Lesson 8 of 12 · 20 min
Keystone species and predicting removals
Explain how keystone species maintain community structure, identify them from food webs and removal data, predict the effects of removing a species, and weigh up single-species conservation.
What you will be able to do
- Explain what makes a species a keystone species, with examples.
- Identify a keystone species from removal experiments or population data.
- Predict the direct and indirect effects of removing a species from a food web.
- Evaluate the use of keystone, flagship and umbrella species in conservation.
In a stone arch, the keystone at the top is one stone among many, but pull it out and the whole arch falls. Some species hold communities together the same way. They are not always abundant, and they are not always large, but take them away and the community changes beyond recognition.
Definition
Keystone species
A keystone species has an effect on the structure of its community that is much larger than its abundance or biomass would suggest. Removing it causes large changes in the species present, their numbers and the habitat.
Keystone species may be predators that stop one prey species from taking over, pollinators or seed dispersers that many plants depend on, or ecosystem engineers that create habitat for others.
Paine's sea stars. In the 1960s Robert Paine removed the predatory sea star Pisaster ochraceus from a stretch of rocky shore at Mukkaw Bay in Washington, USA, and left a nearby stretch untouched as a control. Without Pisaster, barnacles and then mussels spread over the bare rock and crowded out other space-holding species. Within a few years the number of species in the removal area fell from 15 to 8, while the control area stayed diverse (Paine 1966). Pisaster preys mainly on the mussel, the dominant competitor for space, so it keeps space open for many other species. Paine introduced the term keystone species in 1969.
Kelp forests and trophic cascades. Off the Pacific coast of North America, sea otters eat sea urchins, which graze kelp. Where the fur trade wiped out otters, urchins multiplied and grazed the kelp down to bare rock, "urchin barrens", losing the fish and invertebrates that lived among the kelp. Where otters returned, kelp recovered. A change at the top that passes down a food web like this is a trophic cascade.
Australia has its own version. Off eastern Tasmania, the long-spined sea urchin (Centrostephanus rodgersii) has spread south as waters warmed, and it creates barrens in kelp beds. Large southern rock lobsters (Jasus edwardsii) are among the few predators able to eat it, and Scott Ling and colleagues (2009) found that reefs where fishing has removed most large lobsters are more prone to barrens.
A simplified temperate reef food web. Arrows point from the food to the feeder.
Predicting the effects of removing a species
Find what it eats
Its prey (or food plants) lose a consumer, so they are likely to increase.
Find what eats it
Its predators lose a food source, so they are likely to decrease, or switch to other prey, which then decrease.
Find its competitors
Species that share its food are released from competition and may increase.
Follow the knock-on effects
Each change spreads one more step: a prey species that increases will eat more of its food. State each effect with its reason.
Qualify the prediction
Say what it depends on: whether a predator can switch to other prey, whether other species can take over its role, and the time scale.
For each removal, read which species increase and which decrease, and trace why through the arrows. Then try the eucalypt woodland and the coral reef.
Use the kelp bed food web. Predict the most likely effect on the small reef fish if rock lobsters are fished out of the area.
Worked example
Is this sea star a keystone species?
On a rocky shore, ecologists removed a predatory sea star by hand from five plots each year, and left five similar plots as controls. The sea star made up less than of the animal biomass on the shore.
| Year | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mean species richness, control plots | ||||
| Mean species richness, removal plots | ||||
| Mean mussel cover, removal plots (%) |
(a) Calculate the percentage change in species richness in the removal plots from year 0 to year 3. (b) Use the data to justify that the sea star is a keystone species. (c) Explain the mechanism that links the removal to the loss of species. (d) State one limitation of the conclusion.
Step 1: Percentage change
Step 2: Compare with the controls
Richness in the control plots stayed at – species, so the fall to in the removal plots is due to the removal, not to weather or season.
Step 3: Effect out of proportion to abundance
The sea star is under of the animal biomass, yet removing it halved species richness in three years. A large effect on community structure relative to its abundance is the definition of a keystone species.
Step 4: Mechanism
The sea star preys on mussels, the dominant competitor for space on the rock. Without it, mussel cover rose from to . The mussels outcompeted and smothered other space-holding species (barnacles, algae, limpets), which were excluded: predation on the dominant competitor had been preventing competitive exclusion.
Step 5: Limitation
The study covers one shore and three years; the effect may differ on sheltered shores, or the community may change further. Mussel beds also provide habitat for small animals that may not have been counted in species richness.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) . (b) Removal halved richness while controls stayed at 14–15, though the sea star is under 3 % of biomass. (c) It eats the dominant competitor (mussels); without it mussels covered 80 % of the rock and excluded other species. (d) One site and three years; small mussel-bed animals may not be counted.
Method
Percentage change = (new − original) ÷ original × 100.
Compare treatment with control to attribute the change to the removal.
Keystone = large effect relative to abundance; explain the mechanism through the food web.
Watch out for
Forgetting the minus sign for a decrease.
Not using the control plots as evidence.
Not only predators. In the Wet Tropics of Queensland, the southern cassowary (Casuarius casuarius johnsonii) swallows the fruits of well over a hundred rainforest plant species whole and deposits the seeds in a pile of dung, sometimes more than a kilometre away (Westcott and colleagues 2005; Bradford and colleagues 2008). Some trees have fruits so large that few other living animals in the forest can swallow them, so the cassowary is likely to be their main long-distance seed disperser. Flying foxes pollinate eucalypts and carry seeds over long distances. Each may have an effect on forest structure out of all proportion to its numbers.
Calling a species "keystone" is a hypothesis, tested with data: removal or exclusion experiments, comparisons of sites with and without the species, or long-term records before and after it disappeared.
Which observation would be the strongest evidence that species K is a keystone species?
History
Keystone, flagship and umbrella species in conservation
Conservation money is limited, and since Paine's work many biologists have argued for focusing on keystone species, because protecting them protects the structure of the whole community. Two other single-species approaches are common:
- A flagship species is charismatic and wins public support and funding: the koala, the cassowary, the platypus.
- An umbrella species needs so much habitat that protecting enough for it also protects many other species living there.
Not everyone agrees these work. Critics point out that a species can be keystone in one place and not another; that money for one charismatic species may not help the invertebrates, fungi and plants that keep an ecosystem functioning; that habitat for an umbrella species may not include the specialised habitats of other threatened species; and that a single-species focus can miss processes such as fire regimes, water flows or nutrient cycling. Many agencies now combine species programs with whole-ecosystem or landscape approaches.
A council proposes to protect one large area of forest because it is home to a population of koalas, arguing that this will also protect the forest's other species. Evaluate this proposal in about 100 words.
Common mistake
Keystone does not mean dominant
A species with a large effect simply because there is a lot of it (such as the dominant eucalypt in a forest, or the coral in a reef) is a dominant or foundation species, not a keystone in Paine's sense. The point of a keystone is that its effect is disproportionate to its abundance.
Exam tip
Removal questions
Give the effect on each species asked about, the direction (increase or decrease) and the reason through the food web ("because its predator has been removed", "because its food source has decreased"). Where the outcome depends on something the data don't show, say so: "if the owls can switch to other prey…".
Summary
A keystone species has an effect on community structure out of proportion to its abundance or biomass.
Paine's removal of Pisaster sea stars let mussels dominate and cut species from 15 to 8; otters, urchins and kelp show a trophic cascade.
Keystones can be predators, pollinators, seed dispersers (the southern cassowary) or ecosystem engineers.
To predict a removal: prey increase, predators decrease, competitors are released, then follow the knock-on effects and give reasons.
Keystone status is tested with removal experiments, site comparisons and before-and-after records.
Keystone, flagship and umbrella approaches focus conservation on one species; critics argue they can miss other species and ecosystem processes.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.