MPC. Optimum: MSB = MSC, with MSC = MPC + external cost.

  2. Pigouvian tax = external cost per unit at the optimum.

  3. Welfare loss = ½ × external cost × (Qₘ − Q*) for straight, parallel curves.

Watch out for

  • Using MPC instead of MSC to find the optimum.

  • Forgetting the ½ in the triangle.

In a market, MPB=90−QMPB = 90 - Q and MPC=10+QMPC = 10 + Q, with QQ in thousand units. Production causes an external cost of $16 per unit. Find the socially optimal quantity Q∗Q^*.

in thousand units

Common mistake

The welfare loss is a triangle, not the whole gap

Between Q∗Q^* and QmQ_m, each extra unit costs society (MSC) more than it is worth to anyone (MSB). The welfare loss is the sum of those differences: the triangle between MSC and MSB from Q∗Q^* to QmQ_m. Units below Q∗Q^* are worth producing even though they pollute.

In the previous question the external cost is $16 per unit, Q∗=32Q^* = 32 thousand and Qm=40Q_m = 40 thousand units. With straight-line curves, the welfare loss is 12×external cost per unit×(Qm−Q∗)\tfrac{1}{2} \times \text{external cost per unit} \times (Q_m - Q^*). Calculate it in thousand dollars.

in thousand dollars

The challenge of valuing externalities. The numbers above were given to you. In real life nobody hands the government a tidy "external cost per tonne". Valuing an externality is hard because:

  • There is no market price. Clean air and a stable climate are not bought and sold, so economists estimate their value from damage (crop losses, health costs, property damage), from the cost of avoiding the damage, or from surveys of what people say they would pay to protect them.
  • The costs are spread across people, places and time. Emissions released in Gladstone today affect people around the world for a century. Valuing harm to future generations depends on how much weight we give the future (the discount rate), which is a judgement as much as a calculation.
  • The science is uncertain, especially for rare, severe outcomes.

Estimates of the social cost of carbon (the damage from one more tonne of CO₂) show how wide the range can be: in 2021 a United States government estimate was US$51 a tonne, and in November 2023 the US Environmental Protection Agency estimated US$190 a tonne for emissions in 2020 (both in 2020 dollars), partly because it used a lower discount rate (2% rather than 3%) and partly because of updated estimates of the damage.

Why is it difficult to make the price of electricity from coal reflect its full social cost? Select all that apply.

Select all that apply.

Positive externalities in the environment. A farmer who replants native vegetation along a creek gains shade and less erosion (private benefits), and also stores carbon, filters run-off and restores habitat for everyone downstream (external benefits). The benefit to others comes from the farmer's own production decision, so the social cost of planting is the farmer's cost less that external benefit: MSCMSC lies below MPCMPC, and the farmer plants less than the social optimum. Subsidies and payments for carbon storage aim to close that gap.

A positive production externality, such as revegetation: the market produces too little.

Summary

  • Social cost = private cost + external cost; social benefit = private benefit + external benefit.

  • The market settles where MPB = MPC; society is best off at Q∗Q^*, where MSB = MSC.

  • A negative externality causes over-production; the welfare loss is the triangle between MSC and MSB from Q∗Q^* to QmQ_m.

  • A Pigouvian tax equal to the external cost per unit at the optimum moves the market to Q∗Q^*.

  • Externalities are hard to value: no market price, costs spread across people and generations, uncertain science and a judgement about the discount rate.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 7 of 120% read

Save your progress with a free account