Lesson 5 of 8 · 18 min
Energy profile diagrams and activation energy
Sketch energy profile diagrams for exothermic and endothermic reactions, read and from them, and link the bonds to be broken to the size of .
What you will be able to do
- Sketch an energy profile diagram for an exothermic or endothermic reaction, labelling the transition state, and .
- Read and from an energy profile diagram.
- Explain how the strength and number of bonds to be broken affect and so the rate.
In Unit 1 you drew enthalpy level diagrams: two horizontal levels, reactants and products, and a arrow between them. They tell you how much energy is released or absorbed. They don't tell you how fast, because they skip the journey between the two levels.
An energy profile diagram adds that journey. Before reactants can become products, bonds must stretch and start to break, so the energy rises to a peak, the transition state, and then falls as new bonds form. The height of that hump is the activation energy.
An exothermic reaction: and .
Key idea
Reading an energy profile
- Activation energy: from the reactant level up to the peak. , always positive.
- Enthalpy change: from the reactant level to the product level. : negative if the products are lower (exothermic), positive if they are higher (endothermic).
- The transition state (activated complex) at the peak is the highest-energy arrangement of atoms, with old bonds partly broken and new bonds partly formed. It cannot be isolated.
Use the energy profile above. State the enthalpy change, , for the reaction.
An endothermic reaction. The products are higher than the reactants, so is positive.
Use the endothermic energy profile above. Determine the activation energy of the reaction.
Drag and . Notice that changing one does not change the other: how fast and how exothermic are separate questions.
Sketching an energy profile
Label the axes
"Enthalpy" or "energy" (with if values are given) on the vertical axis, "reaction progress" on the horizontal axis.
Draw the reactant and product levels
Products lower for an exothermic reaction, higher for an endothermic one. Label them, with formulas if you know them.
Join them with a smooth hump
The peak (transition state) must be above both levels.
Add the arrow
Vertical, from the reactant level up to the height of the peak.
Add the arrow
Vertical, from the reactant level to the product level, pointing down if exothermic and up if endothermic. Write the value with its sign if you know it.
Worked example
Sketch an endothermic energy profile with a catalyst
A reaction has and an activation energy of . With a catalyst its activation energy is . Sketch an energy profile diagram for the reaction with and without the catalyst, labelling , the catalysed and . Take the reactants to be at on the vertical axis.
The completed sketch.
Step 1: Place the levels
Reactants at 50. is positive, so the products are higher: .
Step 2: Place the uncatalysed peak
is measured up from the reactants: .
Step 3: Place the catalysed peak
. Draw this path dashed, starting and ending at the same levels.
The catalyst does not change the reactants or products, so it cannot change their enthalpies or .
Step 4: Add the arrows
Two upward arrows from the reactant level, to 200 () and to 140 ( with catalyst); one upward arrow from the reactants to the products ().
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Reactants at 50, products at 110, uncatalysed peak at 200 and catalysed peak at 140 , with both paths sharing the same reactant and product levels and an upward arrow.
Method
Products = reactants + .
Peak = reactants + (for each path).
Catalysed path: same ends, lower peak.
Watch out for
Measuring from zero, putting the peak at 150 instead of 200.
Drawing the catalysed path ending at a different product level.
Worked example
Reading activation energies and ΔH from a profile
The energy profile shows a reaction with and without a catalyst.
(a) Determine the activation energy without the catalyst and with it.
(b) Determine and state whether the reaction is exothermic or endothermic.
(c) Determine the activation energy of the reverse reaction without the catalyst.
Energy profile with (dashed) and without (solid) a catalyst.
Step 1: Read the three levels
Reactants , products , uncatalysed peak , catalysed peak .
Step 2: Activation energies
without the catalyst; with it.
Step 3: Enthalpy change
. Negative, so the reaction is exothermic.
Step 4: Reverse activation energy
For the reverse reaction, the "reactants" are the products at 20, so . Check: .
Reading the profile from right to left gives the reverse reaction. Its barrier is measured from where it starts.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) without, with the catalyst (b) , exothermic (c)
Method
Read every level first and write them down.
= peak − start; = end − start.
For the reverse reaction, start from the products.
Watch out for
Reading the peak height (230) as the activation energy.
Writing . The products are lower, so it is negative.
Key idea
Bonds, activation energy and rate
To reach the transition state, colliding particles must stretch and start to break bonds in the reactants. As a rule:
the stronger the bonds, and the more of them, that must be broken or weakened, the higher the activation energy.
A higher means a smaller fraction of collisions have enough energy, so at a given temperature the reaction is slower. Reactions between oppositely charged ions in solution need no covalent bonds broken at all, so their is tiny and they are almost instantaneous.
| Reaction | Bonds that must break | Rate at room temperature |
|---|---|---|
| None: oppositely charged ions attract | Instantaneous (a precipitate forms as the solutions mix) | |
| None | Instantaneous | |
| (414) and (498) | No reaction until a spark or flame supplies ; then fast | |
| (945) and (436) | Immeasurably slow; even at 450 °C it needs an iron catalyst |
Worked example
Why some reactions are instant and others barely happen
When silver nitrate solution is added to sodium chloride solution, a white precipitate forms instantly: . A mixture of nitrogen and hydrogen, , shows no measurable reaction at room temperature, even though the reaction is exothermic. Explain the difference in terms of bonds, activation energy and collisions. Use the data book's bond enthalpies.
Step 1: Identify the bonds that must break
The ionic reaction joins oppositely charged ions that attract each other; no covalent bonds need to break. The ammonia synthesis must break (, one of the strongest bonds there is) and three bonds ( each).
Step 2: Link bonds to activation energy
With no bonds to break, for the precipitation is close to zero. Breaking or substantially weakening a triple bond requires a very large activation energy.
Colliding particles must reach the transition state, where reactant bonds are partly broken. The stronger and more numerous those bonds, the higher that state lies.
Step 3: Link activation energy to successful collisions
Almost every collision between and ions succeeds, so the reaction is over as the solutions mix. At room temperature, almost no – collisions have enough energy to reach the high , so successful collisions are extremely rare.
Step 4: Note what ΔH does not tell you
Being exothermic does not make a reaction fast; and are independent. Industry makes ammonia fast enough only by using an iron catalyst at about 450 °C.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The precipitation breaks no covalent bonds, so its is tiny and almost every ionic collision succeeds: it is instantaneous. Ammonia synthesis must break the very strong bond and three bonds, so its is very high and almost no collisions succeed at room temperature: the rate is negligible.
Method
List the bonds that must break, with their bond enthalpies.
More and stronger bonds → higher .
Higher → smaller fraction of successful collisions → slower.
Watch out for
Saying the ammonia reaction is slow because it is exothermic.
Treating as the total bond enthalpy of the reactants; it is related to it, but much smaller, because new bonds start forming as old ones break.
Based on the bonds that must be broken, which reaction would you expect to have the highest activation energy?
Common mistake
Measure and from the reactants
Both arrows start at the reactant level. Reading from zero, or from the products, gives the wrong value. And and are independent: a very exothermic reaction can still be slow (methane and air), and an endothermic one can be fast.
Looking ahead to Unit 3 — the reverse reaction
Read an energy profile from right to left and you have the reverse reaction. Its activation energy is measured from the products up to the peak:
For the exothermic profile at the top of this lesson, . For an exothermic reaction the reverse barrier is always higher than the forward one, which is why some reactions are hard to reverse. You will use this to explain equilibrium in Unit 3.
Exam tip
Analyse means calculate and say what it shows
"Analyse the energy profile" usually wants values (with signs and units) and an interpretation: whether the reaction is exothermic or endothermic, and what the size of suggests about the rate at room temperature.
Summary
An energy profile plots enthalpy against reaction progress, showing reactants, the transition state and products.
is the height of the peak above the reactants; is the products minus the reactants.
The transition state is above both reactants and products, whichever way goes.
More and stronger bonds to break generally mean a higher , a smaller fraction of successful collisions and a slower rate.
(how fast) and (how much energy) are independent.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.