Lesson 1 of 8 · 15 min
Sense of community
Explain how membership, influence, integration and fulfilment of needs, and shared emotional connection lead to a sense of community, using McMillan and Chavis's (1986) theory.
What you will be able to do
- Define a sense of community.
- Describe membership, influence, integration and fulfilment of needs, and shared emotional connection.
- Explain how each element, in a real group, leads to a sense of community.
- Explain why McMillan and Chavis needed evidence from several disciplines to build their theory.
Think of a group you could walk into and feel that you belong: a sports club, a choir, a group of friends online, a school house. Now think of a group you are technically part of but feel nothing for. The difference is what psychologists call a sense of community.
A community does not have to be a place. It can be a neighbourhood, but it can also be a group held together by an interest, a faith, a language or a cause. What turns a set of people into a community is how its members feel about the group and about each other.
Definition
Sense of community
A sense of community is "a feeling that members have of belonging, a feeling that members matter to one another and to the group, and a shared faith that members' needs will be met through their commitment to be together" (McMillan & Chavis, 1986).
David McMillan and David Chavis proposed that four elements work together to create that feeling.
The four elements of a sense of community (McMillan & Chavis, 1986). They reinforce each other: each makes the others easier.
| Element | What it means | What it looks like in a group |
|---|---|---|
| Membership | Feeling that you belong. Communities have boundaries (who is in), which give emotional safety; members identify with the group, invest time or effort in it, and share symbols (a name, uniform, language, ritual). | A team guernsey, a club song, a membership card, knowing who belongs. |
| Influence | Influence runs both ways. Members feel they can affect what the group does, and the group shapes its members (shared norms, some conformity). Members are drawn to groups where they have a say. | Members vote on decisions; new members learn the group's way of doing things. |
| Integration and fulfilment of needs | Belonging is rewarding: the group meets members' needs (status, skills, success, company), and members share values, so meeting the group's goals meets their own. | Coaching, friendship, a shared purpose, pride in the group's success. |
| Shared emotional connection | A bond built from shared history: frequent, high-quality contact, events members came through together, and honouring members' contributions. | An end-of-season celebration, a flood the club helped clean up after, stories told about the group's past. |
Each card is something the group does. Ask which feeling it creates: belonging, having a say, getting something you need, or a bond from shared experience.
A community choir does each of these things. Which element of a sense of community does each mainly build?
How the elements lead to a sense of community. The elements are not a checklist. They feed each other. Members who feel they belong are more willing to accept the group's influence; members whose needs are met invest more time; time together creates shared history, which strengthens belonging. An exam answer should show this link for each element: say what the group does, which element it builds, and how that element makes members feel part of the community.
Worked example
Explain how a surf club creates a sense of community
A surf life saving club on the Sunshine Coast has a red and yellow uniform that only qualified members wear. Members elect the committee and vote on how the club spends its money. Younger members are trained by experienced lifesavers and earn awards, and many say the club is where their closest friends are. Every year the club holds a dinner where stories are told about rescues the members carried out together.
Explain how the four elements of McMillan and Chavis's (1986) theory lead to a sense of community in this club.
Step 1: Membership
The uniform, worn only by qualified members, is a common symbol that marks a clear boundary of who belongs. Earning the right to wear it is a personal investment. Together these give members a feeling of belonging and identification with the club.
Step 2: Influence
Members elect the committee and vote on spending, so they feel they can influence the group. In turn the club's training and standards shape how members behave. Two-way influence makes members feel they matter, which draws them closer to the club.
McMillan and Chavis stressed that influence runs in both directions; mentioning only the club shaping members misses half of it.
Step 3: Integration and fulfilment of needs
Training, awards and close friendships reward members and meet their needs for competence, status and belonging. Because membership meets their needs, members want to stay and contribute.
Step 4: Shared emotional connection
The annual dinner and the stories of rescues carried out together build a shared history of important events. This emotional bond is what makes the club feel like "us".
Step 5: Link to a sense of community
Each element strengthens the others: belonging makes members open to the club's influence, rewarding membership keeps them involved, and shared events deepen belonging. Together they create a feeling of belonging, of mattering, and of trust that the club will meet members' needs.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Membership: the uniform is a shared symbol and boundary that members invest in. Influence: members vote and elect the committee, and the club's standards shape them. Integration and fulfilment of needs: training, awards and friendships reward members. Shared emotional connection: the dinner and stories of shared rescues build a shared history. Together these give members a sense of belonging and mattering: a sense of community.
Method
For each element, name it and define it in a phrase.
Link it to a specific thing the group in the stimulus does.
Say how it makes members feel part of the community.
Watch out for
Listing the four elements without linking each to the club: the question says "explain how", so each needs a link.
Describing influence only as the club controlling members.
Common mistake
Influence runs both ways
Students often describe influence as only the group shaping its members (conformity). McMillan and Chavis stressed that members must also feel they can influence the group. A group where members have no say tends to feel less like a community, even if everyone conforms.
History
A theory built from many disciplines
McMillan and Chavis did not run one experiment. They built their theory by drawing together evidence from sociology (how neighbourhood and interest-based communities form), social psychology (group cohesion, conformity and attraction), learning theory (reinforcement: we stay where we are rewarded) and community psychology. A concept as broad as "community" cannot be explained from one discipline's evidence, which is why the syllabus uses it as an example of how complex theories are developed.
Why did McMillan and Chavis (1986) need to draw on evidence from several disciplines to develop their theory?
Worked example
Evaluate an online group that lacks an element
An online gaming group has 4,000 members. Anyone can join with one click. The two founders make every decision and delete posts that question them. Members share tips that help each other improve, and the group celebrates when members reach new ranks.
Use McMillan and Chavis's (1986) theory to explain why members may have only a weak sense of community, and suggest two changes that would strengthen it.
Step 1: Check membership
Anyone can join with one click, so the boundary is weak and joining needs no personal investment. With 4,000 members there is little identification with one another. Membership is weak.
Step 2: Check influence
The founders make every decision and remove disagreement. Members cannot influence the group, so influence runs one way only. Members are less likely to feel they matter.
Step 3: Check needs and connection
Sharing tips meets members' needs (integration and fulfilment of needs), and celebrating new ranks gives some shared positive events (shared emotional connection). These elements are present.
Step 4: Suggest changes linked to the missing elements
To strengthen membership: a short welcome process, a shared name or badge, and smaller teams within the group. To strengthen influence: let members vote on rules or elect moderators.
Each suggestion targets an element shown to be weak, which is what makes it a justified suggestion rather than a general idea.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Membership is weak (open boundary, no investment, too large to identify with) and influence is one-way (founders decide; dissent removed), so members may not feel they belong or matter, even though needs are met and there are some shared celebrations. A joining process with a shared badge and smaller teams would strengthen membership; voting on rules or electing moderators would give members influence.
Method
Check each element in turn against the description.
Identify which are weak and explain the effect on the feeling of community.
Suggest changes that target the weak elements.
Exam tip
Answering "explain how … lead to a sense of community"
For each element: name it, describe it in a phrase, link it to something specific the group in the question does, and say how it makes members feel part of the community. Four elements with one link each is a typical 4-mark answer.
Summary
A sense of community is a feeling of belonging, of mattering to each other, and of shared faith that members' needs will be met (McMillan & Chavis, 1986).
Membership: boundaries, emotional safety, identification, personal investment and shared symbols.
Influence: two-way; members affect the group and the group affects members.
Integration and fulfilment of needs: membership is rewarding and members share values.
Shared emotional connection: shared history built from contact, shared events and investment.
The theory drew on sociology, social psychology, learning theory and community psychology: complex theories need evidence from many disciplines.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.