Lesson 8 of 8 · 20 min
Investigating rates, from disappearing crosses to rusting iron
Plan and analyse rate investigations with marble chips, magnesium and the disappearing cross, then apply rate ideas to corrosion and how we prevent it.
What you will be able to do
- Identify the independent, dependent and controlled variables in a rate investigation.
- Process rate data, including as a relative rate and mass loss as and .
- Evaluate a rate method and suggest specific improvements.
- Explain the factors that speed up corrosion, how it is prevented, and how ideas about it developed.
The factors you have explained with collision theory are easy to test at a school bench. Three reactions do almost all the work, because each one gives you something simple to measure.
| Reaction | What you measure | Factors usually tested |
|---|---|---|
| Mass lost from an open flask, or volume of , every 30 s | Surface area (chips or powder), acid concentration, temperature | |
| Volume of against time, or the time for a fixed length of ribbon to disappear | Acid concentration, temperature | |
| Time for the sulfur precipitate to hide a cross under the flask | Thiosulfate concentration, temperature |
The disappearing cross. Start the timer when the acid is added; stop it when you can no longer see the cross from above.
Key idea
Why is a rate
In the disappearing-cross experiment, every run stops at the same amount of sulfur: just enough to hide the cross. If one run takes half as long to make that amount, it is going twice as fast. So the relative rate is , in . The same idea works for the time taken for a fixed piece of magnesium ribbon to disappear.
In a disappearing-cross run the cross disappears after 48 s. Calculate the relative rate, , to three significant figures.
Worked example
Analysing disappearing-cross data
A student added of hydrochloric acid to of sodium thiosulfate solution in a flask over a cross, and timed how long the cross took to disappear. They varied the thiosulfate concentration by dilution, at 22 °C.
| () | 0.040 | 0.080 | 0.120 | 0.160 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean time (s) | 125 | 63 | 41 | 32 |
(a) Calculate the relative rate for each concentration.
(b) State the relationship shown and explain it with collision theory.
(c) Identify one source of error and suggest an improvement.
Step 1: Process the times
Relative rate : , , , .
Every run makes the same amount of sulfur (enough to hide the cross), so a run that takes half the time is going twice as fast.
Step 2: Describe the trend
As the concentration increases, the relative rate increases. Doubling the concentration from 0.040 to 0.080 roughly doubles the rate (8.00 to 15.9 × 10⁻³ s⁻¹).
Step 3: Explain with collision theory
A higher concentration means more thiosulfate ions in each litre, so they collide with ions more frequently. The fraction of collisions with at least is unchanged (same temperature), so successful collisions are more frequent and the rate increases.
Step 4: Evaluate
Deciding exactly when the cross disappears depends on the observer and the lighting, so the times have random error. Use the same observer and lighting, repeat each run three times, or replace the eye with a light sensor and data logger that records when transmitted light falls to a set level.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) , , , (b) Rate increases with concentration (roughly doubling when concentration doubles) because collisions become more frequent at the same fraction of successful collisions. (c) Judging the end point is subjective; use a light sensor.
Method
Relative rate for a fixed amount of reaction.
Describe the trend with numbers.
Explain with collision frequency; temperature is controlled.
Name a specific error and a specific fix.
Watch out for
Plotting time instead of and calling a decreasing time a decreasing rate.
Writing "human error" without saying what the error is or how to reduce it.
Tip
Variables and a fair test
- Independent variable: the one factor you change, such as the concentration of sodium thiosulfate (made by diluting the stock solution with water).
- Dependent variable: what you measure, such as the time for the cross to disappear (processed to ).
- Controlled variables: everything else that could change the rate: the volume and concentration of the acid, the total volume of solution (so the depth of liquid above the cross is the same), the temperature, the same flask and the same cross.
Repeat each run at least three times and average, then plot the processed rate against the independent variable.
A student investigates how temperature affects the rate of the reaction between magnesium ribbon and hydrochloric acid, timing how long a 2.0 cm length of ribbon takes to disappear. Which of these is a controlled variable?
Worked example
Rate of reaction from mass loss
Marble chips are added to of hydrochloric acid in an open flask on a balance. A cotton wool plug lets gas escape but stops acid spray. The reading falls from to in the first 60 s.
(a) Calculate the average rate of mass loss in .
(b) Calculate the average rate of production of in .
(c) Calculate the average rate of use of in .
Step 1: Why the mass falls
. The only thing leaving the flask is gas, so the mass lost is the mass of produced.
Step 2: Rate of mass loss
Step 3: Convert to moles
, so .
Step 4: Rate of use of acid
, so HCl is used at . Divide by the volume: .
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) (b) (c)
Method
Mass lost = mass of gas escaped.
→ .
Mole ratio, then divide by the volume in litres → .
Watch out for
Dividing the final mass, 159.12 g, by the time. Only the change matters.
Using the molar mass of HCl or CaCO₃ to convert the mass of gas.
Exam tip
Evaluating a rate method
Name the specific problem, its effect and a specific fix. For example: "Judging when the cross disappears depends on the observer and the lighting, which causes random error in ; use the same observer and lighting, or replace the eye with a light sensor and data logger." "Gas escapes before the bung is fitted, so early volumes are too low; put the acid in a small tube inside the flask and tip it over after sealing." "Mass loss is tiny for hydrogen, so measure its volume instead."
Corrosion: a slow reaction worth slowing down
Rusting is a reaction you usually want as slow as possible. Iron reacts with oxygen and water in a redox reaction: iron atoms lose electrons (are oxidised) and oxygen gains them (is reduced). You will study redox in detail in Unit 3.
The iron(II) hydroxide that forms is oxidised further, for example , which dries to hydrated iron(III) oxide: rust.
| Conditions | Result | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Tap water, open to air | Rusts | Water and oxygen both present |
| Boiled water under a layer of oil | Little or no rust | Boiling removed dissolved oxygen; the oil stops more dissolving |
| Dry air with anhydrous calcium chloride | No rust | The drying agent removes water vapour |
| Salt water, open to air | Rusts fastest | Dissolved ions make the water conduct, so electrons and ions move more easily between the iron and the oxygen |
| Water, nail wrapped in magnesium ribbon | Nail does not rust | Magnesium is more reactive and is oxidised instead (sacrificial protection) |
| Water, nail wrapped in copper wire | Rusts faster | Copper is less reactive, so the iron is oxidised even more readily |
Key idea
How corrosion is prevented
Almost every modern method relies on understanding the redox chemistry:
- Barriers (paint, oil and grease, plastic coatings, tin or chromium plating) stop oxygen and water reaching the iron, so the reacting particles cannot collide.
- Galvanising coats steel with zinc. The zinc is a barrier, and because zinc is more reactive than iron, it is oxidised first even where the coating is scratched.
- Sacrificial anodes: blocks of zinc or magnesium bolted to ship hulls, jetty piles and pipelines, or the magnesium rod in a hot water tank, are oxidised instead of the steel and replaced when they wear away.
- Impressed current: a power supply pushes electrons onto a steel structure, so iron atoms are not oxidised.
- Alloying: chromium in stainless steel forms a thin, tough oxide layer that seals the surface.
Four identical steel bolts are left outdoors for a year. Which would you expect to corrode fastest?
Worked example
Protecting a steel hull from corrosion
A steel fishing boat moored in Moreton Bay has blocks of zinc bolted to its hull below the waterline. The owner wants to replace a corroded steel propeller shaft fitting with a bronze (mostly copper) one, and asks whether painting the hull would make the zinc blocks unnecessary.
(a) Explain why seawater corrodes steel faster than fresh water.
(b) Explain how the zinc blocks protect the hull, and why they must be replaced every year or so.
(c) Evaluate the owner's two ideas.
Step 1: Why seawater is worse
Rusting is a redox reaction between iron, oxygen and water. Dissolved salts make seawater a good electrical conductor, so ions and electrons move more easily between the places where iron is oxidised and oxygen is reduced. The reaction is faster.
Step 2: How the zinc protects the hull
Zinc is more reactive than iron, so when the two metals are in contact in seawater, zinc is oxidised in preference to iron: . The electrons flow into the steel, so the iron is not oxidised. This is sacrificial protection.
Step 3: Why replace the blocks
The zinc is used up as it is oxidised, so the blocks wear away. Once they are gone the steel corrodes again.
Step 4: Evaluate the bronze fitting
Copper is less reactive than iron. Joined to the steel in seawater, it makes the iron the metal that is oxidised, so the steel around the fitting would corrode faster. Not a good idea unless the metals are electrically insulated from each other.
Step 5: Evaluate painting
Paint is a barrier that stops water and oxygen reaching the steel, so it slows corrosion greatly. But paint is easily scratched or chipped on a working boat, and the exposed steel then corrodes. Using paint and the zinc blocks is better than either alone; the paint also makes the zinc last longer.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Dissolved salts make seawater conduct, speeding the redox reaction. (b) Zinc is more reactive, so it is oxidised instead of the iron; it is consumed, so it must be replaced. (c) A copper-based fitting would speed the corrosion of the nearby steel; paint is a useful barrier but fails where it is damaged, so keep the zinc blocks as well.
Method
Identify the reactants needed for corrosion and what speeds the reaction.
Compare reactivities to decide which metal is oxidised.
Evaluate: strength, limitation, judgement.
Watch out for
Saying the zinc "repels" water. It works by being oxidised instead of the iron.
Thinking any metal coating protects steel. A less reactive metal makes corrosion worse wherever the coating is broken.
History
From Iron Age rust to acid rain
Iron came into wide use around 1200 BCE, and rust came with it. In the first century CE, Pliny the Elder wrote that iron could be protected with coatings of white lead, gypsum or pitch: barrier methods we still use. The iron pillar in Delhi has stood for about 1600 years with remarkably little rust, mainly because its high phosphorus content helps a thin protective layer form on the surface.
In 1824 Humphry Davy, helped by Michael Faraday, bolted lumps of zinc and iron to the copper sheathing of Royal Navy ships so they would corrode instead of the copper: the first sacrificial protection. It worked too well. Copper that no longer dissolved stopped poisoning marine growth, so the hulls fouled with barnacles and weed.
Through the 1800s, many chemists thought an acid, such as carbonic acid from carbon dioxide, was needed for iron to rust. In 1903 Willis Whitney proposed that rusting is electrochemical, and from the 1920s Ulick Evans in Cambridge proved it with careful experiments. Industrial cities then supplied a new problem: sulfur dioxide from burning coal dissolves in moisture to make acids that cut the life of steel bridges, railways and bronze statues. Cleaner air laws reduced sulfur dioxide pollution, but salty sea air still means steel bridges near the coast need regular repainting.
Summary
Rate investigations change one factor (independent variable), measure the time or the amount (dependent variable) and control everything else.
For a fixed amount of reaction, relative rate ; mass loss gives , which converts to with .
Evaluate methods by naming the specific error, its effect and a specific improvement.
Rusting needs iron, water and oxygen; salt, acidic pollutants and higher temperature speed it up.
Barriers stop the reactants colliding; galvanising and sacrificial anodes use a more reactive metal that is oxidised instead.
Ideas about corrosion moved from coatings in Antiquity, through Davy's sacrificial protection and the acid theory, to the electrochemical theory and the effects of air pollution.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.