Lesson 6 of 8 · 18 min
Shifting the production possibility curve
Show economic growth, productivity gains, one-industry technology advances, war, famine and unemployment on the production possibility curve, and evaluate what the model can and cannot show.
What you will be able to do
- Explain economic growth as an outward shift of the production possibility curve and tell it apart from moving from inside the curve to it.
- Show the effect of improvements in health, education and labour productivity, asymmetric technology advances, war and famine.
- Explain why rising unemployment moves the economy's point inside the curve rather than shifting the curve.
- Explain how choosing capital goods today shifts the curve out in future.
- Evaluate the production possibility curve as a model and write a paragraph that describes a shift.
The production possibility curve is drawn for fixed resources and fixed technology. Change either and the curve itself moves. That is how the model shows an economy getting richer or poorer over time.
Key idea
Shift or move?
- A change in the quantity or quality of resources, or in technology, changes what the economy can produce: the curve shifts.
- A change in how fully the existing resources are used (unemployment rising or falling) changes what it does produce: the economy's point moves inside the curve or back to it, and the curve stays put.
- A change in the mix of the two goods is a movement along the curve.
Economic growth is an increase in an economy's output of goods and services. When the economy's capacity grows, the PPC shifts outwards, and combinations that were unattainable become possible. The main causes:
- More resources: a larger labour force from population growth or immigration, newly discovered mineral deposits, more capital from investment.
- Better-quality labour: improvements in education and training, and in health, give a more skilled, fitter workforce that works more days and for more years.
- Higher productivity of labour: more output per hour worked from better management, organisation and capital to work with.
- Better technology that lets the same resources produce more of both goods.
Economic growth: more or better resources, or better technology, shift the curve out from PPC to PPC₁.
A government funds a large expansion of free vocational training, and over several years the workforce becomes more skilled. Show the effect on the production possibility curve.
Asymmetric technology advances. Sometimes technology improves in only one industry. A new drought-tolerant wheat variety lets farmers grow more wheat from the same land and labour, but does nothing for car factories. The most wheat the economy can grow rises; the most cars it can build does not. So the curve pivots outwards along the wheat axis, and the car intercept stays where it was.
Notice what this does to opportunity cost: wheat is now cheaper in terms of cars, because each car given up frees resources that grow more wheat than before. And the economy can now have more of both goods at most points, even though only one industry improved.
A technology advance in wheat growing only: the curve pivots out along the wheat axis.
Choose an event and apply it. The starting curve stays as a dashed outline so you can compare.
Worked example
An advance in one industry only
An economy produces services (horizontal axis) and manufactured goods (vertical axis). New software lets workers in service industries complete far more work per hour; manufacturing is unaffected. Using a production possibility curve, analyse the effect on the economy, including on the opportunity cost of services.
The curve pivots out along the services axis.
Step 1: Identify the change
The software raises the productivity of labour in services only: an asymmetric technology advance.
Step 2: Find each intercept
The most services the economy can produce rises. The most manufactured goods it can produce, with every resource in manufacturing, does not change.
Step 3: Describe the shift
The PPC pivots outwards from PPC to PPC₁ along the services axis, the manufactured goods intercept fixed.
Step 4: Opportunity cost of services
Each unit of manufactured goods given up now frees resources that produce more services than before, so the opportunity cost of a unit of services, in manufactured goods, falls.
Step 5: The wider effect
At almost every mix the economy can now have more of both goods, so it has experienced economic growth, concentrated in services.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The PPC pivots outwards along the services axis with the manufactured goods intercept unchanged. Services become cheaper in terms of manufactured goods, and the economy can reach combinations of both goods that were unattainable before.
Watch out for
Shifting the whole curve out evenly, as if manufacturing had improved too.
War and famine shift the curve inwards. War destroys capital (factories, roads, power stations), kills and injures workers, and pulls labour into the armed forces. Famine kills and weakens workers, and the drought, conflict or failed policy behind it often leaves land degraded for years. Both reduce the economy's resources, so the PPC shifts inwards. Natural disasters such as cyclones and major floods do the same on a regional scale. In practice the point usually falls inside the new, smaller curve as well, because the disruption leaves surviving workers and machines idle.
A global slowdown cuts orders for an economy's exports, and unemployment rises from 4% to 7%. No workers leave the country and no factories close permanently. Show the effect on the diagram.
Today's choice shapes tomorrow's curve. Label the axes consumer goods (food, clothes, entertainment) and capital goods (machines, buildings, infrastructure). An economy that chooses a point with more capital goods gives up consumer goods now, the opportunity cost, but adds to its stock of capital, so its curve shifts out faster in future. An economy that makes too few capital goods to replace the machines that wear out will see its curve shift in.
Choose today's mix for two economies and compare their curves ten years on.
Worked example
Consumer goods today or capital goods for tomorrow
Two economies, Alpha and Beta, have identical production possibility curves for consumer goods and capital goods. Alpha chooses a point where 35% of its output is capital goods; Beta chooses 10%. Analyse what is likely to happen to each economy over the next ten years.
Step 1: The opportunity cost now
Alpha gives up consumer goods today to make more capital goods: its people consume less now. That is Alpha's opportunity cost of investing.
Step 2: What capital goods do
Capital goods (machinery, buildings, infrastructure) add to the economy's stock of capital, so in future its workers have more to work with and productivity rises.
Step 3: Alpha's future curve
Alpha's PPC shifts outwards faster: in ten years it can produce more consumer and capital goods than today.
Step 4: Beta's future curve
Beta enjoys more consumer goods now, but adds little to its capital stock. Its curve shifts out slowly, or, if 10% does not even replace the machines that wear out, shifts in.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Alpha sacrifices consumer goods now but its PPC shifts out further, so it can consume more later. Beta consumes more now but its curve grows slowly, or shrinks if it does not replace worn-out capital.
A two-year famine kills many farm workers and leaves the survivors weaker and less able to work. Which describes the effect on the economy's production possibility curve?
Evaluating the model. The syllabus asks you to analyse and evaluate the PPC. Its strengths are that it shows scarcity, choice, opportunity cost, unemployment and growth on one simple diagram, and makes the cost of every choice visible. Its limitations come from its assumptions:
- Real economies make thousands of goods, not two.
- It is static: it shows capacity at one time, not how long a shift takes.
- It shows how much is produced, not who gets it, so it says nothing about equity.
- It cannot tell you which point an economy should choose: that depends on what its people value, and on the economic system that decides.
- Real curves cannot be measured precisely; economists estimate capacity from data on output, employment and productivity.
Exam tip
Writing about a shift
A strong paragraph names the event, explains the change in resources, productivity or technology it causes, describes the diagram and states the effect on capacity and opportunity cost. For example:
A drought-tolerant wheat variety raises the productivity of land and labour in wheat farming only. On a PPC with wheat on the horizontal axis and cars on the vertical axis, the curve pivots outwards from PPC to PPC₁ along the wheat axis while the car intercept is unchanged. The economy's capacity to produce wheat rises, so the opportunity cost of wheat in cars falls, and combinations of both goods beyond the old curve become attainable.
Worked example
War on the production possibility curve
During a two-year war, a country's factories and power stations are damaged, 12% of its working-age men are conscripted into the army, and many civilians flee abroad. Production of military goods rises while production of consumer goods falls.
(a) Analyse the effect of the war using a production possibility curve with military goods and consumer goods on the axes. (b) Evaluate how well the PPC model represents what happens to the country.
Step 1: (a) Effect on capacity
Damaged factories and power stations are lost capital; civilians who flee are lost labour. The economy's resources fall, so the PPC shifts inwards from PPC to PPC₁.
Step 2: (a) Effect on the mix
The government redirects resources to the war, so the economy moves along its curve towards military goods. The opportunity cost of the extra military goods is the consumer goods given up.
Step 3: (a) Effect on utilisation
Disruption (power cuts, broken supply chains) leaves some surviving resources idle, so production is likely to sit inside PPC₁.
Conscripts are not unemployed: they produce military services. But the disruption to other industries is underutilisation.
Step 4: (b) What the model shows well
The PPC shows three things on one diagram: the loss of capacity (inward shift), the choice of guns over consumer goods (movement along) and idle resources (a point inside). It makes the opportunity cost of war visible.
Step 5: (b) What it leaves out
It is static and cannot show how long rebuilding takes; it cannot show who bears the loss (equity); real capacity is hard to measure in wartime; and two goods hide that some industries collapse while others boom. On balance it is a useful first picture, not a full account.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) The PPC shifts inwards as capital and labour are lost; the economy moves along its new curve towards military goods, giving up consumer goods; and disruption leaves production inside the new curve. (b) The model clearly shows lost capacity, the opportunity cost of war and idle resources, but it is static, says nothing about who bears the cost, and simplifies the economy to two goods, so it is a useful but partial representation.
Method
Separate the effects: capacity (shift), mix (movement along), utilisation (point inside).
Evaluate with the model's strengths and the limits its assumptions set, then give a judgement.
Summary
More or better resources, higher labour productivity or better technology shift the PPC outwards: economic growth.
A technology advance in one industry pivots the curve out along that good's axis only.
War, famine and disasters destroy resources and shift the curve inwards.
Rising unemployment moves the point inside the curve; the curve itself does not move.
Choosing more capital goods now costs consumer goods today and shifts the curve out faster in future.
The PPC shows scarcity and choice clearly but says nothing about equity or which point to choose.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.