Lesson 2 of 8 · 15 min
Culture, individualism and collectivism
Describe culture in the psychological sense as shared behaviours, beliefs and values, and compare individualist and collectivist cultures as tendencies, not labels for every person.
What you will be able to do
- Describe culture in the psychological context.
- Classify aspects of a culture as behaviours, beliefs or values.
- Compare individualist and collectivist cultures in their values and view of the self.
- Explain why individualism and collectivism describe tendencies of cultures, not every person in them.
Ask someone to describe their culture and they often struggle. Culture is like the water a fish swims in: so familiar that you notice it mostly when you leave it, or when someone new does things differently.
Definition
Culture
In psychology, culture is the set of behaviours, beliefs and values shared by a group of people, learned from others and passed from one generation to the next.
| Part | What it is | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Behaviours | What people in the group do: customs, rituals, language, ways of greeting, eating, dressing and celebrating. | How you greet an older relative; whether shoes come off indoors; the language spoken at home. |
| Beliefs | What people in the group hold to be true about the world, people and the self. | Beliefs about what causes illness; about whether ability is fixed or grows with effort; religious beliefs. |
| Values | What people in the group hold to be important or good: the standards used to judge what matters. | Independence, duty to family, honesty, modesty, harmony, achievement. |
These three are linked. Values and beliefs are learned largely by watching behaviour, and behaviour expresses values and beliefs. A family that removes shoes at the door is doing something (behaviour) that may express a belief about cleanliness and a value of respect for the home.
Culture is learned, not inherited: a baby adopted into a family on another continent grows up in that family's culture. It is shared, so it guides how a group interprets the world. And it changes, as each generation adapts it.
Classify each as a behaviour, a belief or a value.
Individualist and collectivist cultures. Cultures differ in many ways, and the difference psychologists have studied most is individualism–collectivism: how much a culture emphasises the individual or the group. Surveys of employees of one multinational company in 40 countries around 1970 (Hofstede, 1980), and later work extending them to more countries, placed English-speaking countries, Australia among them, near the individualist end, and many societies in Asia, Africa and Latin America towards the collectivist end.
Individualist cultures tend to…
- value personal goals, independence, self-reliance and uniqueness
- see the self as independent: defined by personal traits and achievements
- encourage people to express their own opinions and stand out
- form many looser group ties that people join and leave by choice
- judge behaviour mainly by personal rights and choices
Collectivist cultures tend to…
- value group goals, interdependence, duty and harmony
- see the self as interdependent: defined by relationships and roles in the family and community
- encourage people to fit in and avoid open conflict
- form fewer, closer, lifelong group ties (often family and community)
- judge behaviour mainly by its effect on the group and on relationships
Key idea
Tendencies of cultures, not descriptions of people
Individualism and collectivism describe what a culture tends to emphasise in its shared values. They do not describe every person in it.
- People within any culture vary widely; some people in an individualist culture hold strongly collectivist values, and the reverse.
- One person can lean individualist at work and collectivist with family.
- Cultures are not simply one or the other: they sit along a continuum and change over time.
- Later reviews found the differences between countries are real but smaller and less consistent than often claimed, with wide variation within countries (Oyserman, Coon & Kemmelmeier, 2002).
So write "a collectivist culture tends to value harmony", never "people from that country are…". Turning a cultural tendency into a rule about individuals is stereotyping.
Each card is a behaviour, belief or value. Sort it by the tendency it fits. Notice that real people in every culture hold some of each.
A family business is run so that decisions are made together by the extended family, and children are expected to put the family's reputation ahead of their own ambitions. These practices fit better with
Worked example
Classify culture as behaviours, beliefs and values
A researcher interviews members of the fictional Varen community. They report that:
- adult children usually live with their parents until marriage;
- good fortune comes to families who honour their ancestors;
- the most important thing in life is to protect the family's reputation;
- major decisions, such as a job offer in another city, are discussed by the whole extended family.
(a) Classify each as a behaviour, a belief or a value. (b) Explain whether these responses suggest an individualist or a collectivist cultural tendency, and state one caution about the conclusion.
Step 1: Classify each statement
(1) Living with parents is something people do: a behaviour. (2) "Good fortune comes to families who honour ancestors" is held to be true: a belief. (3) "The most important thing" is a judgement of what matters: a value. (4) Discussing decisions as a family is something people do: a behaviour.
Step 2: Find the common thread
Each puts the family group at the centre: decisions are shared, the family's reputation comes first, and the self is defined by family roles.
Step 3: Name the tendency
Group goals, interdependence and duty to family suggest a collectivist tendency.
Step 4: Add the caution
This describes a tendency of the community's shared culture. Individual Varen people will differ, and interviews with a few members may not represent the whole community.
The syllabus treats individualism and collectivism as features of cultures; applying them to every person is stereotyping.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 1 behaviour, 2 belief, 3 value, 4 behaviour. (b) Collectivist: group decisions, family reputation first and a family-defined self are group goals and interdependence. Caution: it is a tendency of the culture, individuals vary, and a small interview sample may not represent the community.
Watch out for
Calling statement 2 a value. It says what causes good fortune, which is a belief about what is true.
Common mistake
Collectivist does not mean everyone agrees
Collectivism is about whose goals are put first and how the self is defined, not about having no opinions. People in collectivist cultures disagree; they may express it more indirectly to keep harmony. Likewise, individualism is not selfishness: valuing independence is not the same as not caring about others.
Exam tip
Describing culture in an answer
When asked to describe culture "with reference to behaviours, beliefs and values", give the definition, then one example of each part, labelled. When asked about individualist and collectivist cultures, contrast them on at least two features (goals, self-concept, relationships) and add that they are tendencies.
Summary
Culture is the behaviours, beliefs and values a group shares, learns and passes on.
Behaviours are what people do; beliefs are what they hold to be true; values are what they hold to be important.
Individualist cultures tend to emphasise personal goals, independence and an independent self.
Collectivist cultures tend to emphasise group goals, harmony, duty and an interdependent self.
These are tendencies of cultures along a continuum: people within any culture vary widely, and treating a tendency as a rule about individuals is stereotyping.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.