Lesson 1 of 12 · 16 min

Market concentration: market power and efficiency

Explain what market concentration and market power are, how a firm with power raises its price and restricts output, and what competition does to allocative, productive and dynamic efficiency.

What you will be able to do

  • Define market concentration and market power and tell them apart.
  • Explain how a firm with market power can raise its price above marginal cost and sell less.
  • Relate market power to allocative, productive and dynamic efficiency.
  • Explain how competitive pressure affects innovation, investment and the allocation of resources.

In 2022–23 two businesses, Woolworths and Coles, made about two-thirds of all supermarket grocery sales in Australia (ACCC, Supermarkets inquiry, final report, 2025). Most Australians shop at one of them every week. Does it matter that so few firms sell so much? This case option is about that question.

Two ideas run through it. Market concentration describes the structure of a market: how much of its sales the largest firms make. Market power describes what a firm can do: raise its price above the competitive level, or hold back output, without losing all its customers. Concentration often brings power, but not always, which is why both ideas matter.

Definition

Concentration and power

Market concentration is the share of a market's sales made by its largest firms. A market where four firms make 80% of sales is highly concentrated.

Market power is a firm's ability to set its price above marginal cost (the cost of making one more unit) without losing all its sales.

Under perfect competition no firm has any market power. Each sells an identical product among thousands of others, so if it charged a cent more than the market price, buyers would go elsewhere. Competition pushes the price down to the cost of producing the last unit.

A firm with market power faces the whole market's downward-sloping demand curve. If it raises its price, it sells less, but it does not lose every customer. It can choose a price that earns more profit than the competitive one, and that choice has a cost for everyone else. Try it.

Interactive

Raise a dominant firm's price

An illustrative market: demand runs from $100 at 0 units to $0 at 1000 units, and each unit costs $20 to make. Watch quantity, consumer surplus, profit and the value lost as the price rises.

A firm with market power raises its price from the competitive level, $20, to $60. Which set of changes follows?

Choose one answer

The cost of market power in the illustrative market. Raising the price to $60 cuts output from 800 to 400 units; the shaded triangle is the value lost (deadweight loss).

Measure the triangle: its height is $60−$20=$40\$60 - \$20 = \$40 and its base is 800−400=400800 - 400 = 400 units, so the deadweight loss is 12×40×400=$8000\tfrac{1}{2} \times 40 \times 400 = \$8000 of value that nobody receives. This is the core of the economic case against concentrated markets: under-provision. The firm produces less than society wants at a price above what the last unit costs.

The syllabus asks you to support your analysis of the costs and benefits of concentrated markets with diagrams, and a sketch like this one does that job: demand, marginal cost, the competitive and restricted quantities, and the deadweight loss shaded. (The formal diagrams of each market structure, with marginal revenue curves, are an optional extension.) Say it in words as well: price above marginal cost, output restricted, consumer surplus transferred to profit, and a loss of total welfare.

Worked example

Market concentration: the cost of a dominant firm's price

  • Complex familiar

In an illustrative market, demand is P=100−0.1QP = 100 - 0.1Q (price in dollars, QQ in units a week) and every unit costs $20 to produce (marginal cost). Under competition the price would be $20. A dominant firm sets the price at $60 instead.

(a) Find the quantity sold at each price. (b) Calculate consumer surplus at each price, the dominant firm's profit at $60 and the deadweight loss. (c) Explain what the result shows about allocative efficiency.

6 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Find each quantity from the demand curve.

  2. Consumer surplus: half × quantity × (choke price − price).

  3. Profit: (price − marginal cost) × quantity.

  4. Deadweight loss: half × lost output × (price − marginal cost).

Watch out for

  • Counting the whole fall in consumer surplus as lost value: most of it is a transfer to the firm.

  • Saying the firm "produces more to earn more": it earns more by producing less.

What market power does to the three kinds of efficiency
EfficiencyMeaningWith strong competitionWith a dominant firm or tight oligopoly
AllocativeProducing what consumers value most, in the right quantities (price = marginal cost)Price is pushed down to marginal cost, so output is where society wants itPrice above marginal cost; output restricted; deadweight loss
ProductiveProducing at the lowest cost per unitFirms that waste resources make losses and leaveLess pressure to cut costs ("X-inefficiency"); but large firms may gain economies of scale
DynamicImproving over time through innovation and investmentRivals force firms to innovate or lose customersLess pressure to innovate; but large profits can fund research and big investments

Key idea

Competitive pressure

Competitive pressure is the threat of losing customers to rivals. It is what drives firms to keep prices near cost (allocative efficiency), cut waste (productive efficiency), and invent better products and processes (dynamic efficiency). Where competition is weak, those pressures weaken too. That is why economists judge a market's performance by how much competitive pressure its firms face, not only by how many firms there are.

Match each situation to the kind of efficiency it is mostly about.

Competition is not always better on every count. In some industries the cost of building the first unit of capacity is enormous: a fuel refinery, a national banking network, a city's water pipes. One or a few large firms can produce at a lower cost per unit than many small ones, because they spread those fixed costs over more output (economies of scale). Splitting such a market into many small firms could raise costs. And the profit a large firm earns can fund research and big investments that small firms could not afford, a point the economist Joseph Schumpeter made in the 1940s.

So the economic question is never simply "how many firms?" It is: does this market's structure give consumers prices close to cost, efficient production and steady improvement, or does it let firms keep prices high, costs slack and innovation slow?

Interactive

More firms, lower costs?

Add firms to an industry with large economies of scale. The price falls towards marginal cost, but each smaller firm's average cost rises. Then switch to small economies of scale.

In an industry with large economies of scale, the number of firms rises from 2 to 8. Which outcome is most likely?

Choose one answer

Exam tip

Explaining the effect of competitive pressure

A full-mark explanation links cause to effect in a chain, for each kind of efficiency you discuss: less competitive pressure → firm can raise price above marginal cost without losing all its sales → output restricted and consumers pay more → allocative inefficiency (deadweight loss). Then give the other side: economies of scale or funding for innovation.

Summary

  • Market concentration is about structure (the largest firms' share of sales); market power is about behaviour (pricing above marginal cost).

  • A firm with market power faces a downward-sloping demand curve: a higher price means less output, a transfer of consumer surplus to profit, and a deadweight loss.

  • Weak competition threatens allocative efficiency (price above marginal cost), productive efficiency (slack costs) and dynamic efficiency (slow innovation).

  • Large firms can bring economies of scale and fund innovation, so concentration has benefits as well as costs.

  • Competitive pressure, the threat of losing customers, is what drives firms towards all three kinds of efficiency.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 1 of 120% read

Save your progress with a free account