Lesson 2 of 8 · 14 min
Opportunity cost and decision-making
Explain opportunity cost as the next best alternative forgone, identify and value it in personal, business and government decisions, and see why benefits and costs are judged subjectively.
What you will be able to do
- Define choice, opportunity cost and trade-off.
- Identify the opportunity cost of a decision from a list of alternatives.
- Value an opportunity cost when the alternatives can be measured.
- Explain why decision-makers weigh benefits against costs subjectively.
It is Saturday. Your manager offers you a six-hour shift, your friends are going to the beach, and you have an assignment due on Monday. You choose the shift. What did it cost you?
Not "the beach and the assignment". You could only have done one thing with those six hours, so what you really gave up was the one option you would have picked instead. That is the opportunity cost.
Definition
Opportunity cost
Opportunity cost is the next best alternative forgone when a choice is made. It is the benefit of the best option you gave up, including the satisfaction and enjoyment it would have brought, whether or not it can be measured in money.
Three ideas sit underneath this definition.
- Choice is selecting one use of scarce resources over the others. Scarcity makes it unavoidable.
- A trade-off is giving up some of one thing to get more of another. Every choice involves one.
- Only the next best alternative counts. The other options you rejected were not going to happen anyway, so they are not part of the cost.
Rank the options. The one you choose is first; the opportunity cost is the second, and only the second.
Priya has $60. Her choices, from most to least preferred, are a concert ticket, a new pair of shorts, and putting the money in her savings account. She buys the concert ticket. What is the opportunity cost of her decision?
Valuing an opportunity cost. Sometimes the alternatives can be measured. If your Saturday shift pays $24 an hour for six hours and your next best use of the day is a second job paying $21 an hour for the same six hours, the opportunity cost of the first job is the $126 you would have earned in the second. Often the next best alternative is not paid at all, and then its value is whatever it is worth to you.
Worked example
The opportunity cost of starting university
Ella has finished Year 12. She ranks her options for next year: (1) start a university degree, (2) take a full-time job at a Townsville logistics firm paying $48 000 for the year, (3) take a gap year travelling. She chooses university.
(a) Identify the opportunity cost of her choice. (b) Explain why the gap year is not part of it. (c) Explain why another student with the same options might rationally choose the job.
Step 1: Find the next best alternative
Her second-ranked option is the job, so the opportunity cost of university is the job: the $48 000 income forgone, plus anything else she valued about it (work experience, independence).
Step 2: Explain why the third option is excluded
She could only do one of the three. Had she not gone to university she would have taken the job, not travelled, so the gap year was never going to happen. Only the next best alternative is forgone.
Adding every rejected option overstates the cost: you can only give up what you would otherwise have had.
Step 3: Explain the subjective part
Benefits are judged subjectively. A student who values an income now, or who is less sure about a degree, may weigh the $48 000 above the expected benefits of study and rationally choose the job.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) The full-time job: $48 000 of income and the experience that came with it. (b) Only the next best alternative is forgone, and that was the job. (c) Benefits and costs are weighed subjectively, so a student who values present income more highly can rationally choose differently.
Method
Rank the alternatives; the opportunity cost is the second-ranked one.
Value it in money where you can, and add its non-money benefits.
Exclude every other alternative.
Explain that the ranking depends on subjective preferences.
Watch out for
Counting university fees as the opportunity cost: fees are a money cost of the choice made, not the alternative given up.
Adding the job and the gap year together.
Sam is offered two jobs for the same Sunday. A landscaping job pays $27 an hour for 5 hours. A café job pays $24 an hour for 7 hours. Sam takes the landscaping job. What is the opportunity cost of that choice, in dollars of income forgone?
Key idea
Benefits are measured subjectively
A rational decision-maker chooses the option whose benefits most exceed its costs, including the opportunity cost. But the benefits are subjective: they depend on the person's own preferences and circumstances. Sam turned down $33 more income for two hours of free time; another student would not. Neither is wrong. Economics does not tell people what to value; it shows them what each choice gives up.
Businesses and governments face opportunity costs too. A business that spends $200 000 on a new delivery van cannot spend it on refitting its shop. When the Queensland Government builds a new hospital, the opportunity cost is the next best project the same funds, land and workers could have delivered: perhaps a new school or a road upgrade. Because public funds come from taxes, the opportunity cost can also be the lower taxes households would otherwise have paid.
Worked example
A government's opportunity cost
A state government has $1.5 billion of uncommitted funds. Its cabinet ranks three uses: (1) build two new regional hospitals, (2) cut payroll tax for small businesses, (3) upgrade a highway. It builds the hospitals.
Identify the opportunity cost of the decision and explain why voters might disagree about whether it was the right choice.
Step 1: Identify the next best alternative
The cabinet's second choice was the payroll tax cut, so the opportunity cost of the hospitals is the tax cut and the benefits it would have brought businesses and their workers.
Step 2: Note what the opportunity cost is not
It is not the $1.5 billion itself (that is the money cost), and not the highway as well, which was ranked third.
Step 3: Explain why judgements differ
Different voters weigh the benefits subjectively. A family in a regional town may value the hospitals far above a tax cut; a small business owner may rank the tax cut first. Each is judging the same trade-off with different preferences.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The opportunity cost is the payroll tax cut, the next best use of the funds. Voters may disagree because they measure the benefits of the hospitals against those of the tax cut subjectively.
Method
The opportunity cost is the next best alternative, by the decision-maker's ranking.
The money spent is not the opportunity cost; it is what the money could have done instead.
Disagreement comes from subjective valuation of benefits.
Common mistake
A free thing still has an opportunity cost
A "free" concert in the park costs no money, but you give up the evening you could have spent another way. A government scheme that is "free" to users is paid for with resources that had another use. No resource used is ever truly free.
A council decides to build a skate park on vacant land. Which of these is the best statement of the opportunity cost?
Exam tip
Explain the significance
When a question asks why opportunity cost is significant in decision-making, say three things: scarcity means every choice gives something up; a good decision compares the benefits of an option with what it gives up, not just its money price; and because benefits are judged subjectively, people facing the same options can rationally choose differently.
Summary
Scarcity makes choice unavoidable, and every choice is a trade-off.
Opportunity cost is the next best alternative forgone: one option, not all of them.
It includes non-money benefits such as time, satisfaction and enjoyment.
Decision-makers weigh benefits against costs subjectively, so people can rationally choose differently.
Businesses and governments face opportunity costs with every use of their funds, land and workers.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.