Lesson 6 of 12 · 18 min
Species interactions
Explain predation, competition, mutualism, commensalism and parasitism by their effect on each species, and infer interactions from abundance and experimental data.
What you will be able to do
- Explain predation, competition, mutualism, commensalism and parasitism, giving the effect (+, − or 0) on each species.
- Describe and explain the cycles in predator and prey populations.
- Infer the interaction between two species from data on their abundance alone and together.
- Explain why correlation in abundance data suggests but does not prove an interaction, and how an experiment can test it.
On a Great Barrier Reef bommie, a coral polyp shelters algae inside its cells, a cleaner wrasse picks parasites off a coral trout, a staghorn coral and a plate coral grow towards the same patch of light, and a reef shark takes a parrotfish. Every species in a community is tied to others. Ecologists sort these ties by one simple question: does each species gain, lose or stay unaffected?
| Interaction | Species A | Species B | Australian example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Predation (including herbivory) |
| − prey | Dingoes hunting red kangaroos; koalas eating eucalypt leaves |
| Competition | − | − | Introduced honeybees and native birds and bees using the same nectar and tree hollows |
| Mutualism | Reef-building corals and the algae (zooxanthellae) in their tissues; rhizobia (root-nodule bacteria) in wattle roots | ||
| Commensalism | 0 | Staghorn ferns growing high on rainforest trees | |
| Parasitism |
| − host | Paralysis ticks feeding on bandicoots; mistletoe drawing water and nutrients from eucalypts |
Decide the effect on each species first, then the name follows.
Definition
Predation and parasitism
In predation, the predator kills and eats its prey. Herbivory is often treated as a form of predation: the herbivore eats part or all of a plant.
In parasitism, the parasite lives on (ectoparasite, such as a tick) or in (endoparasite, such as a tapeworm) its host and feeds from it over a long period. It harms the host but usually does not kill it quickly, since a dead host is no longer a food source.
Definition
Competition, mutualism and commensalism
Competition happens when organisms need the same limited resource: food, water, light, nesting sites or space. Both lose, because each has less. It is intraspecific between members of one species and interspecific between species.
In mutualism both species benefit. Corals give their algae shelter, carbon dioxide and nutrients; the algae give the coral sugars from photosynthesis, much of the food the coral needs.
In commensalism one species benefits and the other is unaffected. A staghorn fern gets a perch in the light; the tree, as far as anyone can measure, neither gains nor loses.
Mistletoe attaches to the branches of a eucalypt and draws water and minerals from its xylem. Heavily infested branches can die back. Name this interaction.
Predator–prey cycles. When prey are plentiful, predators have plenty of food, breed well and increase. More predators eat more prey, so the prey population falls. With less food, predators then starve or breed less and decline. With fewer predators, prey recover, and the cycle repeats. The predator population lags behind the prey, and it is usually smaller, because of the energy lost between trophic levels.
The classic example is the snowshoe hare and the Canada lynx, whose numbers were recorded for nearly a century from the furs traded to the Hudson's Bay Company in Canada. Both cycled roughly every 10 years, with the lynx peaks a year or two after the hare peaks. (Later studies showed that the hares' food plants also drive the cycle: real cycles usually have more than one cause.)
A predator–prey cycle (model data). The predator population peaks after the prey and is smaller.
Play the model. Where on the prey curve does the predator population start to fall? Then change the predation rate and watch the cycle change.
Using the predator–prey graph, explain why the predator population falls a few years after the prey population starts to fall.
Inferring interactions from data. A data test often gives the abundance or growth of two species measured alone and together and asks you to name the interaction. Compare each species' result together with its result alone:
- Both do better together → mutualism.
- Both do worse together → competition.
- One does better, the other worse → predation or parasitism.
- One does better, the other the same → commensalism.
Worked example
Classify interactions from growth data
Three pairs of species were each studied alone and together. The table gives a measure of each species' success (population size or growth) under each condition.
| Pair | Species A alone | Species A together | Species B alone | Species B together |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1: two grass species in pots | ||||
| 2: a black ant and a sap-sucking bug on a wattle | ||||
| 3: an orchid and the tree it grows on |
For pair 3, the orchid is A (its success is its biomass, in g, which is zero alone because it cannot establish on the ground) and the tree is B (its growth in cm per year).
Name the interaction in each pair and justify each with the data.
Step 1: Pair 1
A falls from alone to together; B falls from to . Both are harmed (−/−): competition, probably for light, water and soil nutrients.
Step 2: Pair 2
The ants increase from to and the bugs from to . Both benefit (+/+): mutualism. (Ants commonly protect sap-sucking bugs from predators and feed on the sugary honeydew they excrete.)
Step 3: Pair 3
The orchid grows only on the tree ( → , +), and the tree's growth is the same either way (, 0). One benefits, the other is unaffected (+/0): commensalism.
Step 4: Comment on the evidence
The conclusions rest on single values. Replicates (several pots or trees per treatment) and a statistical comparison would show whether differences such as and are really equal, or whether small effects are being missed.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Pair 1 competition (both lower together); pair 2 mutualism (both higher together); pair 3 commensalism (the orchid benefits, the tree's growth is unchanged).
Method
Compare each species together with alone: higher (+), lower (−) or the same (0).
Combine the two signs: +/+ mutualism, −/− competition, +/− predation or parasitism, +/0 commensalism.
Quote the numbers for both species.
Watch out for
Comparing species A with species B instead of each species with itself alone.
Naming the interaction without giving the effect on each species.
Correlation in field data. In the field you usually can't grow species apart. Instead you record the abundance of both species in many quadrats or over many years and look for a correlation:
- A negative correlation (where one is common, the other is rare) suggests competition, or a predator keeping its prey down.
- A positive correlation (they rise and fall together) suggests mutualism, or a consumer tracking its food.
But a correlation does not show cause. Both species might respond to a shared abiotic factor (soil moisture, shade, salinity) without interacting at all. The test is a manipulative experiment: remove one species from some plots (or fence it out), leave matched control plots alone, replicate, and measure the other species over time.
Students count two species of snail in 30 quadrats on a rocky shore. Quadrats with many of species P have few of species Q. Which conclusion is best supported?
Common mistake
Parasite or predator?
Both are +/−. A predator kills its prey, usually quickly, and eats many prey in its lifetime. A parasite feeds on a living host, often for a long time, and usually doesn't kill it. A mosquito taking a blood meal is closer to a parasite; a dingo killing a wallaby is a predator.
Exam tip
Naming an interaction from data
Name the interaction, give the effect on each species with numbers from the data, and use the "alone" values as the comparison: "Species A reached 420 alone but only 180 with B; B reached 300 alone and 110 with A. Both are harmed, so they compete."
Summary
Predation (+/−): the predator kills and eats prey. Herbivory is a form of it.
Parasitism (+/−): the parasite feeds on a living host, harming but not usually killing it quickly.
Competition (−/−) for limited resources is intraspecific or interspecific. Mutualism is +/+; commensalism is +/0.
Predator and prey populations cycle, with the predator peaks lagging and smaller.
Compare each species together with alone to classify an interaction from data.
Correlation in abundance data suggests an interaction; a replicated removal experiment with controls tests it.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.