Lesson 7 of 12 · 16 min
Niches and competitive exclusion
Describe a species' ecological niche, distinguish fundamental and realised niches, and explain the competitive exclusion principle and resource partitioning with experimental and field data.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the ecological niche of a species in terms of its habitat, resources, activity, tolerances and interactions.
- Distinguish between fundamental and realised niches.
- Explain the competitive exclusion principle using Gause's and Connell's experiments.
- Explain how resource partitioning lets similar species coexist, and interpret zonation data from an investigation.
If a species' habitat is its address, its niche is its profession: what it eats, where and when it feeds, what conditions it can tolerate, and how it affects and is affected by other species. Two species can share an address. This lesson is about why they can't, in the long run, share a profession.
Definition
Ecological niche
The ecological niche of a species is its role in the ecosystem: the full set of biotic and abiotic conditions and resources it needs and uses, including its habitat, food, the time and place it is active, the range of temperature, moisture or salinity it tolerates, and its interactions with other species.
The fundamental niche is the whole range a species could occupy with no competitors or predators. The realised niche is the part it actually occupies, usually smaller, because other species exclude it from some of it.
For example, the niche of the koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) includes eucalypt woodland and forest on fertile soils, a diet of the leaves of a limited range of eucalypt species (it is a specialist), resting for most of the day and feeding mainly at night, a liver and gut microbes that cope with the toxins in eucalypt leaves, and interactions with dingoes and large owls as predators and with Chlamydia bacteria as a disease.
Key idea
The competitive exclusion principle
Two species that compete for the same limited resources in the same way cannot coexist indefinitely. The species that uses the resource more efficiently will increase, and the other will be driven to local extinction, unless the niches of the two species diverge.
This is also called Gause's principle, after the Russian ecologist Georgy Gause.
Gause's experiments (1934). Gause grew two species of the protist Paramecium in test tubes of culture medium, fed on bacteria. Grown separately, Paramecium aurelia and P. caudatum each grew to a stable population. Grown together, P. aurelia kept increasing while P. caudatum declined until it disappeared. The two used the same food in the same place, and P. aurelia was the better competitor.
When Gause instead paired P. caudatum with P. bursaria, both survived. P. bursaria fed mainly at the bottom of the tube and P. caudatum in the liquid above: their niches differed enough to coexist.
Two Paramecium species grown together (shape of Gause's results, illustrative values). P. caudatum is excluded.
What do Gause's results for P. aurelia and P. caudatum grown together show?
Connell's barnacles. On rocky shores in Scotland, Joseph Connell (1961) studied two barnacles. Chthamalus lived only high on the shore and Balanus lower down, although Chthamalus larvae settled in both zones. When he removed Balanus from rocks low on the shore, Chthamalus survived and grew there. When Balanus was present, it smothered, undercut and crushed the Chthamalus.
So the fundamental niche of Chthamalus covers the upper and lower shore, but competition with Balanus restricts its realised niche to the upper shore. Balanus is kept off the upper shore by an abiotic factor: it dries out at low tide.
Chthamalus could live on the whole shore (fundamental niche) but competition with Balanus restricts it to the upper shore (realised niche).
In Connell's study, what restricts the realised niche of Chthamalus to the upper shore?
Resource partitioning. Similar species that live together usually turn out to divide resources between them. In North American spruce forests, Robert MacArthur (1958) found five similar warbler species feeding in the same trees, but each foraged mostly in a different zone: the tips of the upper branches, the inner trunk area, the lower branches, and so on. On a reef, several species of butterflyfish that all eat coral specialise on different coral species.
By dividing a resource in space, time or size, each species reduces its competition with the others, and their realised niches no longer overlap completely.
Start with complete niche overlap and run the model. Then reduce the overlap or switch on resource partitioning.
Worked example
Lichens on a tree trunk and competitive exclusion
Students investigated vertical zonation on the trunks of ten paperbark trees (Melaleuca quinquenervia) beside a lagoon. On each trunk they placed a quadrat at the centre of each height band on the side facing the water, and recorded the percentage cover of two crustose lichen species.
| Height band (m) | – | – | – | – |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lichen P, mean cover (%) | ||||
| Lichen Q, mean cover (%) |
(a) Describe the distribution of the two lichens. (b) The students concluded that competition between P and Q causes the zonation. Evaluate this conclusion. (c) Propose a modification to the investigation that would test it.
Step 1: Describe the pattern with data
Lichen P is most abundant at the base ( at –) and decreases with height to at –. Lichen Q shows the opposite: at the base, rising to at the top. The two trends cross between the – and – bands, where both species are common.
Step 2: What supports the conclusion
The two species largely replace each other along the trunk (a negative relationship), which is what competitive exclusion would produce: each may be the better competitor in its own zone, giving each a realised niche narrower than its fundamental niche.
Step 3: What weakens the conclusion
The data are correlational. Abiotic factors change with height on a trunk beside water: humidity, splash, shade and bark texture. P may simply need the wetter base and Q the drier, brighter upper trunk, with no competition at all. The survey also used only one side of each trunk and one season.
"Evaluate" needs both sides and a judgement.
Step 4: Judgement
The conclusion is plausible but not supported by these data alone: they show zonation, not its cause.
Step 5: Modify the investigation
Run a removal experiment: on each tree, scrape lichen P from marked squares in its zone and leave matched squares untouched as controls; do the same for Q in its zone. Record the cover of the other species in each square every few months for a year. At the same time, measure light intensity and humidity in each height band with data loggers. If Q spreads into cleared squares in P's zone (and vice versa), competition is excluding it; if not, abiotic factors are the likelier cause.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) P decreases with height (52 % → 2 %), Q increases (3 % → 47 %). (b) Consistent with competitive exclusion, but correlational: an abiotic gradient (moisture, light) could explain it, so the conclusion is not yet justified. (c) A replicated removal experiment with controls, plus abiotic measurements in each band.
Method
Describe each species' trend with numbers from the data.
Separate pattern (correlation) from cause (competition or abiotic factors).
Test competition by removing one species and watching the other, with controls and replicates.
Watch out for
Treating zonation as proof of competition.
Suggesting "more trees" as the only improvement when the problem is the type of evidence.
Students found that two lichen species on a tree trunk occupy different heights, and concluded that competition causes the zonation. Suggest one experiment that would test this conclusion.
Common mistake
Habitat is not niche
Two species can share a habitat (the same tree, the same reef) and still have different niches. Competitive exclusion only applies when the niches overlap closely in a resource that is in short supply.
Exam tip
Explaining competitive exclusion
A full answer states the principle (same limited resource, used the same way, cannot coexist indefinitely), names the outcome (the better competitor excludes the other or the niches diverge through resource partitioning), and uses evidence: "When grown alone, both species … ; together, only …".
Summary
A niche is a species' role: habitat, resources, activity times, tolerances and interactions.
The fundamental niche is what a species could occupy; the realised niche is what it does occupy, narrowed by competitors and predators.
Competitive exclusion: two species competing for the same limited resource in the same way cannot coexist indefinitely.
Gause's Paramecium and Connell's barnacles are the classic evidence; removal experiments test for competition.
Resource partitioning by place, time or size lets similar species coexist.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.