Lesson 5 of 8 · 18 min
The production possibility curve
Draw a production possibility curve from a schedule, use points on, inside and beyond it to show scarcity, choice, efficiency and unemployment, and calculate opportunity cost along it.
What you will be able to do
- Plot a production possibility curve from a production possibility schedule.
- Use points on, inside and beyond the curve to explain efficiency, underutilisation, unemployment and scarcity.
- Explain choice and trade-offs as movements along the curve.
- Calculate the opportunity cost of one more unit of a good from a schedule.
- Explain why opportunity cost rises along a bowed curve and stays constant along a straight one.
Imagine a small island economy that produces only two things: food and machinery. If it put every worker, field, machine and manager into machinery it could make 150 machines a year. If it put everything into food it could grow 50 thousand tonnes. Most of the time it does some of each. The question is which combinations are possible, and what each extra tonne of food costs in machinery.
| Combination | Food (thousand tonnes) | Machinery (units) |
|---|---|---|
| A | 0 | 150 |
| B | 10 | 144 |
| C | 20 | 126 |
| D | 30 | 96 |
| E | 40 | 54 |
| F | 50 | 0 |
The schedule plotted. Each lettered point is a maximum combination; the curve joins them.
Definition
Production possibility curve
A production possibility curve (PPC), or production possibility frontier, shows the maximum combinations of two goods an economy can produce in a given period when all its resources are fully and efficiently employed with its existing technology.
Where the economy's point sits tells you three things.
- On the curve (A to F): every resource is used, and used efficiently. This is efficiency: more of one good can only be made by giving up some of the other.
- Inside the curve: some resources are idle or poorly used. This is underutilisation of resources, and its most important form is unemployment of labour. The economy could make more of both goods without giving anything up.
- Beyond the curve: unattainable with today's resources and technology. That combinations out there exist but cannot be reached is scarcity, drawn.
Inside (A): resources underutilised. On (B): efficient, full employment. Beyond (C): unattainable.
Drag the economy's point. The readout shows whether it is on, inside or beyond the curve, and how much capacity is unused.
An economy is producing at a point inside its production possibility curve. Which statement is correct?
Choice and trade-offs. Moving along the curve from B to C, the island chooses 10 thousand tonnes more food and accepts 18 fewer machines. Every point on the curve is a trade-off, and choosing between them is the economy's choice. The machinery given up is the opportunity cost of the extra food.
Opportunity cost from a schedule
Read the two combinations
B is (10 food, 144 machinery); C is (20 food, 126 machinery).
Find what is gained and what is given up
Food gained: . Machinery given up: .
Divide what is given up by what is gained
State it with units
Between B and C, the opportunity cost of one more thousand tonnes of food is 1.8 machines.
Worked example
Opportunity cost from a production possibility schedule
A country can produce the following combinations of beef and wheat (thousand tonnes) in a year.
| Combination | A | B | C | D | E | F |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beef | 0 | 10 | 20 | 30 | 40 | 50 |
| Wheat | 200 | 192 | 168 | 128 | 72 | 0 |
(a) Calculate the opportunity cost of one thousand tonnes of beef when moving from B to C. (b) Calculate the opportunity cost of one thousand tonnes of wheat when moving from D to C. (c) State whether opportunity cost is constant or increasing, with a reason.
Step 1: (a) Changes from B to C
Beef gained . Wheat given up .
Step 2: (a) Divide
thousand tonnes of wheat per thousand tonnes of beef.
Step 3: (b) Changes from D to C
Wheat gained . Beef given up .
Now wheat is the good gained, so it goes on the bottom.
Step 4: (b) Divide
thousand tonnes of beef per thousand tonnes of wheat.
Step 5: (c) Compare the steps
Each extra 10 of beef costs 8, 24, 40, 56 and then 72 of wheat. The cost increases, because resources are not equally suited to beef and wheat, so the curve bows outwards.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 2.4 thousand tonnes of wheat. (b) 0.25 thousand tonnes of beef. (c) Increasing: each extra 10 of beef costs more wheat than the last.
Method
Write the two combinations.
Opportunity cost of one unit of the good gained = amount of the other good given up ÷ amount gained.
Compare successive steps to decide constant or increasing.
Watch out for
Dividing the wrong way: 10 ÷ 24 is the cost of wheat in beef.
Giving 24 (the cost of all 10 thousand tonnes) instead of the cost of one.
Use the island's schedule. What is the opportunity cost of one more thousand tonnes of food when the island moves from D to E?
Why the curve bows outwards. Work out the cost of each extra 10 thousand tonnes of food: 6, then 18, 30, 42 and 54 machines. The opportunity cost rises as the island makes more food. That is because resources are not equally suited to both goods. The first workers and land moved into farming are the ones best at farming and least useful in the machine works, so little machinery is lost. The last ones moved are skilled machinists and factory sites, poor at farming, so each extra tonne of food costs a lot of machinery. Increasing opportunity cost is what makes the curve concave (bowed out).
If resources were equally suited to both goods, every step would cost the same and the PPC would be a straight line: constant opportunity cost.
Step from combination to combination and compare the cost of each step on a bowed curve and a straight one.
Worked example
Why the PPC bows outwards
An economy produces minerals and tourism services. Explain why its production possibility curve is likely to be bowed outwards rather than a straight line. Use the idea of opportunity cost.
Step 1: State what a bowed curve means
A bowed (concave) PPC means increasing opportunity cost: each extra unit of one good costs more of the other than the last.
Step 2: Explain with suitability of resources
Resources are not equally suited to both goods. The first resources moved from tourism into mining are those best suited to mining (geologists, remote land with ore bodies, heavy machinery) and least useful in tourism, so little tourism is lost.
Step 3: Follow it to the end of the curve
As mining expands further, the resources moved are increasingly suited to tourism and poor at mining (hospitality staff, coastal resorts), so each extra unit of minerals costs more tourism.
Step 4: Contrast with a straight line
If every resource were equally good at both, each unit of minerals would cost the same tourism and the PPC would be straight.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Because resources are not equally suited to minerals and tourism, moving them from one to the other gives up more and more of the other good: opportunity cost increases, so the curve bows outwards.
Common mistake
Price the right good
The opportunity cost of food is measured in machinery given up, and the opportunity cost of machinery is measured in food given up. Moving from D (30, 96) to C (20, 126) gains 30 machines and gives up 10 thousand tonnes of food, so one machine costs thousand tonnes of food. Always write the units.
Exam tip
Drawing the PPC in a response
Label both axes with the goods, draw the curve bowed outwards (unless the question gives constant costs) and label it PPC. Mark each point you discuss with a letter and say in your writing what it shows: "Point A, inside the curve, shows underutilised resources such as unemployed workers." A diagram you never refer to earns little.
Summary
The PPC shows the maximum combinations of two goods with resources fully and efficiently employed and technology fixed.
On the curve: efficiency. Inside: underutilisation and unemployment. Beyond: unattainable, which shows scarcity.
Moving along the curve is a choice and a trade-off; the good given up is the opportunity cost.
Opportunity cost of one unit of X = units of Y given up ÷ units of X gained.
A bowed curve means increasing opportunity cost because resources are not equally suited; a straight one means constant cost.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.