Lesson 5 of 8 · 15 min
Positive and negative: naming the consequence
Distinguish positive and negative reinforcement and positive and negative punishment in unfamiliar scenarios with a two-question method, including the cases students confuse most.
What you will be able to do
- Identify the behaviour whose likelihood changes in an operant scenario.
- Decide whether a stimulus is added or removed, and whether the behaviour becomes more or less likely.
- Distinguish negative reinforcement from punishment.
- Analyse scenarios in which one event is a consequence for two people.
Exam questions on operant conditioning rarely ask you to define the four consequences. They describe something that happens at home, at school or at work and ask you to name it. The scenarios are written to trip up anyone who guesses from the feel of the words, so use a method instead.
Naming an operant consequence
Name the behaviour
Whose behaviour is changing, and what exactly is it? "Ella handing in homework on time", not "Ella".
What happens after it?
Find the consequence: the thing that starts or stops straight after the behaviour.
Added or removed?
If a stimulus is added, it is positive. If a stimulus is taken away, it is negative.
More or less likely?
If the behaviour becomes more likely in future, it is reinforcement. If less likely, punishment.
Put the two words together
Positive or negative, then reinforcement or punishment.
| Behaviour | Consequence | Added or removed? | Behaviour then | Name |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Finishing chores | Pocket money | Added | More likely | Positive reinforcement |
| Taking a painkiller for a headache | The headache goes | Removed (unpleasant) | More likely | Negative reinforcement |
| Touching a hot stove | A burn | Added (unpleasant) | Less likely | Positive punishment |
| Swearing at the dinner table | Phone taken for the evening | Removed (pleasant) | Less likely | Negative punishment |
When Mei starts her car, it beeps until she fastens her seatbelt. She now buckles up as soon as she gets in. Which consequence is this?
Common mistake
Negative reinforcement is not punishment
This is the pair students confuse most. Negative reinforcement increases a behaviour by taking away something unpleasant: the behaviour is how you escape or avoid it. Punishment decreases a behaviour.
A useful check: in negative reinforcement the unpleasant thing is there before the behaviour and the behaviour ends it (the beeping is going until the belt clicks). In positive punishment the unpleasant thing comes after the behaviour, because of it (the burn comes after the touch).
For each scenario, name the behaviour and the consequence.
Worked example
Name the operant consequence and justify it
For each scenario, identify the behaviour and name the consequence, justifying both words.
(a) Jayden''s coach makes him run extra laps each time he is late to training. He stops being late. (b) Every time Amira finishes her homework before dinner, her parents let her skip washing the dishes. She finishes her homework early more often.
Step 1: (a) Behaviour and consequence
Behaviour: arriving late to training. Consequence: extra laps.
Step 2: (a) Added or removed? More or less?
Extra laps are added (positive), and being late becomes less likely (punishment): positive punishment.
Step 3: (b) Behaviour and consequence
Behaviour: finishing homework before dinner. Consequence: she does not have to wash the dishes.
Step 4: (b) Added or removed? More or less?
An unpleasant chore is removed (negative), and finishing homework early becomes more likely (reinforcement): negative reinforcement.
Skipping a chore feels like a reward, which tempts students to say positive reinforcement. Nothing is added; something unpleasant is taken away.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Positive punishment: laps added, lateness decreases. (b) Negative reinforcement: dishes removed, finishing homework early increases.
Watch out for
Calling (b) positive reinforcement because it feels like a reward. Ask what is added or removed.
Name the consequence in each scenario.
Two people, two consequences. Many scenarios describe a consequence for two people at once, and each person's behaviour has its own name. A child screams in the supermarket until a parent buys a chocolate bar. For the child, screaming is followed by chocolate (added) and becomes more likely: positive reinforcement. For the parent, buying the chocolate is followed by the screaming stopping (removed) and also becomes more likely: negative reinforcement. Always say whose behaviour you are naming.
In the supermarket example, which consequence explains why the parent is more likely to buy the chocolate next time?
Note
It is defined by its effect
Whether something is reinforcement or punishment depends on what it does to the behaviour, not on what the person giving it intended. A teacher who scolds a student for calling out, only for the calling out to increase (the student enjoys the attention), has reinforced it. If a scenario says the behaviour increased, it was reinforcement.
Each time Harry calls out in class, his teacher stops the lesson to tell him off in front of everyone. Harry calls out more and more. Which consequence is acting on Harry's calling out?
Exam tip
Justify both words
A two-mark identification usually wants both halves justified: "Negative because the beeping is removed when she fastens the belt; reinforcement because fastening the belt becomes more likely." Naming the behaviour first makes the answer clear.
Summary
Name the behaviour first, then ask: added or removed (positive or negative)? More or less likely (reinforcement or punishment)?
Negative reinforcement increases a behaviour that removes something unpleasant. It is not punishment.
A fine, a lost privilege or time-out is negative punishment: something pleasant is taken away.
One event can be a consequence for two people; name each person's behaviour and consequence separately.
A consequence is defined by its effect on the behaviour, not by what was intended.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 4 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.