Lesson 6 of 12 · 17 min
Environmental economics: growth, the Kuznets curve and the EPI
Explain the trade-off between economic growth and ecologically sustainable development with the environmental Kuznets curve and the Environmental Performance Index, and read Australian evidence of degradation for its assumptions.
What you will be able to do
- Explain the trade-off between economic growth and ecologically sustainable development.
- Describe the environmental Kuznets curve and criticise the "grow now and clean later" view.
- Interpret Australia's results in the Environmental Performance Index.
- Calculate and interpret percentage changes in emissions data, and examine the source's assumptions.
Economic growth raises incomes, jobs and living standards. It has usually also meant more energy, more mining, more land cleared and more waste. That is the trade-off at the heart of this case option: more output today can mean a poorer environment for the future. Two ideas help you think about whether the trade-off can be escaped.
The environmental Kuznets curve: a hypothesis, not a law.
Definition
The environmental Kuznets curve
The environmental Kuznets curve (EKC) is the hypothesis, first tested by Grossman and Krueger in the early 1990s, that environmental damage per person rises as a poor country's income grows, then falls once income passes a turning point. As people grow richer they demand a cleaner environment, can afford cleaner technology, and shift from heavy industry to services.
The curve suggests countries can grow now and clean later. The syllabus calls this an optimism bias, and there are good reasons for caution:
- Not every pollutant follows it. Local pollutants such as sulphur dioxide and smoke have fallen in rich countries, but carbon dioxide, whose damage is global and long-delayed, has kept rising with income in many countries.
- Some damage cannot be undone. An extinct species, a cleared old-growth forest or a bleached reef does not return when a country becomes rich.
- Pollution can be exported. A rich country can look cleaner because it now imports goods made in factories elsewhere.
- The turning point may be very high, or a country may never reach it before the damage is done.
A government report argues that Australia need not act on emissions now, because "richer countries always become cleaner". Which is the strongest economic criticism?
Australia's emissions as evidence. The Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water (DCCEEW) publishes a quarterly update of the national greenhouse gas inventory. Its December 2025 update estimated emissions of 458.9 million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent (Mt CO₂-e) in the year to December 2025, down 2.1% on the year before and 24.5% below the year to June 2005, the base year for Australia's legislated target of 43% below 2005 levels by 2030.
Australia's emissions in the year to December 2025 as an index, with the year to June 2005 = 100: total emissions, emissions per person and emissions per dollar of GDP (DCCEEW, December 2025 quarterly update: 24.5%, 45.2% and 54.7% below 2005).
The economy has grown a great deal since 2005 while total emissions fell by about a quarter, so emissions per dollar of output have more than halved. This is decoupling: growth with fewer emissions per unit, the kind of change the EKC predicts. Much of the fall since 2005 came from less land clearing (counted under land use, land-use change and forestry) and, more recently, from electricity, as renewable generation displaced coal and gas. But total emissions are what warm the climate, and they are still about three-quarters of their 2005 level.
Worked example
Environmental economics: how far to Australia's 2030 target?
DCCEEW estimated Australia's emissions at 458.9 Mt CO₂-e in the year to December 2025, 24.5% below the year to June 2005. The legislated target is 43% below 2005 levels by 2030.
(a) Estimate emissions in the year to June 2005. (b) Find the emissions level the 2030 target implies. (c) By what percentage would emissions need to fall from the year to December 2025 to meet it? Give answers to one decimal place.
Step 1: Work back to 2005
24.5% below means the 2025 level is of 2005: Mt CO₂-e.
You cannot add 24.5% of 458.9 back on: the percentage is of the 2005 value, not the 2025 one.
Step 2: Apply the target
43% below 2005 is 57% of it: Mt CO₂-e.
Step 3: Percentage change still needed
.
Step 4: Interpret
Emissions fell about 24.5% in roughly twenty years; meeting the target needs a fall of about the same size again in about five. The estimate depends on the land-use figures, which DCCEEW revises between updates.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) About 607.8 Mt CO₂-e. (b) About 346.5 Mt CO₂-e. (c) A further fall of about 24.5% from the 2025 level.
Watch out for
Calculating 2005 as : the 24.5% is a share of the 2005 value.
Emissions fell from 468.6 Mt CO₂-e in the year to December 2024 to 458.9 Mt CO₂-e in the year to December 2025. Calculate the percentage change, to one decimal place.
Key idea
Examining the source
DCCEEW's figures are the government's official estimates, prepared to international reporting rules. Ask what they assume. They count emissions produced in Australia, not those embodied in the goods Australians import, nor those released when Australia's exported coal and gas are burned overseas. They include an estimate for land use, land-use change and forestry, which is revised as methods improve, so the per cent below 2005 changes between updates. And "below 2005" depends on choosing 2005 as the base: a different base year tells a different story.
The Environmental Performance Index. Yale and Columbia universities' EPI ranks countries on dozens of indicators grouped into three objectives: environmental health (air and water quality, sanitation), ecosystem vitality (biodiversity, forests, fisheries, pollution) and climate change. In the 2026 EPI, which ranked 177 countries on 47 indicators, Australia placed 25th overall with a score of 59.40. It ranked 12th on environmental health but 30th on ecosystem vitality and 71st on climate change.
The EPI's authors note that wealth strongly predicts a high score, partly because rich countries can afford environmental infrastructure and good governance, "but some of the out-performance reflects the outsourcing of dirty industries to the Global South". That is the export-of-pollution critique of the EKC, made by the index itself.
Australia ranked 12th on environmental health and 71st on climate change in the 2026 EPI. What does this contrast best suggest?
Summary
Economic growth raises living standards but has usually increased pressure on the environment: the trade-off with ESD.
The environmental Kuznets curve is the hypothesis that damage rises then falls with income; "grow now and clean later" is an optimism bias because some damage is global, accumulating or irreversible, and pollution can be exported.
In the year to December 2025 Australia's emissions were 458.9 Mt CO₂-e, 24.5% below 2005, while emissions per dollar of GDP were 54.7% lower (DCCEEW).
Australia ranked 25th of 177 in the 2026 EPI: 12th on environmental health but 71st on climate change.
Read every source for what it counts and leaves out: territorial emissions exclude imports and exported fuels; base years and revisions change the story.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.