Lesson 12 of 12 · 20 min
Comparing ecosystems across space and time
Interpret survey, fossil, pollen and sediment data to compare ecosystems between places and over time, and see how First Nations knowledges of environmental change inform land management.
What you will be able to do
- Interpret ecological data to compare ecosystems at different places (spatial scales) and times (temporal scales).
- Judge whether a comparison is valid by checking methods, sampling effort and variables.
- Explain how fossils, pollen, charcoal and sedimentary rock characteristics provide evidence of past ecosystems.
- Describe how First Nations peoples' knowledges of environmental change inform land management, including fire.
Is a rainforest more productive than a woodland? Has a reef recovered since the last bleaching? What grew on the Atherton Tableland before people arrived? Each question compares ecosystems: across space (different places at the same time) or across time (the same place at different times, from seasons to millions of years). Data tests ask you to make these comparisons and to say how far the data support them.
Definition
Spatial and temporal scales
A spatial comparison looks at ecosystems in different places: two sites along a gradient, a burnt and an unburnt patch, Queensland's wet and dry tropics.
A temporal comparison looks at one ecosystem at different times: before and after an event, across seasons, over decades of monitoring, or over thousands to millions of years using fossils and sediments.
A chronosequence substitutes space for time: sites of different known ages (such as sand dunes formed at different times) are compared to infer how one site would change over time. The great dune systems of K'gari (Fraser Island) and Cooloola are a famous example.
| Measure | Site A (burnt 2 years ago) | Site B (unburnt for 25 years) |
|---|---|---|
| Plant species richness (per quadrat, mean) | 34 | 21 |
| Ground-layer cover (%) | 62 | 28 |
| Litter depth (cm, mean) | 1.2 | 6.8 |
| Tree canopy cover (%) | 35 | 58 |
| Above-ground biomass (t ha⁻¹) | 96 | 148 |
Using the survey table, which conclusion is best supported by the data?
Tip
Is the comparison valid?
Before you compare two data sets, check that they were collected the same way: the same sampling method and quadrat size, the same sampling effort (number of quadrats, hours of trapping), the same season and time of day, and the same units. Compare per unit area or means, not totals from different-sized samples. Look for replicates (more than one site of each kind): with one site each, a difference could be due to anything else that differs between the two places.
Evidence of past ecosystems: fossils. Fossils are the remains or traces (footprints, burrows, leaf impressions) of past organisms, usually preserved in sedimentary rock. A group of fossils found together, a fossil assemblage, shows which species lived together. At Riversleigh, in Boodjamulla National Park in north-west Queensland, limestone deposits hold the fossils of hundreds of animal species from about 25 to 15 million years ago, including many rainforest species, in country that is now dry savanna. Together they show that this region once supported rainforest.
| Rock characteristic | What it indicates |
|---|---|
| Coarse grains (conglomerate, coarse sandstone) | Fast-flowing water: rivers, steep streams, beaches |
| Very fine grains (mudstone, shale) | Still water: lakes, lagoons, deep sea |
| Coal | Swamps or wetlands with dense plant growth, buried before the plants decomposed |
| Limestone with coral or shell fossils | Warm, shallow, clear seas (reefs) |
| Ripple marks | Moving water or wind over sand: a shallow shore, river bed or dune |
| Mud cracks | Wet mud that dried out: seasonal pools or tidal flats |
| Salt and gypsum layers (evaporites) | Shallow water evaporating in a hot, dry climate |
Pollen and charcoal in lake sediments. Pollen grains have tough walls and shapes distinctive to each plant group, and they settle into lake and swamp mud year after year. A sediment core drilled from the lake bed is a timeline: the deeper the layer, the older it is (dated by radiocarbon and other methods). Counting pollen types in each layer shows how the vegetation changed; counting charcoal shows how often there were fires.
Lynch's Crater, a swamp-filled volcanic crater on the Atherton Tableland, holds one of the longest such records in Australia. Rule and colleagues (2012) also counted the spores of a fungus (Sporormiella) that grows on the dung of large herbivores. In their core, the spores fell sharply around 41 000 years ago, suggesting that megafauna declined then. A rise in charcoal and a change from rainforest to more fire-tolerant sclerophyll vegetation followed after the decline. The authors argued that the loss of large browsers let fuel build up and changed the vegetation, though how far Sporormiella tracks megafauna is still debated.
Worked example
Read a pollen and charcoal core
A sediment core was taken from a swamp on a tableland in north Queensland. The table summarises the pollen and charcoal in five layers (illustrative data based on the kind of record such cores give).
| Depth (m) | Age (thousand years ago) | Rainforest pollen (%) | Eucalypt and other sclerophyll pollen (%) | Grass pollen (%) | Charcoal (particles per ) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
(a) Describe how the vegetation changed between 60 000 and 25 000 years ago. (b) Describe the relationship between charcoal and the type of vegetation. (c) Propose an explanation for the change, and state what other evidence would help test it. (d) Give two limitations of using pollen percentages to reconstruct past vegetation.
Step 1: Read the core from the bottom up
Deeper layers are older, so read from (60 000 years ago) upwards.
Step 2: Vegetation change
Rainforest pollen fell from (60 000 years ago) to (25 000 years ago), while sclerophyll pollen rose from to and grass from to . The biggest change was between 45 000 and 38 000 years ago. The vegetation changed from rainforest to more open, fire-tolerant sclerophyll forest and woodland.
Step 3: Charcoal and vegetation
Charcoal rose from – to – particles per at the same time as sclerophyll and grass pollen increased: more fire is associated with more fire-tolerant vegetation (a positive correlation), and rainforest pollen is highest when charcoal is lowest.
Step 4: Possible explanation
More frequent fire (from a drier climate, or from changed burning after people arrived, or from fuel building up after large herbivores declined) killed fire-sensitive rainforest plants and favoured fire-tolerant eucalypts and grasses. To test between these, look for climate evidence in the same layers (for example, other indicators of rainfall), dung-fungus spores (Sporormiella) as a record of large herbivores, and archaeological dates for human arrival in the region.
Step 5: Limitations
Plants produce and disperse different amounts of pollen (wind-pollinated eucalypts and grasses produce far more than many animal-pollinated rainforest trees), so percentages do not equal cover. Pollen can blow in from far away. Dates of layers carry uncertainty, and a correlation between charcoal and vegetation does not show which caused which.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Rainforest pollen fell from 78 % to 22 % and sclerophyll and grass pollen rose, mostly between 45 000 and 38 000 years ago. (b) Charcoal rose as sclerophyll and grass pollen rose: more fire with more fire-tolerant vegetation. (c) Increased fire (climate, people or megafaunal decline) favoured fire-tolerant plants; test with climate proxies, Sporormiella and archaeological dates. (d) Unequal pollen production and dispersal; long-distance pollen; dating uncertainty; correlation not cause.
Method
Deeper is older: read a core from the bottom up.
Describe change with numbers and identify when it was fastest.
Treat links between records as correlations and name evidence that could test the cause.
Watch out for
Reading the core top-down as if the top were oldest.
Stating that people caused the change as a fact.
A geologist finds a seam of coal containing fossil leaves and stems of Glossopteris, an extinct plant, in Queensland's Bowen Basin. What does this most likely show about the past ecosystem?
First Nations knowledges of environmental change. Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples have observed and managed Australian ecosystems for more than 60 000 years, and much of that knowledge is held and passed on today through Country, story, language, song and practice. It includes detailed, long-term data on the timing of flowering, animal breeding and migration, rainfall and fire, and on how species respond to each other and to the land.
Some of this knowledge spans very long periods. Patrick Nunn and Nicholas Reid (2016) compared Aboriginal stories from 21 places around Australia's coast that describe the sea flooding land that was once dry. The water depths the stories imply match the sea-level rise at the end of the last ice age, suggesting the stories have been passed on for more than 7000 years.
Seasonal calendars. Many communities describe the year by ecological events rather than months. In Kakadu, the Bininj/Mungguy calendar has six seasons. Burning begins early in the dry season, as the country dries out, with small, patchy fires lit in strategic places; in the Ngurrungurrudjba (Yellow Water) calendar the start of woodland burning is tied to the flowering of a particular eucalypt (Eucalyptus miniata). The calendar links an abiotic change (drying) to a biotic signal (flowering) to a management action.
Key idea
Cultural burning holds country at a successional stage
Cultural burning uses frequent, cool, low-intensity, patchy fires, lit at the right time of year for each kind of country. They burn the grass and litter but not the canopy, creating a mosaic of patches burnt at different times. This:
- removes fuel, so the hot, destructive fires of the late dry season have less to burn;
- keeps open grassy woodland open, stopping dense shrubs or rainforest species from taking over (holding the community at a chosen successional point);
- gives a mix of fresh regrowth and older unburnt refuges, supporting a high diversity of plants and animals.
Burn patches at different times and watch the landscape become a mosaic of successional stages, each with its own plants and animals.
These practices continue and are growing. Victor Steffensen, a Tagalaka man from north Queensland, learned fire management from the Kuku Thaypan Elders Dr Tommy George and Dr George Musgrave on their Country near Laura, on Cape York Peninsula. He co-founded the Firesticks Alliance and wrote Fire Country (2020), and now works with communities across Australia on "right fire for the right country".
In western Arnhem Land, the West Arnhem Land Fire Abatement (WALFA) project, run by Aboriginal ranger groups since 2006, shifts burning to the early dry season. It has reduced the area burnt by late dry season wildfires and the greenhouse gases they release, and its method became the basis for savanna burning carbon projects across northern Australia.
Explain how early dry season cool burning can maintain an open grassy woodland at a particular successional stage.
Note
Respectful use of First Nations knowledges
Knowledge belongs to particular peoples and Country. When you write about it, name the people or Country your source names, describe the practice specifically, use the present tense where the practice continues, and present knowledge holders as experts in their own right, not as sources of "data" for science to validate.
Exam tip
Comparing data sets
Compare like with like and quote numbers from both ("species richness was 34 at Site A but 21 at Site B"). State the trend or difference, suggest a cause using biology, and give a limitation: one site each, different seasons, unequal sampling effort, or correlation rather than cause.
Summary
Ecosystems are compared across space (different places) and time (seasons to millions of years); chronosequences substitute space for time.
Valid comparisons need the same methods, sampling effort, season and units, with replicate sites.
Fossil assemblages show which organisms lived together; sedimentary rock type, grain size, coal, limestone, ripple marks and mud cracks show the past environment.
Pollen, charcoal and dung-fungus spores in dated sediment cores record changes in vegetation, fire and megafauna, as at Lynch's Crater.
First Nations knowledges hold long-term observations of environmental change; seasonal calendars link abiotic and biotic signals to land management.
Cool, patchy, early dry season burning reduces late-season wildfires and holds country at chosen successional stages.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.