Lesson 3 of 12 · 18 min

Productivity and transfer efficiency

Calculate gross and net productivity, consumer energy budgets and the efficiency of energy transfer between trophic levels, and explain where the energy goes.

What you will be able to do

  • Calculate GPP, NPP or producer respiration using NPP = GPP − R.
  • Use a consumer's energy budget (ingested, egested, assimilated, respired, stored) to find its gross and net productivity.
  • Calculate the efficiency of energy or biomass transfer between trophic levels from a food chain or energy flow diagram.
  • Explain why only about 10 % of energy passes to the next trophic level and why food chains are short.

A hectare of good Queensland pasture might carry one beef steer. The same hectare planted with grain could feed many more people directly. The reason is numerical: at every step up a food chain, most of the energy is lost. This lesson puts numbers on that.

Definition

Primary productivity

Gross primary productivity (GPP): the rate at which producers fix light energy as chemical energy by photosynthesis.

Respiration (RR): the energy producers release in their own respiration, which ends up as heat.

Net primary productivity (NPP): the rate at which energy is stored in new producer biomass. It is all that consumers and decomposers can ever get.

Net primary productivity
NPP=GPP−R\text{NPP} = \text{GPP} - R

Productivity is a rate, so it always carries units of energy (or biomass) per area per time: kJ m−2 y−1\mathrm{kJ\,m^{-2}\,y^{-1}}, or g m−2 y−1\mathrm{g\,m^{-2}\,y^{-1}} of dry biomass. Tropical rainforests and coral reefs have some of the highest NPP per square metre on Earth; deserts and the open ocean some of the lowest.

Producers typically use between about a third and two-thirds of their GPP in respiration. Trees in a warm rainforest respire a large share to maintain big trunks and roots; a fast-growing crop stores more of its GPP.

The GPP of a seagrass meadow in Moreton Bay is 35 000 kJ m−2 y−135\,000\unit{kJ\,m^{-2}\,y^{-1}}, and the seagrass uses 21 000 kJ m−2 y−121\,000\unit{kJ\,m^{-2}\,y^{-1}} in respiration. Calculate its NPP, in kJ m−2 y−1\mathrm{kJ\,m^{-2}\,y^{-1}}.

in kJ m -2 y -1

Consumers have an energy budget too. Not everything an animal eats is digested. The undigested part leaves as faeces (egested) and goes to decomposers. The part absorbed across the gut wall is assimilated. Of the assimilated energy, most is respired for movement, maintenance and (in mammals and birds) body heat. Only what remains is stored in new tissue: growth and reproduction. That stored energy is what the next trophic level can eat.

One day in the energy budget of a common brushtail possum (illustrative values). Gross productivity is the assimilated energy; net productivity is the energy stored in new tissue.

A consumer's energy budget
TermRelationshipPossum example (kJ per day)
Assimilated (gross productivity)ingested − egested2000−700=13002000 - 700 = 1300
Net productivity (new tissue)assimilated − respiration1300−1260=401300 - 1260 = 40
Lost as heatrespiration12601260

Note

Warm-blooded animals store less

The possum stores only about 401300×100≈3 %\frac{40}{1300} \times 100 \approx 3\,\% of the energy it assimilates. Mammals and birds (endotherms) respire much of their food just to keep warm. Reptiles, fish and insects (ectotherms) take their heat from the environment and typically store a much larger share of what they assimilate as new tissue. So a kilogram of food grows more lizard than possum.

Key idea

Transfer efficiency

The efficiency of energy transfer between two trophic levels is

transfer efficiency=energy at the higher trophic levelenergy at the lower trophic level×100 %\text{transfer efficiency} = \frac{\text{energy at the higher trophic level}}{\text{energy at the lower trophic level}} \times 100\,\%

The same formula gives the efficiency of biomass transfer. In most ecosystems it is roughly 10 %, with a range of about 5–20 %. Use the measure of energy the question gives at each level (GPP, NPP, assimilated energy) and say which you used.

Energy flow through a grassland, in kJ m−2 y−1\mathrm{kJ\,m^{-2}\,y^{-1}} (illustrative data). Every box except the decomposers ends in respiration lost as heat.

Use the grassland energy flow diagram. Calculate the efficiency of energy transfer from herbivores to carnivores.

in \%

Using the same diagram, calculate the efficiency of energy transfer from producers to herbivores, based on the producers' GPP. Give your answer to one decimal place.

in \%

Round to 1 decimal place.

Worked example

GPP, NPP and a beef herd's energy budget

  • Complex familiar
  • Technology active

A Queensland pasture grazed by beef cattle was studied for a year. All values are in kJ m−2 y−1\mathrm{kJ\,m^{-2}\,y^{-1}}.

MeasurementEnergy
GPP of the pasture30 00030\,000
Respiration of the pasture plants18 00018\,000
Energy in the grass eaten by cattle3 0003\,000
Energy in cattle faeces1 2001\,200
Respiration of the cattle1 7101\,710

Calculate (a) the NPP of the pasture, (b) the energy assimilated by the cattle, (c) the net productivity of the cattle, (d) the percentage of the pasture's NPP that is assimilated by the cattle, and (e) the percentage of the energy the cattle eat that ends up in new tissue. (f) Explain why your answer to (e) is so small.

6 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. NPP = GPP − R.

  2. Assimilated = ingested − egested; net productivity = assimilated − respiration.

  3. Efficiency = higher ÷ lower × 100, using the measures the question names.

Watch out for

  • Using GPP instead of NPP in (d).

  • Subtracting respiration from the energy ingested instead of the energy assimilated.

Interactive

Change the transfer efficiency

Drag the sliders and watch the respiration losses. Then switch to Odum's Silver Springs data and calculate a transfer efficiency yourself.

Where does the other 90 % go? At every level:

  1. Not all of the lower level is eaten: roots, bark, bones and whole organisms die uneaten and go to decomposers.
  2. Not all that is eaten is assimilated: indigestible parts such as cellulose, fur and chitin are egested.
  3. Most of what is assimilated is respired, and that energy is lost as heat.

Only the energy stored in new tissue is available to the next level. This is why food chains rarely have more than four or five trophic levels: by the fifth, there is too little energy left per square metre to support a population of large predators.

Which statement best explains why food chains rarely have more than five trophic levels?

Choose one answer

Common mistake

Efficiencies above 100 %

If you get an efficiency above 100 %, you have divided the wrong way. Energy can only decrease up a food chain, so the higher level always goes on top. Also check the units match: don't divide a value in kJ m−2 y−1\mathrm{kJ\,m^{-2}\,y^{-1}} by one in kJ m−2 d−1\mathrm{kJ\,m^{-2}\,d^{-1}}.

Exam tip

Calculations in the data test

Show the formula, the substitution and the answer with its unit or %. Round only at the end, to the decimal places asked for. If the question doesn't say which measure of energy to use for the producers, state your choice ("using the GPP, …"). Then interpret: "only 6 % of the energy fixed by producers reaches the herbivores; most is lost as heat in plant respiration or passes to decomposers."

Summary

  • NPP = GPP − R. GPP is the rate of energy fixation; NPP is the energy stored in new biomass, available to consumers and decomposers.

  • A consumer's gross productivity is its assimilated energy (ingested − egested); its net productivity is assimilated − respired, the energy stored in new tissue.

  • Transfer efficiency = (energy at the higher level ÷ energy at the lower level) × 100, typically about 10 % (5–20 %).

  • Energy not passed on is lost as heat in respiration, or passes to decomposers in faeces, uneaten parts and dead organisms.

  • Endotherms store a smaller share of assimilated energy than ectotherms, because they respire more to keep warm.

  • Large losses at every transfer limit food chains to about four or five trophic levels.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 4 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 3 of 120% read

Save your progress with a free account