Lesson 8 of 8 · 20 min
Economic systems and how they answer the three questions
Compare how market, planned and mixed economies answer the three economic questions, analyse real countries from Singapore to North Korea with dated data, and write an evaluation that uses evidence.
What you will be able to do
- Describe market, planned and mixed economic systems by who owns resources and who answers the three questions.
- Analyse how real economies answer the three questions, using dated, sourced facts.
- Evaluate economic systems against criteria such as efficiency, equity, growth and choice, from more than one perspective.
- Plan and write a paragraph and an extended response that use data and information as evidence.
Every country faces the same basic economic problem and the same three questions. What differs is who answers them: consumers and businesses trading in markets, a government with a plan, or some mix of the two. That arrangement is the country's economic system.
| Feature | Market economy | Planned (command) economy | Mixed economy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ownership of resources | Mostly private | Mostly the state | Private and public |
| What and how much? | What consumers will buy and firms can sell at a profit | Set by the central plan | Mostly markets; government provides some goods (health, education, defence) |
| How? | Firms choose the lowest-cost method | Planners and state enterprises decide | Firms choose, within government rules |
| For whom? | Those with the income to pay | Distributed by the state, often by need or rationing | Markets, adjusted by taxes, transfers and public services |
| Coordinated by | Prices | Plans and quotas | Prices and government |
Each system's case. A market system's strength is efficiency: prices carry information about what people want and what is scarce, and profit rewards firms that cut costs and innovate. Its weaknesses are equity, because people without income or wealth go without, and the things markets provide poorly, such as public goods and the protection of the environment (Unit 2). A planned system can direct resources to the government's priorities and aims at a more equal distribution, but planners cannot gather the information millions of prices carry, enterprises have weak incentives to cut costs, and the result is often shortages, surpluses and little consumer choice.
No real economy is purely one or the other. It is more accurate to place countries on a spectrum, from mostly market to mostly planned, and to support each placement with evidence.
One way to place the syllabus's examples on the spectrum. Placements are judgements; support yours with evidence.
Classify each feature by the economic system it best describes.
Real economies, with dated facts. Each fact below is the kind of evidence an analysis needs: what it shows about who answers the three questions, and when it was true.
| Economy | Evidence | What it shows |
|---|---|---|
| Singapore | Ranked 1st (score 84.1) in the Heritage Foundation's 2025 Index of Economic Freedom. Yet 76.0% of resident Singaporeans lived in public HDB flats in 2024–25 (financial year 2024). | Markets answer most "what" and "how" questions, but the state provides most housing: a market-led mixed economy. |
| United States | Score 70.2 (26th) in the 2025 Index. A federal minimum wage of US$7.25 an hour, unchanged since July 2009; Medicare and Medicaid since 1965. | Market-led; government sets limited floors and provides health insurance for older and low-income people. |
| United Kingdom | The NHS, funded mainly from taxes, has provided health care free at the point of use since 1948. British Telecom (1984) and British Gas (1986) were privatised. National Living Wage £12.71 an hour (21 and over) from April 2026. | Mixed: health care is answered "for whom" by need; many industries moved from state to private ownership. |
| Norway | The state owns 67% of Equinor, its largest oil and gas company. Oil revenue goes to the Government Pension Fund Global; the budget may spend about the fund's expected real return, set at 3% since 2017 (4% before). | Mixed, with large state ownership of a key resource and a rule that shares oil wealth across generations. |
| Saudi Arabia | The government owns the large majority of Saudi Aramco (1.5% of shares listed in December 2019). Vision 2030 (announced April 2016) aims to diversify away from oil. VAT introduced at 5% in 2018, raised to 15% in July 2020. | State-led: the government owns the main resource and directs "what" through its diversification plan. |
| China | Declared a "socialist market economy" as its goal in October 1992, after reforms from 1978. Five-Year Plans set priorities (the 14th covered 2021–2025); urban land is owned by the state. | State-led mixed: markets set most prices, but the state owns land and key enterprises and plans priorities. |
| Cuba | Most enterprises are state-owned and basic food has been rationed through the libreta since 1962. Private micro, small and medium enterprises (up to 100 workers) were legalised in August 2021. Score 25.4 (175th) in the 2025 Index. | Mostly planned, with a growing but limited private sector. |
| North Korea | Centrally planned; the state owns almost all enterprises and land. No official national accounts are published: the Bank of Korea (South Korea's central bank) estimated growth of 3.1% in 2023 and 3.7% in 2024. Score 3.0, last (176th), in the 2025 Index. | The most planned economy in the syllabus's list; even basic data come from outside estimates. |
Using the table, which piece of evidence best supports the claim that Singapore's economy is mixed rather than purely market?
Note
Weigh the source
The Index of Economic Freedom is published by the Heritage Foundation, a United States research institute that favours free markets. Its score measures how market-oriented an economy's rules are; it does not measure living standards, equity or growth. Evidence like this is useful, but in an evaluation name the source and say what it does and does not measure.
Worked example
Using data to compare two economic systems
Use the information below to analyse how Singapore and Cuba answer the question "for whom to produce?" for housing and food.
- Singapore: ranked 1st (score 84.1) in the Heritage Foundation's 2025 Index of Economic Freedom; 76.0% of the resident population lived in public HDB flats in the 2024–25 financial year.
- Cuba: ranked 175th (score 25.4) in the same index; basic food has been distributed through a ration book since 1962; private small and medium businesses were legalised in August 2021.
Step 1: Read Singapore's evidence
The index shows that markets answer most questions in Singapore. But for housing, the state builds the flats most residents live in (76.0% in 2024–25), so government plays a large part in answering for whom for housing.
Step 2: Read Cuba's evidence
Cuba's low score shows a mostly planned economy. The ration book means the state, not prices, decides for whom basic food is produced: a set quantity per person.
Step 3: Note the change in Cuba
Legalising private businesses in 2021 lets markets answer some questions, so Cuba has moved a little towards the mixed part of the spectrum.
Step 4: Compare
Both use government to answer "for whom" for an essential good, but in different ways: Singapore inside a market economy, through public housing that households buy; Cuba through rationing in a planned economy.
Step 5: Note the limits of the evidence
The index measures market orientation, not living standards or equity, and comes from a free-market research institute, so it shows how each economy is organised, not which one serves its people better.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Singapore is strongly market-oriented (1st in 2025) yet the state provides housing for about three-quarters of residents, so government answers "for whom" for housing within a market economy. Cuba is mostly planned (175th) and answers "for whom" for basic food by rationing, though it has allowed private businesses since 2021. The data show how each is organised, not which delivers better outcomes.
Evaluating a system. "Evaluate" means making a judgement against criteria, with evidence, and considering more than one perspective. Useful criteria for economic systems:
- Efficiency: are resources fully employed, and do they go where they are valued most?
- Growth: is the economy's capacity rising (the PPC shifting out)?
- Equity: who owns the resources, and how evenly are income and essential goods shared?
- Choice and incentives: can people choose what to buy, where to work and whether to start a business?
- Stability and security: are prices, jobs and access to essentials secure?
A mostly market economy tends to score well on efficiency, growth and choice and less well on equity; a mostly planned one claims equity and security, and tends to struggle with efficiency, incentives and choice. Perspectives differ on how much each criterion matters, and good responses say so rather than declaring one system simply best.
Writing an extended response on economic systems
Introduction
Define the key terms (economic system, the three questions), state the criteria you will use, and give your judgement in one sentence.
Body paragraph: make a point
One criterion or one country per paragraph. State the claim in the first sentence.
Explain with economics
Use the concepts: opportunity cost, efficiency, equity, incentives, the PPC (describe the diagram if you use one).
Support with dated data
Quote a figure with its year and source: "the state owned 67% of Equinor in 2025".
Link and weigh
Say what the evidence shows about the question, and what it does not show. Give the other perspective.
Conclusion
Answer the question: a judgement that follows from the evidence you gave, with its main qualification.
Worked example
Writing an analytical paragraph with data
Write one analytical paragraph explaining how Norway answers the question "for whom to produce?" with its oil wealth, using this information: the Norwegian state owns 67% of Equinor; oil revenue is placed in the Government Pension Fund Global; the budget may spend about the fund's expected real return, set at 3% a year since 2017 (4% before).
Step 1: Point
Open with the claim: Norway uses state ownership and a sovereign wealth fund to share its oil wealth across the whole population and across generations.
Step 2: Explain with economics
Oil is the factor land, and owning it earns rent. Because the state owns most of Equinor, much of that income goes to the public rather than private shareholders: the state is answering for whom.
Step 3: Evidence
Use the figures with their dates: The state owns 67% of Equinor, and oil revenue is saved in the Government Pension Fund Global; since 2017 the budget may spend only about the fund's expected real return of 3% a year.
Step 4: Link and weigh
Spending only the return keeps the fund's value for future Norwegians, so the answer to "for whom" includes people not yet born, an equity choice between generations. The cost is lower spending today than the oil revenue would allow.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Norway uses state ownership and a sovereign wealth fund to share its oil wealth widely. Oil is a natural resource (land), and because the state owns 67% of Equinor, much of the rent from it flows to the public rather than to private owners. That revenue is saved in the Government Pension Fund Global, and since 2017 the budget may spend only about the fund's expected real return of 3% a year (down from 4%). By spending the return and not the fund itself, Norway answers "for whom" with both today's and future citizens in mind, an equity choice between generations whose opportunity cost is the higher public spending it could fund today.
Method
Point: one clear claim answering the question.
Explain: the economic concept (factor income, the three questions, equity).
Evidence: figures with their dates.
Link: what the evidence shows, and the trade-off involved.
A student concludes an essay: "Market economies are better than planned economies." Which revision would most improve this as an evaluative judgement?
Summary
Market economies answer the three questions through prices and private ownership; planned economies through state ownership and plans; mixed economies use both.
Every real economy is mixed; place countries on a spectrum and support the placement with dated evidence.
Markets tend to do well on efficiency, growth and choice; planning claims equity and security but struggles with information and incentives.
Name a source, its date, and what it does and does not measure.
Evaluate against stated criteria, consider more than one perspective, and end with a judgement that follows from the evidence.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.