Lesson 7 of 8 · 20 min
Social learning theory and the Bobo doll experiments
Distinguish modelling from vicarious conditioning, describe what Bandura's Bobo doll experiments showed, and analyse their design and data.
What you will be able to do
- Describe social learning theory and how it extended behaviourist learning theory.
- Distinguish between modelling and vicarious conditioning.
- Describe vicarious conditioning as observed in the Bobo doll experiments, including the difference between learning and performance.
- Analyse the design and results of Bandura, Ross and Ross (1961): variables, matching, observation and reliability.
Behaviourism explained learning as the result of a learner's own experience: a stimulus paired with another, or a behaviour followed by a consequence. But think about how you learnt to use chopsticks, tie a tie or do a TikTok dance. You did not try random movements until one was reinforced. You watched someone. By the 1960s Albert Bandura, a Canadian-born psychologist at Stanford University, was arguing that behaviourism had left out the most common kind of human learning.
Definition
Social learning theory
Social learning theory (Bandura, 1977) proposes that people learn by observing the behaviour of others (models) and its consequences in a social context, and that cognitive processes, such as paying attention, remembering and expecting consequences, determine what is learnt and whether it is performed.
Bandura did not reject conditioning. He extended it, which is how the syllabus describes the development of learning theories: each built on the evidence for the last. Two additions mattered most:
- Learning can happen by observation alone, with no reinforcement given to the learner at all.
- Learning is not the same as performance. A person can learn a behaviour by watching and not perform it until they expect it to pay off.
Bandura described four processes that observational learning needs. You need to give the model attention; retain what you saw in memory; be able to reproduce it (a toddler cannot reproduce a backflip); and have the motivation to perform it, which depends largely on the consequences you expect.
Modelling
Learning a behaviour by observing a model and imitating it.
The observer copies what the model did. No consequence for the model is needed.
A child watches her dad shave and then "shaves" with a toy razor in the same strokes.
Vicarious conditioning
Learning from the consequences the model receives.
Seeing the model reinforced makes the observer more likely to perform the behaviour (vicarious reinforcement); seeing the model punished makes them less likely (vicarious punishment).
A student sees a classmate praised for asking a question, and starts asking questions too.
Common mistake
Copying is not enough for vicarious conditioning
If a scenario mentions only what the model did, it is modelling. It is vicarious conditioning only if the observer sees what happened to the model as a result, and that changes how likely the observer is to act. The word "vicarious" means experienced through someone else.
Name the social learning in each scenario.
The Bobo doll experiments. Bandura and his colleagues tested these ideas in a series of experiments with preschool children and a Bobo doll, an inflatable clown that springs back up when knocked over. The aggressive acts the models performed were deliberately unusual (sitting on the doll and punching its nose, hitting it with a mallet, saying "Pow" and "Sock him in the nose"), so that if children did them later, they could only have learnt them from the model.
History
Bandura, Ross & Ross (1961)
Aim: to find out whether children would imitate aggression they had watched an adult perform, in a new setting with the model absent.
Participants: 36 boys and 36 girls from the Stanford University Nursery School, aged 37 to 69 months.
Design: the children were rated on aggressiveness by the experimenter and a teacher, matched in threes on those ratings, and one of each three was allocated at random to each condition: an aggressive model, a non-aggressive model (who played quietly with toys), or no model (control). The model was male or female.
Procedure: each child played in a corner of a room for 10 minutes while the model played (aggressively or quietly). The child was then mildly frustrated (shown attractive toys, then told they were for other children) and taken to a room with aggressive and non-aggressive toys, including a smaller Bobo doll, for 20 minutes. Observers behind a one-way mirror recorded what the child did in each 5-second interval.
Results: children who had watched the aggressive model performed many of its distinctive physical and verbal aggressive acts; children in the other two groups almost never did. Boys imitated more physical aggression than girls.
Conclusion: new behaviours can be learnt by modelling, without any reinforcement.
Mean imitative physical aggression in Bandura, Ross and Ross (1961), Table 1. Girls in violet, boys in blue. Aggr.: aggressive model; Calm: non-aggressive model; F, M: the model's sex; None: control group.
Using the graph, how many times greater was the mean imitative physical aggression of boys who watched the aggressive male model than that of boys in the control group? Give your answer to 1 decimal place.
Why did Bandura, Ross and Ross match the children on their rated aggressiveness before allocating them to conditions?
History
Bandura (1965): vicarious conditioning
Aim: to find out whether the consequences a model receives affect children's imitation, and whether they affect learning or only performance.
Procedure: nursery-school children watched a film of an adult behaving aggressively towards a Bobo doll, in the distinctive ways of the earlier study. The film ended differently for three groups. Model rewarded: another adult rewarded the model. Model punished: another adult punished him, telling him off. No consequences: the film simply ended. Each child was then left alone in a room with a Bobo doll and the same toys, and observers recorded how many of the model's aggressive acts the child performed (performance). Finally the experimenter offered each child attractive rewards for every one of the model's acts they could show (positive incentive: a test of what they had learnt).
Results: before the incentive, children who had seen the model punished performed significantly fewer of the model's aggressive acts than children in the other two groups (vicarious punishment). Once offered the incentive, children in all three groups could reproduce the model's behaviour, and the differences between groups largely disappeared.
Conclusion: the model's consequences changed whether children performed the behaviour, not whether they learnt it. Learning happened through observation in every group.
Compare what each group did on its own, then when offered a reward for imitating.
In Bandura (1965), what does the incentive phase show about the children who saw the model punished?
A class replication. You cannot ethically re-run the Bobo doll studies in class, but the same question can be asked about a harmless behaviour. A Year 11 class tested vicarious reinforcement with 20 Year 8 volunteers, allocated at random to two groups. Each group watched a short video of a student picking up litter in the playground; in one version a teacher thanked and praised her, in the other she was teased by friends. Afterwards, each student was given five minutes in a littered courtyard (a clean-up set up for the study), and the number of pieces of litter they picked up was counted.
Illustrative class data. Look at the means and the 95% confidence intervals, then the t-test.
The praised group's mean was 7.9 pieces and the teased group's 4.9 pieces. An unpaired t-test gave , , . Which conclusion is justified?
Worked example
Analyse the design of Bandura, Ross and Ross (1961)
In Bandura, Ross and Ross (1961), 72 children were matched on their rated aggressiveness and allocated to watch an aggressive model, a non-aggressive model or no model. Their imitative aggression was then recorded by observers behind a one-way mirror in each 5-second interval of a 20-minute session.
(a) Identify the IV and the DV. (b) Name the design and explain one advantage of it here. (c) Explain why the observers watched through a one-way mirror and why a second observer scored half the children.
Step 1: Identify the variables
IV: the model the child watched (aggressive, non-aggressive or none). DV: the number of imitative aggressive acts, counted in 5-second intervals over 20 minutes.
Step 2: Name the design
Each child took part in one condition only, and the children were matched in threes on aggressiveness before allocation: a matched participants design.
Step 3: Its advantage
Children's existing aggressiveness could affect the DV. Matching makes the groups equal on it, which reduces participant differences between conditions more than random allocation alone would with groups this small, without the order effects of repeated measures.
Step 4: The one-way mirror
Children who knew they were being watched might behave differently. Observers who cannot be seen reduce this reactivity, so the behaviour is more natural.
Step 5: The second observer
Two observers scoring the same children independently allow inter-observer reliability to be checked: their scores correlated in the .90s, so the scoring was consistent.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) IV: type of model (aggressive, non-aggressive, none); DV: imitative aggressive acts in 5-second intervals. (b) Matched participants: it equalises existing aggressiveness across conditions without order effects. (c) The one-way mirror reduces reactivity; a second observer allows inter-observer reliability to be checked (it was in the .90s).
Note
Evaluating the Bobo doll studies
Strengths: a controlled experiment with random allocation (and matching in 1961), novel acts that could only have been learnt from the model, and observers whose scoring agreed closely (reliabilities in the .90s).
Limitations: a Bobo doll is designed to be knocked over, so hitting it may not be real aggression towards a person; children may have acted as they thought the adults wanted (demand characteristics); the samples came from one university nursery school; and only short-term effects were measured.
Ethics: children were deliberately shown aggression, frustrated, and may have left more aggressive than they arrived, with no record of how this was addressed.
Exam tip
Name the consequence for the model
When a question asks you to describe vicarious conditioning in the Bobo doll experiments, say what the model did, what happened to the model (rewarded, punished, nothing), and what that did to the children's performance. Then add the incentive phase: the consequence changed performance, not learning.
Summary
Social learning theory (Bandura, 1977): learning by observing models in a social context, through attention, retention, reproduction and motivation.
Modelling is learning a behaviour by observing and imitating it. Vicarious conditioning is learning from the consequences the model receives.
Bandura, Ross and Ross (1961): children who watched an aggressive model copied its novel aggression; those who watched a quiet model or no model rarely did.
Bandura (1965): seeing the model punished reduced imitation (vicarious punishment), but an incentive showed all groups had learnt the behaviour: learning is not the same as performance.
The studies controlled participant variables well but used a doll, one nursery school and short-term measures, and raise ethical concerns.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 5 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.