Lesson 7 of 8 · 15 min

The three economic questions, efficiency and equity

Explain how every economy tackles scarcity by answering what and how much to produce, how to produce and for whom, and distinguish efficiency (use of resources) from equity (who owns them).

What you will be able to do

  • Explain the three basic economic questions and classify decisions by the question they answer.
  • Explain the ways an economy can answer them, through markets, government and tradition.
  • Distinguish efficiency (the use of resources) from equity (who owns the resources and receives the output).
  • Explain why policies can trade some efficiency for more equity, and the reverse.

A country cannot make everything its people want, so somebody, somehow, has to decide what gets made, how, and who gets it. Economists boil the basic economic problem down to three questions that every society answers, whether it is Australia, Cuba or Saudi Arabia.

The three basic economic questions
QuestionWhat it decidesAustralian example
What and how much to produce?Which goods and services are made, and in what quantities. On the PPC, which point the economy chooses.How much of Queensland's farmland goes to sugar cane rather than beef or horticulture.
How to produce?Which combination of land, labour, capital and enterprise is used, and with what technology.Whether a mine uses driverless trucks (capital-intensive) or more drivers (labour-intensive).
For whom to produce?Who receives the goods and services: how output and income are distributed.Who gets a hospital bed: Medicare makes public hospital treatment free for eligible patients, rather than going to whoever pays most.

Two of the three questions on the PPC. What and how much: choosing between points such as A and B. How: whether resources are used efficiently, on the curve, or left idle at C. For whom cannot be drawn on it at all.

Which basic economic question does each decision answer?

Three ways to answer them. Societies use three broad mechanisms, usually in combination:

  • The market: consumers and businesses make their own decisions, and prices coordinate them. What gets made is what consumers will pay for and businesses can profit from; how it is made is the cheapest method a business can find; who gets it depends on who has the income to buy it.
  • Government: a central authority decides by plan, law, taxes, spending and public ownership. It may provide goods directly (public schools, defence), regulate how they are made (safety and environmental laws) and redistribute income (taxes, pensions, Medicare).
  • Tradition: custom decides, as in communities where the trades, land use and sharing of food follow long-standing practice.

The mix a country uses is its economic system, the subject of the next lesson.

Definition

Efficiency

Efficiency is about the use of resources: getting the most out of scarce resources. An economy is efficient when it

  • produces at the lowest possible cost, with no resources wasted or idle (productive efficiency: on the PPC, not inside it), and
  • produces the combination of goods society values most (allocative efficiency: the right point on the PPC).

You will study efficiency in detail in Unit 2.

Definition

Equity

Equity is about who owns the resources, and so who receives the income and the goods produced: whether the distribution is fair. Equity is not the same as equality. Most Australians think it is fair for a surgeon to earn more than a student, but also fair that a person on a low income can still see a doctor.

The distinction matters because the two can conflict. Owning a factor of production is what earns its income: rent for land, interest for capital, profit for enterprise, wages for labour. So an economy where a few people own most of the land and capital can be highly efficient and still very unequal.

Governments that want more equity redistribute: progressive income taxes take a larger share of higher incomes, and the money funds pensions, Medicare and public schools. Economists debate the cost. One view is that high taxes and generous payments weaken the incentive to work, save and start businesses, so the economy produces less: some efficiency is traded for equity. Another view is that equity can raise efficiency, because healthier, better-educated people are more productive. Most economies sit somewhere between the two, and where they sit is a value judgement as much as an economic one.

Worked example

A policy through the lens of efficiency and equity

  • Complex familiar

A government introduces free dental care for all children, funded by a small increase in income tax. Explain which basic economic question this answers, and analyse its effects on equity and efficiency.

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Classify each statement as about efficiency or about equity.

Common mistake

The PPC cannot show equity

The production possibility curve shows what and how much is produced and whether resources are used efficiently, but nothing about for whom. Two economies at the same point on identical curves can have completely different distributions of income. Say so when you evaluate the model.

A government raises the top income tax rate and uses the revenue to increase unemployment benefits. Which statement best describes the efficiency–equity trade-off involved?

Choose one answer

Summary

  • Every economy answers three questions: what and how much to produce, how to produce, and for whom.

  • Markets answer them through prices; governments through plans, laws, taxes and spending; tradition through custom.

  • Efficiency is about the use of resources: no waste (on the PPC) and the mix society values most.

  • Equity is about who owns resources and receives the output: fairness, not equality.

  • Redistribution can improve equity but may cost efficiency through incentives; the size of the trade-off is debated.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 7 of 80% read

Save your progress with a free account