Lesson 3 of 8 · 18 min

Little Albert, learned fear and the ethics of early conditioning

Describe how Watson and Rayner (1920) conditioned fear in an infant, how it generalised, the ethical problems with their study and Pavlov's, and the evidence that immune responses can be conditioned.

What you will be able to do

  • Describe the Little Albert experiment, naming its NS, UCS, UCR, CS and CR.
  • Explain how a fear response can be learnt and can generalise to similar stimuli.
  • Identify the ethical issues in Watson and Rayner's (1920) and Pavlov's (1897/1902) studies.
  • Consider the evidence for classical conditioning of immune responses in humans.

Pavlov's dogs learnt to salivate. In 1920 the American psychologist John B. Watson set out to show that something far more human, an emotion, could be learnt the same way. Watson had founded behaviourism in 1913, arguing that psychology should study only what can be observed, and he believed that most fears are not inborn but conditioned. To test it, he and his graduate student Rosalie Rayner conditioned fear in an infant.

History

Watson & Rayner (1920), "Conditioned emotional reactions"

Aim: to find out whether a fear response could be classically conditioned in a human infant, whether it would transfer to similar objects, and how long it would last.

Participant: "Albert B.", a healthy infant raised in a children's hospital where his mother worked, described as calm and unemotional. A single participant: a case study.

Baseline (about 9 months): Albert was shown a white rat, a rabbit, a dog, a monkey, masks, cotton wool and burning newspaper. He showed no fear of any of them. A loud sound, made by striking a steel bar with a hammer just behind his head, made him startle and cry.

Conditioning (from 11 months 3 days): each time Albert reached for the white rat, the bar was struck behind him. After seven pairings, over two sessions a week apart, Albert cried and crawled away as soon as he saw the rat on its own.

Generalisation tests: Albert then showed fear of a rabbit, a dog, a fur coat, cotton wool and a Santa Claus mask, and was wary of Watson's hair. He played happily with his wooden blocks. A month later, without further conditioning, much of the fear remained, though weaker.

What happened next: Albert was taken out of the hospital before any attempt was made to remove the fear.

Match each part of the Little Albert experiment to its classical conditioning term.

Fear conditioned in Albert, and how it generalised.

What it showed. An emotional response, fear, was learnt by classical conditioning in a few trials, and it generalised to furry or white, rat-like objects but not to dissimilar ones such as the blocks. Watson argued that many adult fears and phobias begin this way. The idea is the basis of treatments still used: if fear is learnt by pairing, it can be weakened by presenting the feared stimulus without the frightening outcome (extinction), as in exposure therapy and systematic desensitisation.

What it could not show. One infant is a very small sample. Albert's reactions were described rather than measured on a scale, the procedure changed as it went (the rat was sometimes "freshened" with extra pairings), and later researchers who tried to repeat it with other infants had mixed results. The study is better evidence that fear can be conditioned than evidence of how often fears are learnt this way.

Albert showed fear of a fur coat, though it had never been paired with the loud sound. This shows

Choose one answer

Key idea

Science as a human endeavour

The dot points on ethics and on immune conditioning are science as a human endeavour: they can be assessed in your internal assessments rather than the external exam. The description of learned fear and Little Albert is examinable in the external exam.

The ethics of early conditioning studies. Neither Pavlov nor Watson and Rayner worked under the ethical principles you apply to research today. Judged against them, both studies have serious problems.

Ethical issues in the early conditioning studies
PrincipleWatson & Rayner (1920)Pavlov (1897/1902)
Protection from harmAlbert was deliberately frightened, repeatedly, and his fear spread to other objects.Dogs had surgery to make fistulas in their cheeks and were restrained in harnesses for long sessions; many suffered or died.
Removing the harmAlbert left before any attempt to remove the fear, and the researchers knew he might.The surgery could not be reversed, and the dogs were used again and again.
Informed consent and voluntary participationAn infant cannot consent. His mother, who worked at the hospital, may not have felt free to refuse, and there is no record of what she was told.Animals cannot consent, which is why animal research must be justified and minimise harm.
Withdrawal rightsAlbert's crying and attempts to crawl away were not treated as a reason to stop.Not applicable in the same way, but distress was not a reason to stop.
DebriefingNo record of a debrief, or of follow-up of Albert's wellbeing.Not applicable.
Interactive

Check the Little Albert procedure

Step through the procedure as it was run. Mark each step as fine or name the principle it breaches.

Today a study like Watson and Rayner's would not be approved. Research with people in Australia must follow the National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Human Research (NHMRC), which puts participants' welfare ahead of the research, and research with animals must follow the Australian code for the care and use of animals for scientific purposes, which requires researchers to replace animals where possible, reduce their number and refine procedures to minimise suffering. Both are applied by ethics committees before a study begins.

Explain two ways Watson and Rayner's (1920) study breached ethical principles that apply to psychological research today.

Write it out as you would in an exam. Put maths between dollar signs, like $x^2 + 1$. Worth 1 mark.

0 / 4000

Can the immune system be conditioned? The immune system is not under voluntary control, so if classical conditioning works on involuntary responses, it should be possible to condition an immune response. Ader and Cohen showed it in rats in 1975: rats given a sweet drink with a drug that suppresses the immune system later showed immune suppression after the sweet drink alone.

In humans, Goebel and colleagues (2002) gave healthy volunteers the immunosuppressant drug cyclosporin A (the UCS, which suppresses immune activity: the UCR) together with a distinctively flavoured, coloured drink (the NS), four times over three days. The following week, the volunteers drank the drink again, but with placebo capsules instead of the drug. Their immune function was suppressed by the drink alone (CS → CR), compared with a control group. The study was double-blind and placebo-controlled.

Note

Weighing the immune evidence

The findings have been repeated by the same research group, and they suggest conditioning might one day let patients take lower drug doses. But the samples are small, the effects are modest and short-lived (they fade as the CS is presented without the drug: extinction), and most of the work comes from a few laboratories. That is good reason to treat it as promising evidence, not a settled treatment.

Worked example

Analyse a study of conditioned immune responses

  • Complex unfamiliar

In Goebel et al. (2002), healthy volunteers took the immunosuppressant drug cyclosporin A together with a distinctively flavoured and coloured drink, four times over three days. The next week, the experimental group drank the same drink with placebo capsules, while a control group had not had the drink paired with the drug. The experimental group's immune function was suppressed after the drink alone. The study was double-blind and placebo-controlled.

(a) Identify the UCS, UCR, CS and CR. (b) Explain the purpose of the placebo capsules and of the double-blind procedure. (c) Evaluate how far this evidence supports classical conditioning of immune responses in humans.

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

In Goebel et al.'s (2002) study, what was the conditioned stimulus?

Choose one answer

Summary

  • Watson and Rayner (1920) paired a white rat (NS) with a loud noise (UCS) that made Albert cry (UCR); after seven pairings the rat alone (CS) produced fear (CR).

  • The fear generalised to a rabbit, a dog, a fur coat, cotton wool and a Santa Claus mask, but not to his blocks.

  • It showed that fear can be learnt by classical conditioning, but it was one infant, so it cannot be generalised far.

  • Ethical problems: deliberate harm, no removal of the fear, doubtful consent, no withdrawal or debrief. Pavlov's dogs underwent surgery and long restraint.

  • Goebel et al. (2002) conditioned immune suppression in healthy people: a drink paired with cyclosporin A later suppressed immune function on its own.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 4 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 3 of 80% read

Save your progress with a free account