Lesson 5 of 8 · 18 min
Immigration, acculturation and culture shock
Describe the psychological challenges of immigration and acculturation, including culture shock, assimilation and marginalisation, using Berry's two dimensions of acculturation.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the psychological challenges of immigration.
- Describe culture shock and the stages the U-curve model proposes, and evaluate the model with evidence.
- Explain Berry's two dimensions of acculturation and the four strategies, including assimilation and marginalisation.
- Describe the psychological challenges associated with each strategy.
Moving to a new country can bring safety, opportunity and family reunion. It also asks a great deal of a person, all at once: a new language, new rules for everyday life, new ways of being judged. Some people choose to move; others, such as refugees, are forced to leave and may arrive after trauma and loss. The psychological demands are real for both.
| Challenge | What it involves |
|---|---|
| Language | Difficulty communicating at work, school, the doctor's or with neighbours; feeling less competent than at home. |
| Loss of support | Leaving family and friends behind; grief and homesickness; having no one to ask how things work. |
| Work and status | Qualifications not recognised; taking work below one's skills; loss of social standing. |
| Discrimination | Prejudice and exclusion because of language, appearance, religion or culture. |
| Family change | Children often learn the new language and ways faster than parents, which can shift roles and cause conflict between generations. |
| Identity | Working out which culture's values to follow, and who you are when the two differ. |
Definition
Acculturation and acculturative stress
Acculturation is the cultural and psychological change that follows continuing contact between people of different cultures. It happens to everyone involved, though usually more to the newcomers. Acculturative stress is the stress caused by these demands: anxiety, low mood, feelings of being lost or excluded, and the physical signs of stress.
Culture shock. The anthropologist Kalervo Oberg (1960) described culture shock: the anxiety and disorientation that come from losing all the familiar signs and rules of social life, such as how to greet people, when to speak, or what a gesture means. The U-curve model of adjustment over time was proposed by Sverre Lysgaard (1955), from interviews with Norwegian Fulbright scholars in the United States; its stages are usually named after Oberg's description.
The U-curve model of culture shock (an illustration of the model, not data).
| Stage | What the person tends to experience |
|---|---|
| Honeymoon | Excitement and curiosity; differences seem interesting. |
| Crisis (culture shock) | Frustration, anxiety, homesickness and sometimes anger as everyday problems pile up and differences feel like obstacles. |
| Adjustment (recovery) | Learning the new rules and language; problems become manageable; humour returns. |
| Adaptation (mastery) | Functioning comfortably in the new culture, often with a mix of old and new ways. |
The U-curve as the model describes it. Real people vary in timing, and some never have a honeymoon.
Note
Testing the U-curve
Colleen Ward and colleagues (1998) followed Japanese students in New Zealand, measuring their adjustment on arrival and at 4, 6 and 12 months. Adjustment problems were greatest at the start and decreased over the year. There was no honeymoon. The U-curve describes some people well, but a longitudinal study that measures the same people repeatedly gives stronger evidence about change over time than asking people to remember how they felt, and it did not support the U shape.
Why is a longitudinal design (measuring the same people several times after arrival) better than a single survey asking people to recall their first year, for testing the U-curve model?
Acculturation strategies. John Berry (1997) noted that every person or group in contact with a new culture faces two questions:
- Is it important to keep my heritage culture and identity?
- Is it important to take part in the new (larger) society and have contact with its people?
The answers combine into four strategies.
Berry's (1997) two dimensions of acculturation and the four strategies.
| Strategy | Heritage culture | New society | Psychological challenges |
|---|---|---|---|
| Integration | Kept | Takes part | Juggling two sets of expectations; but usually the least acculturative stress, with support from both cultures. |
| Assimilation | Given up | Takes part | Loss of heritage language, traditions and ties to family and community; guilt or conflict with family; can still meet prejudice despite fitting in. |
| Separation | Kept | Little part | Limited access to work, education and services; isolation from the wider society; can increase misunderstanding between groups. |
| Marginalisation | Little connection | Little part | Belonging nowhere: the highest acculturative stress, loneliness, low self-esteem and poorer mental health. Usually results from exclusion and loss of culture rather than choice. |
Key idea
Strategies depend on the society too
A person can only integrate if the larger society lets them. When the dominant group demands that newcomers give up their culture, assimilation is being imposed; when it excludes them, separation becomes segregation, and loss of culture combined with exclusion produces marginalisation. So acculturation is shaped by the attitudes and policies of the receiving society, not just the choices of individuals.
Drag the point along both dimensions, then place each fictional person by what they keep and what they take part in.
Identify the acculturation strategy each fictional person shows.
Which works best? Across many studies, integration tends to go with the best psychological wellbeing and marginalisation with the worst (Berry, 1997). The international study of immigrant youth you met in the lesson on WEIRD research found the same: young people with an integration profile had the best psychological and sociocultural adaptation, and those with a diffuse profile, who were unsure of their place in either culture (like marginalisation), had the worst (Berry, Phinney, Sam & Vedder, 2006).
| Profile | Description | % of immigrant youth |
|---|---|---|
| Integration | Strong ties to both cultures | 36.4 |
| Ethnic | Mainly oriented to the heritage culture (like separation) | 22.5 |
| National | Mainly oriented to the new society (like assimilation) | 18.7 |
| Diffuse | Unclear, weak ties to both (like marginalisation) | 22.4 |
Use the table. About how many of the 5,366 immigrant youth had an integration profile? Give your answer to the nearest whole number.
Worked example
Identify acculturation strategies and their challenges
Mina moved to Brisbane at 14. Three years later she speaks her heritage language with her parents, cooks family recipes and attends her community's festivals, and she also plays netball for her school and has friends from many backgrounds.
Her cousin Sef, who moved at the same time, now speaks only English, has stopped attending family gatherings, and says he wants to be "just like everyone else here".
(a) Identify the acculturation strategy each is using, with reference to Berry's two dimensions. (b) Describe one psychological challenge Sef may face.
Step 1: Place Mina on both dimensions
Keeps her heritage culture (language, food, festivals): high. Takes part in the new society (sport, friends): high. High–high is integration.
Step 2: Place Sef on both dimensions
Has let go of his heritage culture: low. Takes part in the new society: high. Low–high is assimilation.
Step 3: Describe a challenge of assimilation
Sef may lose his heritage language and ties to his family and community. This can bring conflict or guilt with his parents and grandparents and leave him without the support of his heritage community, while he may still meet prejudice despite fitting in.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Mina: integration (keeps heritage culture and takes part in the new society). Sef: assimilation (takes part in the new society but gives up his heritage culture). (b) Sef may lose his heritage language and family ties, causing conflict with his family and loss of his community's support.
Worked example
Interpret adjustment data and evaluate the U-curve
Illustrative data: international students completed a homesickness and stress questionnaire (0–40; higher means more difficulty) on arrival and at 3, 6 and 12 months. The mean scores were 24, 21, 17 and 12.
(a) Describe the trend. (b) Explain whether the data support the U-curve model of culture shock. (c) Explain why this design is better than asking students at 12 months to recall how they felt.
Step 1: Describe the trend with numbers
Difficulty was highest on arrival (24) and fell at every measurement, to 12 at 12 months: a fall of 12 points, halving over the year.
Step 2: Compare with the U-curve
The U-curve predicts low difficulty in the honeymoon (high adjustment), rising to a peak in the crisis stage at around a few months, then falling. Here difficulty was highest at the start and fell steadily: no honeymoon and no later crisis. The data do not support the U-curve; they match Ward et al. (1998).
Difficulty scores are the reverse of adjustment, so a U in adjustment would be an upside-down U in difficulty.
Step 3: Explain the design advantage
This is a longitudinal design: the same students were measured as they went. Recall at 12 months would depend on memory, which is distorted by how students feel now, and would give one data point per student instead of four.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Mean difficulty fell steadily from 24 on arrival to 12 at 12 months. (b) Not supported: the U-curve predicts low difficulty in a honeymoon then a later peak, but difficulty was highest on arrival. (c) Measuring the same students at each point avoids memory bias in recalling feelings and tracks change within each person.
Watch out for
Forgetting that a difficulty score runs the opposite way to adjustment.
Common mistake
Integration versus assimilation
Both strategies take part in the new society. The difference is the heritage culture: kept in integration, given up in assimilation. Note too that "integration" here is Berry's acculturation strategy, not McMillan and Chavis's "integration and fulfilment of needs".
Exam tip
Describing a challenge
The syllabus names culture shock, assimilation and marginalisation. For each, give a definition and a specific psychological challenge (an emotion, a loss, a stress) and, where you can, why it arises. "Assimilation is hard" earns nothing; "assimilation can cost a young person their heritage language, straining relationships with grandparents who speak little English" earns the marks.
Summary
Immigration brings challenges of language, lost support, work and status, discrimination, family change and identity: acculturative stress.
Culture shock is the anxiety of losing familiar cultural cues. The U-curve proposes honeymoon, crisis, adjustment and adaptation, but longitudinal evidence (Ward et al., 1998) found problems greatest at entry.
Berry's two dimensions: keeping the heritage culture, and taking part in the new society.
Integration (both), assimilation (new only), separation (heritage only), marginalisation (neither).
Integration usually goes with the best adaptation and marginalisation with the worst; which strategies are possible depends on the receiving society.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.