Lesson 5 of 6 · 16 min
Classifying substances from property data
Use melting points, electrical conductivity, solubility and hardness data to decide whether a substance is ionic, metallic, covalent molecular or a covalent network, and plan and evaluate the tests that give that data.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the typical properties of each type of substance in one comparison.
- Use a set of property data to determine a substance's structure and bonding, with reasons.
- Plan safe tests of the properties of ionic, metallic and covalent substances, and evaluate the results.
A technician finds five unlabelled jars of solids. Without a formula, you can still work out what kind of substance each one is, because structure and bonding leave fingerprints in the properties: how high the solid melts, whether it conducts as a solid or only when melted or dissolved, how hard it is and whether it dissolves.
This lesson puts the last two lessons together into one method.
| Property | Ionic lattice | Metallic lattice | Covalent molecular | Covalent network |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Particles | Cations and anions | Cations in delocalised electrons | Separate molecules | Atoms in a continuous network |
| Melting point | High | Usually high (varies widely) | Low | Very high |
| Conducts as a solid | No | Yes | No | No (graphite: yes) |
| Conducts as a liquid | Yes | Yes | No | — |
| Conducts in water | Yes, if soluble | Insoluble | Usually no (acids such as HCl react with water and do) | Insoluble |
| Mechanical | Hard and brittle | Malleable and ductile | Soft, if solid | Very hard (graphite: soft) |
A decision path for classifying a solid. Conductivity in the solid and liquid states does most of the work.
Worked example
Classifying five solids from their properties
Determine the structure and bonding of each solid, giving the evidence for each.
| Solid | Melting point (°C) | Conducts as solid | Conducts as liquid or in water | Other observations |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 801 | no | yes (molten and in water) | brittle crystals, dissolves in water |
| B | 1085 | yes | yes (molten) | malleable, insoluble |
| C | 114 | no | no | soft, dissolves in hexane but barely in water |
| D | about 1700 | no | no (molten) | very hard, insoluble in water and hexane |
| E | above 3500 | yes | — | soft and slippery, black, insoluble |
Step 1: A: ionic lattice
High melting point; conducts only when molten or dissolved, so its charged particles are ions that are fixed in the solid and free in the liquid. Brittle and water-soluble fit too. (Sodium chloride.)
Step 2: B: metallic lattice
Conducts as a solid and as a liquid, so it has delocalised electrons; malleable. (Copper.)
Step 3: C: covalent molecular
Low melting point, so only weak forces between molecules are overcome; never conducts, so no mobile charged particles; soft. (Iodine.)
Step 4: D: giant covalent network
Very high melting point, so strong bonds throughout; but it never conducts, even molten, so it has no ions or delocalised electrons. Very hard and insoluble. (Silicon dioxide.)
Step 5: E: giant covalent network with delocalised electrons
Melts only above 3500 °C, so strong covalent bonds throughout, yet it conducts as a solid, is soft and slippery, and is black: graphite, whose layers slide and whose delocalised electrons move along the layers.
E is the trap. Conducting as a solid suggests a metal, but a soft, slippery black solid that is not malleable and melts above 3500 °C fits graphite.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
A ionic (sodium chloride); B metallic (copper); C covalent molecular (iodine); D giant covalent network (silicon dioxide); E giant covalent network, graphite.
Method
Solid conductivity: yes, metallic (or graphite).
Then melting point: low, covalent molecular.
High: conducts molten or in water, ionic; never conducts, covalent network.
Use the other observations to confirm or catch exceptions.
Watch out for
Calling E a metal because it conducts. Check the other columns.
Calling D ionic because of its high melting point.
Substance X melts at 772 °C. The solid does not conduct electricity, but it dissolves in water and the solution conducts. What is the structure and bonding in X?
A conductivity tester. If the substance conducts, the circuit is complete: the globe lights and the ammeter reads a current.
Investigating the properties of ionic, metallic and covalent substances
Observe
Record the appearance (lustre, colour, crystals) of samples such as copper, sodium chloride, sugar (sucrose), paraffin wax and sand (silicon dioxide).
Hardness and brittleness
Try to scratch each sample, and press a crystal with a spatula. Metals dent or bend; ionic crystals shatter; wax is soft.
Melting
Gently heat a small sample of the low-melting solids (wax, sugar) in a test tube in a fume cupboard, and note whether it melts quickly. Do not try to melt salt or sand: their melting points (801 °C and about 1700 °C) are far beyond a Bunsen flame on a test tube. Look up the high values instead.
Solubility
Shake a little of each solid with water, and with a non-polar solvent such as hexane, in a fume cupboard.
Conductivity
Test each solid with the conductivity tester, then each solution in water. Rinse the electrodes with deionised water between tests, and test deionised water on its own as a control.
Why should the student test deionised water on its own with the conductivity tester?
Worked example
Is sugar ionic? Evaluating a student's claim
A student tested solids and their solutions (made with tap water) with a conductivity tester containing an ammeter.
| Test | Current (A) |
|---|---|
| Solid sugar (sucrose) | 0.00 |
| Sugar dissolved in tap water | 0.02 |
| Solid sodium chloride | 0.00 |
| Sodium chloride dissolved in tap water | 0.85 |
The student concluded: "Sugar and sodium chloride are both ionic, because both solutions conducted." Sugar melts (and decomposes) at about 186 °C.
Evaluate the student's conclusion and suggest how to improve the investigation.
Step 1: Look at the size of the currents
The sugar solution's current (0.02 A) is about 40 times smaller than the salt solution's (0.85 A). "Both conducted" hides a huge difference.
Step 2: Identify the flaw in the method
Tap water contains dissolved ions (such as , and ), so it conducts slightly on its own. No control was tested, so the small current with sugar could come entirely from the tap water.
Without a control you cannot tell what part of a result is caused by the variable you are testing.
Step 3: Use the other evidence
Sugar melts at a low temperature (about 186 °C), which fits a covalent molecular substance with weak forces between molecules, not an ionic lattice (sodium chloride melts at 801 °C).
Step 4: Judge the conclusion
The conclusion is valid for sodium chloride (a large current in solution, none as a solid) but not supported for sugar. The evidence points to sugar being covalent molecular: its solution contains neutral molecules, not ions.
Step 5: Suggest improvements
Use deionised water to make the solutions, and test the deionised water alone as a control; rinse the electrodes with deionised water between tests; keep the concentration and electrode spacing the same for each solution; repeat each test.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The conclusion is only partly valid. Sodium chloride's results (0.00 A as a solid, 0.85 A in solution) support ionic bonding. Sugar's tiny current (0.02 A) is most likely due to ions already in the tap water, since no control was tested; with its low melting point, the evidence shows sugar is covalent molecular. Improve by using deionised water with a deionised-water control, rinsing electrodes between tests and controlling concentration.
Method
Compare the sizes of results, not just yes or no.
Look for a missing control or an uncontrolled variable.
Bring in all the evidence (melting point too).
Judge: supported, partly supported or not supported, and why.
Suggest specific improvements.
Watch out for
Agreeing that sugar is ionic because "the ammeter moved".
Suggesting only "repeat the experiment", which would repeat the same flaw.
Common mistake
One property is not enough
A high melting point fits ionic, metallic and network covalent substances. Insolubility in water fits metals, networks and many molecular substances. Use the whole data set, and lean on conductivity: as a solid, as a liquid and in solution. Watch for the exceptions: graphite conducts as a solid; mercury is a metal that is liquid at room temperature; some ionic compounds (such as ) are insoluble in water.
Exam tip
Classifying in a data question
For each substance, quote the data you are using, state the structure type, and link the data to the model: "Substance B conducts as a solid and as a liquid, so it has delocalised electrons that are free to move: a metallic lattice." When a substance doesn't fit perfectly, say which evidence decides and why.
Summary
Conducts as a solid: metallic (or graphite). Conducts only when molten or dissolved: ionic. Never conducts and melts low: covalent molecular. Never conducts and melts very high: covalent network.
Use every column of a data set; a single property rarely decides the structure.
In the practical, use a deionised-water control, rinse electrodes between tests, and don't heat high-melting solids in test tubes.
Explain each classification by linking the data to the particles and forces in the model.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.