Lesson 8 of 8 · 20 min
Reducing prejudice through intergroup contact
Describe how intergroup contact that is sustained, with superordinate goals, mutual interdependence and equality of status reduces prejudice, with the evidence, and explore other ways to build intercultural understanding.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the four conditions of intergroup contact that reduce prejudice.
- Explain the Robbers Cave and jigsaw classroom evidence, including its limitations and ethical issues.
- Interpret data on contact and prejudice, choosing and interpreting the right statistical test.
- Explore ways to increase intercultural understanding to reduce conflict.
If prejudice grows from unfamiliarity and competition, bringing groups together should help. Sometimes it does. But history is full of groups that lived side by side for generations and stayed hostile. In 1954 Gordon Allport proposed the contact hypothesis: contact between groups reduces prejudice, but only under the right conditions.
| Condition | What it means | Why it reduces prejudice |
|---|---|---|
| Sustained | Contact is repeated and lasts long enough for real relationships to form, not a single meeting. | Time lets people see outgroup members as individuals, so stereotypes break down; friendships form. |
| Superordinate goals | Both groups want a goal they cannot reach alone. | The groups' interests line up instead of competing; "us and them" becomes "we". |
| Mutual interdependence | Each group needs the other to succeed; outcomes depend on each other. | People must cooperate and rely on each other, which builds trust and liking. |
| Equality of status | Members of both groups have equal standing in the situation. | Neither group is in charge, so contact does not confirm stereotypes of one group as inferior. |
Two groups in a setting. Switch each condition on or off and see how the setting changes and what the classic research found.
The Robbers Cave experiment. In 1954, Muzafer Sherif and colleagues ran a summer camp for boys at Robbers Cave State Park in Oklahoma. The boys, who did not know each other, were split into two groups that did not at first know the other existed.
- Group formation. Each group bonded and named itself: the Rattlers and the Eagles.
- Friction. The groups competed in a tournament with prizes for the winners only. Name-calling, flag burning and cabin raids followed; each group rated the other with unfavourable stereotypes.
- Integration. First the researchers tried simple contact: meals and films together. Hostility continued, with food fights. Then they set superordinate goals: the camp's water supply "failed" and both groups had to find the fault; the boys pooled money to rent a film; and both groups pulled together on a rope to start a stalled food truck.
| Measure | End of friction (stage 2) | End of integration (stage 3) |
|---|---|---|
| Rattlers: best friends chosen from the Eagles | 5 of 78 choices | 36 of 99 choices |
| Eagles: best friends chosen from the Rattlers | 5 of 67 choices (7.5%) | about a quarter of choices |
| Rattlers: ratings of the Eagles that were unfavourable | 53% | 4.5% |
| Eagles: ratings of the Rattlers that were unfavourable | 76.9% | 22.6% |
Calculate the percentage of the Rattlers' friendship choices that went to Eagles at the end of the integration stage. Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
Key idea
What Robbers Cave shows
Competition created prejudice between groups of boys who were alike in background. Contact alone (eating together) did not reduce it. A series of superordinate goals, requiring interdependence, over days of sustained contact between groups of equal status, did.
Note
Limitations and ethics
- The boys were chosen to be similar (same age, similar backgrounds), and the "groups" were created for the study, so the results may not generalise to groups with real cultural differences, histories and power differences.
- It was a field experiment with one camp: no control group and little replication.
- The boys did not know they were being studied (deception), and the researchers deliberately created hostility between children. Today this would breach the principle of protection from harm and need full informed consent from parents and the children's assent, withdrawal rights and a debriefing.
The jigsaw classroom. In 1971, schools in Austin, Texas, had just been desegregated, and classrooms were tense. Elliot Aronson's team designed the jigsaw technique. Students work in small, mixed groups. Each student learns one piece of the lesson and teaches it to the group; nobody can complete the task without every other member's piece. That builds in mutual interdependence, equal status (every piece matters equally) and a superordinate goal (the group's learning), and it ran several times a week (sustained). Students in jigsaw classes came to like each other more across groups and showed less prejudice than students in ordinary classes (Aronson & Bridgeman, 1979).
Here are illustrative data, made up for practice, from a class that used jigsaw groups for eight weeks. Ten students completed a prejudice scale (higher scores mean more prejudice) before and after.
Each student was measured twice, so the paired t-test is the right one. Illustrative data.
For these data, the paired t-test gives and the unpaired t-test gives . Which conclusion is correct?
Worked example
Analyse before-and-after data from a jigsaw program
Illustrative data: ten students completed a prejudice scale (higher scores mean more prejudice) before and after eight weeks of jigsaw groups.
| Student | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before | 34 | 29 | 38 | 31 | 27 | 36 | 33 | 30 | 35 | 28 |
| After | 30 | 27 | 33 | 30 | 24 | 31 | 31 | 29 | 30 | 27 |
(a) Identify the design and the appropriate t-test. (b) Calculate the mean of the differences (before − after) and the t statistic, to 2 decimal places. (c) With , state a conclusion. (d) Identify one limitation of the design and suggest an improvement.
Step 1: Identify the design and test
Each student was measured twice: repeated measures, so the paired t-test.
Step 2: Find each student's difference
Before − after: 4, 2, 5, 1, 3, 5, 2, 1, 5, 1.
Step 3: Mean and standard deviation of the differences
. With technology, .
Step 4: Standard error and t
; with .
Step 5: Conclude
, so reject the null hypothesis: prejudice scores fell significantly, by a mean of 2.90 points, after the program.
Step 6: Limitation and improvement
There is no control group, so something else over eight weeks (other lessons, maturation, getting used to the scale) could explain the fall. Add a control class taught without jigsaw groups, with classes randomly allocated, and compare the change in both.
A repeated measures design controls for differences between students, but not for events that happen to everyone over time.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Repeated measures; paired t-test. (b) Mean difference 2.90; (). (c) : prejudice scores fell significantly after the program. (d) No control group, so other changes over the eight weeks could explain the fall; add a randomly allocated control class without jigsaw groups.
Method
Match the test to the design (paired for repeated measures or matched participants).
Compute each difference, then , , and .
Compare p with 0.05 and state the conclusion in words.
Watch out for
Using the unpaired test: it gives here and would wrongly suggest no significant change.
Claiming the program caused the fall without a control group.
How strong is the evidence overall? Thomas Pettigrew and Linda Tropp (2006) combined 515 studies with about a quarter of a million participants in 38 nations. The mean correlation between contact and prejudice was r = −.21. In a single class study an r that small (below 0.25) would be described as no correlation, but averaged over 515 studies it is a small, very reliable effect: more contact went with less prejudice in 94% of the studies. The more rigorous experimental studies found a stronger effect (about r = −.33, a weak correlation). Contact under Allport's conditions usually reduced prejudice more, though the conditions helped rather than being essential. Later analysis found that contact works mainly by reducing anxiety about the other group and increasing empathy, and less by increasing knowledge (Pettigrew & Tropp, 2008).
Note
Contact and empathy in the brain (an Australian study)
Yuan Cao and colleagues (2015) at the University of Queensland scanned the brains (fMRI) of Chinese students who had arrived in Australia between six months and five years earlier while they watched videos of people of their own race and of another race receiving painful touch. A brain area linked to empathy, the anterior cingulate cortex, responded more to own-race pain: a racial bias in empathy. But the more contact a student reported with people of the other race, the more strongly it responded to their pain. The design is correlational, so less biased students may simply have sought more contact; but the neural measure is harder to fake than a questionnaire.
Illustrative survey of 12 students. Correlation alone cannot show that contact causes lower prejudice: less prejudiced people may simply choose more mixed activities.
In the survey, (, ). Which statement is the best conclusion?
Increasing intercultural understanding. Contact is one tool. Others aim at the same processes: less anxiety, more empathy, accurate knowledge, and fair decisions.
- Cooperative structures in schools, sport and workplaces: mixed teams with shared goals (jigsaw, team sports, buddy programs).
- Learning about cultures and histories, including the history and languages of the First Nations peoples of the local area, taught with and by those communities. Acknowledgements of Country and Welcomes to Country by Traditional Owners recognise the peoples whose Country a community is on.
- Perspective-taking and stories that let people imagine another's experience, which builds empathy.
- Structuring decisions to limit implicit bias: blind review of applications, clear criteria decided in advance.
- Visible norms and leadership: schools, workplaces and leaders who state and enforce that racism is unacceptable.
Not every program works. A review of hundreds of prejudice-reduction studies found that many interventions are brief and measured only in the short term, so the strongest evidence is still for sustained, structured contact (Paluck et al., 2021).
Worked example
Evaluate a contact program against the four conditions
Two neighbouring high schools, one mostly attended by students from a recently arrived migrant community, have a history of conflict. A council proposes a one-day "cultural fair" at which students from the second school visit stalls run by the first school's students, with a prize for the school whose students sell the most food.
Evaluate the proposal using the conditions for reducing prejudice through intergroup contact, and propose a better program.
Step 1: Check sustained
One day is not sustained: too short for relationships to form.
Step 2: Check superordinate goals and interdependence
There is no shared goal. Worse, the prize sets the schools in competition, which Robbers Cave showed increases hostility. Neither school needs the other to succeed: no mutual interdependence.
Step 3: Check equality of status
One school's students serve and the other's are visitors. The roles are unequal, and the arrangement could reinforce stereotypes of the migrant students as "other".
Step 4: Judge
The fair meets none of the conditions and adds competition, so it is unlikely to reduce prejudice and could increase it.
Step 5: Propose an improvement
A term-long joint project (for example, mixed teams from both schools designing and building a community garden for a shared competition entry), meeting weekly, with each team member responsible for one essential part and equal roles for both schools. This is sustained, has a superordinate goal, requires mutual interdependence and gives equal status.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The proposal fails all four conditions: it is a single day (not sustained), has no shared goal and adds competition, involves no interdependence, and gives unequal roles. It may increase hostility. A term-long project in mixed teams working towards a shared goal, with interdependent roles and equal status, would meet all four conditions.
Watch out for
Praising the fair because it brings groups together: contact alone is not enough, and competition makes it worse.
Common mistake
Contact is not enough on its own
"Put the groups together and prejudice will fall" loses marks. Robbers Cave showed that eating together did not reduce hostility, and competitive contact increased it. Always name which conditions the contact meets.
Exam tip
Describing ways to reduce prejudice
Name each condition in the syllabus's words (sustained, superordinate goals, mutual interdependence, equality of status), say what it looks like in the program described, and explain how it reduces prejudice. Support with evidence: Robbers Cave, the jigsaw classroom, or Pettigrew and Tropp's meta-analysis.
Summary
Contact reduces prejudice most when it is sustained, with superordinate goals, mutual interdependence and equality of status.
Robbers Cave (run in 1954; Sherif et al., 1961): competition created hostility; contact alone did not end it; superordinate goals did. Out-group friendships among Rattlers rose from 6.4% to 36.4%.
The jigsaw classroom builds interdependence, equal status and shared goals into everyday lessons.
Across 515 studies, more contact went with less prejudice (mean r = −.21), mainly through less anxiety and more empathy.
Repeated measures data need the paired t-test; correlational data cannot show cause.
Intercultural understanding also grows through cooperative structures, learning cultures and histories, perspective-taking, fair decision processes and clear norms.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.