Lesson 1 of 8 · 13 min
Scarcity and the basic economic problem
Describe the basic economic problem of relative scarcity, tell needs from wants, and explain why individuals, businesses and governments at every level must make choices.
What you will be able to do
- Define scarcity, relative scarcity, needs, wants and economic resources.
- Describe the basic economic problem and why it makes choice unavoidable.
- Give examples of decisions forced by scarcity for individuals, businesses and governments at local, state, national and international levels.
Think about everything you would buy if money were no object: a car, a trip to Japan, the latest phone, a house near the beach. Now think about everyone in Queensland doing the same, and every hospital, school and road the state could use. The list never ends. Satisfy one want and another takes its place.
Against that endless list stands a fixed stock of things to make it with: so much land and water, so many workers and hours in the day, so many machines and buildings. That gap is where economics starts.
Definition
Scarcity
Scarcity is the condition in which wants are greater than the resources available to satisfy them. Because resources are limited and wants are unlimited, not every want can be met, so people and societies must choose.
Needs are the goods and services required to survive: food, water, shelter, clothing and basic health care. Wants are everything beyond that, and they are unlimited. Economists usually talk about "needs and wants" together, because scarcity affects both: even meeting everyone's needs takes resources that could have been used another way.
Economic resources are the inputs used to produce goods and services. Economists group them into four factors of production: land, labour, capital and entrepreneurial ability (a later lesson in this topic covers each). A good that takes resources to make is an economic good. Something so plentiful that nobody has to give anything up to use it, such as the air you breathe, is a free good.
The basic economic problem in one line.
Key idea
Relative scarcity
Scarcity in economics is relative: a resource is scarce relative to the wants it must serve, not because there is only a tiny amount of it. Australia has more than a million square kilometres of farmland and some of the world's largest iron ore deposits, and they are still scarce, because there are more uses for them than they can supply. Even a billionaire faces scarcity: there are only 24 hours in their day.
Which statement best describes the basic economic problem?
Common mistake
Scarcity is not a shortage
A shortage is a temporary situation in one market, such as tradespeople being hard to find after a flood, and it can be fixed. Scarcity never goes away. Even when a supermarket's shelves are full, the resources that stocked them could have been used to make something else.
Who has to choose? Everyone who uses resources. The syllabus groups these decision-makers as individuals (and households), businesses and governments, and governments make choices at four levels: local (councils), state, national (the Australian Government) and international (countries acting together).
| Decision-maker | Scarce resource | The choice it faces |
|---|---|---|
| Individual | Time and income | A Year 12 student chooses between a Saturday shift, study and sport. |
| Household | Income | A family chooses between a holiday and a new car. |
| Business | Land, labour, capital | A Bundaberg farm chooses whether to plant sugar cane or macadamias on its land. |
| Local government | Rates and grants | A council chooses between resurfacing roads and building a new library. |
| State government | State revenue | The Queensland Government chooses how to divide its budget between hospitals, schools and roads. |
| National government | Tax revenue and borrowing | The Australian Government chooses between more defence spending, more aged care or lower taxes. |
| International | Shared resources such as fish stocks | Pacific nations agree on catch limits for tuna so the stock lasts. |
Worked example
The economic problem facing a drought-hit council
After two dry years, the dam supplying a western Queensland town is at 30% of capacity. Residents want to keep watering gardens, the council had planned to fill a new public swimming pool, and the town's meatworks, its largest employer, wants to expand and use more water.
Describe the basic economic problem facing the council, and explain why it must make a decision.
Step 1: Name the scarce resource
The resource is water, a natural resource (the factor of production land). The dam holds a limited amount.
Step 2: Name the competing wants
Gardens, the swimming pool and the meatworks expansion all want the same water. Together they want more than the dam can supply.
Step 3: Call it relative scarcity
Water is relatively scarce: limited relative to the wants it must serve. It is not that there is no water, but that there is not enough for every use.
Relative scarcity is the syllabus term. Using it, and saying "relative to wants", is what turns a description into an economic one.
Step 4: Explain why a decision is needed
Because the water cannot meet every want, the council must choose how to allocate it, for example restricting garden watering to protect the meatworks' supply. Whatever it chooses, the next best use of the water is given up: the opportunity cost.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The council faces relative scarcity: water is limited relative to the competing wants of households, the pool and the meatworks. It cannot satisfy all of them, so it must choose how to allocate the water, and every choice has an opportunity cost.
Method
Identify the scarce resource and its factor of production.
List the competing wants.
Use the term relative scarcity and say "relative to wants".
Explain that scarcity forces a choice, and the choice has an opportunity cost.
Watch out for
Saying "there is not enough water" without linking it to competing wants: that describes a shortage, not relative scarcity.
Match each decision to the level of government that makes it.
Scarcity means every decision-maker faces the same three-step logic: resources are limited, so they must choose one use over others, and choosing one use means giving up the next best. That last step is opportunity cost, the subject of the next lesson. Later in this topic you will see how a whole society answers the same problem with its three economic questions: what and how much to produce, how to produce and for whom.
Exam tip
Describe questions
"Describe the basic economic problem" wants the characteristics: limited resources, unlimited needs and wants, relative scarcity, the need to choose, and who chooses. Use those terms and give one example. A two-mark describe question is one sentence of definition and one of application.
A student says, "Sunlight is free, so it is not scarce." When is this true, and when is it not?
Summary
Scarcity: wants are greater than the resources available to satisfy them.
Scarcity is relative: resources are limited relative to unlimited needs and wants, however much of them there is.
Economic resources are the factors of production: land, labour, capital and entrepreneurial ability.
Scarcity forces choice on individuals, businesses and governments at local, state, national and international levels.
Every choice gives something up: its opportunity cost.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.