Lesson 5 of 12 · 15 min
Environmental economics: ecologically sustainable development
Explain ecologically sustainable development in terms of allocative, productive and dynamic efficiency, and the environmental impacts of producing and consuming, from emissions to the depletion of resources and the commons.
What you will be able to do
- Define ecologically sustainable development (ESD).
- Relate ESD to allocative, productive and dynamic efficiency.
- Explain the environmental impacts of production and consumption, including the depletion of resources and common access resources.
Every good you buy has two prices. One is on the label. The other is paid by the environment: the coal burned to make the electricity, the water drawn from a river to grow the cotton, the plastic that ends up in the ocean. Markets record the first price well and often miss the second. Environmental economics is about what happens when they do, and what can be done about it.
Definition
Ecologically sustainable development
Ecologically sustainable development (ESD) is development that meets the needs of people today without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs (the Brundtland Report, 1987). Australia's National Strategy for Ecologically Sustainable Development (1992) put it as using, conserving and enhancing the community's resources so that ecological processes are maintained and total quality of life, now and in the future, can increase.
ESD does not mean no growth or no use of resources. It means using them so that the stock of natural capital (clean air, fertile soils, fish stocks, water, a stable climate) is not run down faster than it can recover or be replaced. Economists connect it to the three kinds of efficiency you met in Topic 1.
| Efficiency | What it means | What ESD asks of it |
|---|---|---|
| Allocative | Resources go to the uses society values most | Prices include the full social cost, environmental damage too, so goods that harm the environment are not over-produced |
| Productive | Producing at the lowest cost per unit | Using fewer resources, less energy and less pollution for each unit of output |
| Dynamic | Improving over time through innovation and investment | Developing cleaner technologies (renewable electricity, batteries, recycling) that cut environmental damage per unit |
An electricity grid replaces coal-fired generation with wind, solar and batteries as their costs fall, cutting emissions per megawatt-hour. Which kind of efficiency does this mainly illustrate?
Environmental impacts of economic activities. Both producing and consuming affect the environment.
- Production. Burning coal and gas for electricity releases greenhouse gases; mining clears land and can contaminate water; farming and land clearing cause erosion and nutrient run-off, which has harmed water quality on the Great Barrier Reef; manufacturing produces waste.
- Consumption. Driving releases emissions and causes congestion; single-use packaging becomes litter in waterways; household energy and water use add up across millions of homes.
- Depletion of natural resources. Non-renewable resources such as coal, gas and minerals are used up. Renewable resources such as fish stocks, forests, groundwater and topsoil can be depleted if they are used faster than they regenerate.
- Common access resources. The atmosphere, the oceans and many rivers are open to everyone and owned by no one, so each user has little reason to conserve them: the tragedy of the commons.
An illustrative fishery shared by several boats, under open access, a quota or property rights.
Classify each environmental impact.
Evidence of degradation in Australia. The national State of the Environment 2021 report, released in July 2022, concluded that "the state and trend of the environment of Australia are poor and deteriorating", pointing to climate change, habitat loss, invasive species, pollution and resource extraction. It is the most comprehensive assessment of its kind, prepared every five years by independent scientists for the federal government. Like any source, read it for what it measures (the state of ecosystems, not the economic benefit of the activities that affect them) and for who it was written for.
Worked example
Environmental economics: a fishing quota and ESD
Under open access, boats in a coastal fishery catch more each season than the fish stock can replace, and the stock is falling. The government introduces a total allowable catch divided into individual transferable quotas.
Explain how the quota system supports ecologically sustainable development, referring to allocative, productive and dynamic efficiency.
Step 1: Identify the problem
The fishery is a common access resource. Each boat gains the full value of extra fish but bears only a small part of the cost of a smaller stock, so together they over-fish: the tragedy of the commons. Future catches are being sacrificed, which is not sustainable.
Step 2: How the quota restores sustainability
A total allowable catch set at or below the stock's regeneration rate means the stock is maintained, so future generations can still fish it: ESD.
Step 3: Allocative efficiency
Because quotas can be traded, they move to the fishers who value them most (those who earn the most from each tonne), so the limited catch goes to its highest-valued use.
Step 4: Productive efficiency
With a secure share, fishers no longer race to catch fish first. They can use fewer, better-planned trips and less fuel per tonne, lowering cost per unit.
Step 5: Dynamic efficiency
Owners of a long-lived quota gain from a healthy stock, so they have reason to invest in selective gear and better practices that raise the value of the fishery over time.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The quota caps the catch at what the stock can replace (sustainability), trading sends quota to its highest-valued users (allocative), secure shares end the race to fish and cut costs (productive), and long-term ownership rewards investment in better practices (dynamic).
Watch out for
Saying ESD means no fishing at all.
Common mistake
Sustainable does not mean untouched
ESD does not require leaving every resource in the ground. It requires that a renewable resource is used no faster than it regenerates, and that the benefits of using a non-renewable resource are invested so that future generations are no worse off (for example in skills, infrastructure or alternative technologies).
Summary
ESD meets present needs without compromising future generations' ability to meet theirs.
Allocatively, ESD needs prices that include environmental costs; productively, fewer resources per unit; dynamically, cleaner technology over time.
Production and consumption both affect the environment: emissions, land clearing, run-off, waste and congestion.
Non-renewable resources are depleted by use; renewable ones when used faster than they regenerate; common access resources deteriorate because no one owns them.
Australia's State of the Environment 2021 report judged the environment poor and deteriorating.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.