Lesson 2 of 6 · 16 min
Separating mixtures
Choose a separation method from a difference in physical properties, plan and evaluate a separation, and see how water analysis led Ellen Swallow Richards to the first water quality standards.
What you will be able to do
- Match a separation method to the difference in physical properties it relies on.
- Plan the separation of a mixture of several components, step by step.
- Calculate a percentage recovery and evaluate the errors in a separation.
- Describe Ellen Swallow Richards' contribution to water quality standards and home economics.
Water from a creek is a mixture: sand and mud that settle out, dissolved salts you cannot see, and perhaps microbes. Turning it into drinking water means separating it, one property at a time.
Because the substances in a mixture are not bonded to each other, each keeps its own properties. Every separation method works by exploiting a difference in a physical property: particle size, solubility, boiling point, density, magnetism.
| Method | Separates | Property difference | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Filtration | An insoluble solid from a liquid | Solubility and particle size: solid particles are too big to pass through the filter paper | Sand from water |
| Evaporation, crystallisation | A dissolved solid from its solvent | Volatility: the solvent evaporates, the solute does not | Salt crystals from salt water |
| Simple distillation | A solvent from a solution | Boiling point: the solvent boils off and is condensed | Pure water from sea water |
| Fractional distillation | Miscible liquids | Boiling point, when the boiling points are close (within about 25 °C); the column gives a much better separation than simple distillation | Ethanol from water; crude oil into fractions |
| Separating funnel (or decanting) | Immiscible liquids | Density and immiscibility: the denser liquid forms the lower layer | Oil from water |
| Magnetic separation | A magnetic solid from others | Magnetism | Iron filings from sulfur powder |
| Chromatography | Dissolved substances, such as dyes | Different attraction to the paper (stationary phase) and the solvent (mobile phase) | Dyes in an ink |
Simple distillation. Cooling water enters the condenser at the lower end so the jacket stays full. The thermometer bulb sits at the side arm, where it reads the temperature of the vapour that is distilling.
Which method would give a sample of pure water from sea water?
Separating a mixture of sand and salt
Dissolve
Add warm water and stir until all the salt has dissolved. The sand does not dissolve.
Filter
Pour through filter paper in a funnel. The sand stays on the paper as the residue; the salt solution passes through as the filtrate.
Wash the residue
Rinse the sand with a little more water, so no salt solution is left clinging to it, and add the washings to the filtrate.
Crystallise the salt
Heat the filtrate in an evaporating basin until it is concentrated, then leave it to cool and finish evaporating slowly. Heating to dryness makes the crystals spit out of the basin.
Dry and weigh
Dry both the sand and the salt (in a warm oven or a desiccator) and weigh them.
Worked example
Separating iron, salt and sand
A mixture contains iron filings, sand and salt (sodium chloride). Describe how to obtain a dry sample of each, naming the property each step relies on.
Step 1: List the differences in properties
Iron is magnetic; sand and salt are not. Salt dissolves in water; sand and iron do not.
Every separation step uses one difference. Listing them first shows you the order.
Step 2: Remove the iron first
Spread the dry mixture out and pass a magnet (wrapped in plastic, so the filings slide off easily) over it. The iron filings are attracted to the magnet and lifted out.
Do this while the mixture is dry. In water the iron would begin to rust, and wet sand and salt would stick to it.
Step 3: Dissolve the salt
Add warm water to the sand and salt and stir until the salt has dissolved.
Step 4: Filter
Filter the mixture. The sand stays on the filter paper (insoluble, too large to pass through); the salt solution passes through as the filtrate. Wash the sand with a little water.
Step 5: Crystallise the salt and dry the sand
Evaporate most of the water from the filtrate, then leave it to crystallise. Dry the sand in a warm oven.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(1) Magnet: removes the magnetic iron. (2) Dissolve in water: the salt is soluble, the sand is not. (3) Filter: separates insoluble sand from the salt solution. (4) Evaporate and crystallise: recovers the salt, because the water is volatile and the salt is not. Dry each product.
Method
List the properties in which the components differ.
Remove whatever is easiest to remove from the dry mixture first.
Dissolve, filter, then evaporate or crystallise.
Name the property each step uses.
Watch out for
Adding water first, so the iron rusts and the magnet picks up wet sand.
Saying filtration separates the salt: dissolved salt goes through the paper.
A green food colouring looks like one substance, but chromatography shows it is a mixture of a yellow and a blue dye. Each dye travels a different distance because it is attracted differently to the paper and the solvent. (You measure values in Unit 2.)
Worked example
Evaluating a salt recovery
Crust scraped from the edge of a dry salt lake is a mixture of sodium chloride with insoluble sand and clay. A student dissolved of the crust in water, filtered it, and evaporated the filtrate to dryness. They recorded:
| Mass (g) | |
|---|---|
| Salt-lake crust used | 20.00 |
| Salt recovered | 5.86 |
| Residue on the filter paper (weighed straight after filtering) | 14.62 |
(a) Calculate the percentage of salt in the crust from these results.
(b) The two products total more than 20.00 g. Explain the most likely cause.
(c) The student saw salt crystals spitting out of the basin during evaporation. Explain the effect on the result in (a), and suggest two improvements to the method.
Step 1: Calculate the percentage of salt
Step 2: Compare the total with the starting mass
, which is more than the 20.00 g used. Mass cannot be created, so something extra was weighed.
Step 3: Find the cause
The residue was weighed straight after filtering, while it was still wet. Its mass includes water (and some salt solution soaked into it), so 14.62 g is too high.
Water clinging to the residue is the only extra substance that could add mass. Spitting or lost salt would make the total smaller, not larger.
Step 4: Explain the effect of spitting
Salt that spits out of the basin is lost, so the mass of salt recovered is too small and 29.3 % is an underestimate. This is a systematic error: it always lowers the result.
Step 5: Suggest improvements
Stop heating when crystals first appear and let the rest of the water evaporate slowly (or cover the basin loosely), so no salt spits out. Wash the residue with a little distilled water to rinse out trapped salt solution, then dry it in an oven to constant mass before weighing.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 29.3 % salt.
(b) The residue was weighed wet: the water (and salt solution) still in it added mass, so the total, 20.48 g, exceeds 20.00 g.
(c) Salt lost by spitting makes the recovered mass, and so the 29.3 %, too low. Improvements: heat gently and stop when crystals form, finishing the evaporation slowly; wash the residue and dry it to constant mass before weighing.
Method
Percentage = part ÷ whole × 100 %.
Check whether the products add up to the starting mass; an excess means something extra was weighed.
For each error, give its direction (too high or too low) and an improvement that removes the cause.
Watch out for
Writing "human error" or "inaccurate measurements" instead of naming the cause and its direction.
Suggesting "repeat the experiment" for a systematic error. Repeats reduce random error; they do not stop salt spitting.
In a sand–salt separation, a student weighs the sand while it is still damp. What effect does this have on the calculated percentage of sand in the mixture?
History
Ellen Swallow Richards and clean water
Ellen Swallow Richards (1842–1911) was the first woman admitted to the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), graduating in chemistry in 1873, and later taught sanitary chemistry there.
In 1887 the Massachusetts State Board of Health began a survey of the state's inland waters, and Richards supervised the analysis: tens of thousands of samples over two years. Because human and household waste is salty, she used chloride as a marker of pollution: she mapped the natural ("normal") chloride level across the state, which falls with distance from the sea, and any sample well above its local normal value showed sewage contamination. Her Normal Chlorine Map and the survey's results led to the first state water quality standards in the United States and to the first modern municipal sewage treatment plant, in Lowell, Massachusetts.
Richards then applied chemistry to the home itself: the safety of food, water and air, nutrition and sanitation. She founded the new discipline of home economics and in 1908 became the first president of the American Home Economics Association.
Why did a chloride level well above the local "normal" value suggest that a Massachusetts lake was polluted by sewage?
Common mistake
What filtration can and cannot do
Filtration removes insoluble solids only. Anything dissolved (salt, sugar, the colour in cordial) passes through the filter paper. To recover a dissolved solid, evaporate or crystallise; to recover the solvent, distil.
Exam tip
Justify the method with a property
A full answer names the method and the property difference it uses: "Use a magnet, because iron is magnetic and sulfur is not", or "Fractional distillation, because ethanol (78 °C) and water (100 °C) have different boiling points". For a multi-step separation, give the steps in order and say what each one removes.
Summary
Every physical separation uses a difference in a physical property of the components.
Filtration: insoluble solid from liquid. Evaporation or crystallisation: dissolved solid. Distillation: the solvent, or liquids with different boiling points. Separating funnel: immiscible liquids. Magnet: magnetic solids. Chromatography: dissolved substances.
Plan multi-part separations in order (for sand, salt and iron: magnet, dissolve, filter, crystallise), and wash and dry each product.
Percentage recovery compares the mass recovered with the mass expected; spitting, unwashed residues and damp products are common errors, each with a direction.
Ellen Swallow Richards' water survey and Normal Chlorine Map led to the first state water quality standards in the US; she also founded home economics.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.