Lesson 8 of 8 · 18 min
Comparing the three theories, and learning in everyday life
Compare classical conditioning, operant conditioning and social learning theory with behaviourism and social and cognitive psychology, and apply them to parenting, school, work, advertising, role models and social media.
What you will be able to do
- Compare classical conditioning, operant conditioning and social learning theory on matched features.
- Discuss behaviourism and social and cognitive psychology as the theories underlying them.
- Decide which theory best explains a behaviour in a scenario.
- Apply the theories to childrearing, schooling, employment, advertising, role models and social media.
You now have three explanations of learning. The external exam asks you to compare them, and to discuss the theories they come from. A comparison is not three separate descriptions: it puts the theories side by side on the same features and says how they are alike and how they differ.
Behaviourism. John B. Watson (1913) argued that psychology should be a natural science of observable behaviour: what goes on in the mind cannot be observed, so it should be left out. Behaviour is learnt from the environment, through associations between stimuli and responses. Pavlov's classical conditioning and Skinner's operant conditioning are both behaviourist. In both, the learner's own experience of stimuli and consequences is what produces learning, and both were built on carefully controlled animal experiments whose results were assumed to apply to people.
Social and cognitive psychology. Social psychology studies how other people influence us; cognitive psychology studies mental processes such as attention, memory and expectation. Bandura's theory belongs to both: learning happens in a social context, by watching others, and it depends on cognitive processes inside the learner (attention, retention, reproduction and motivation). It explains what behaviourism could not: learning without reinforcement, and learning that is not performed until later.
| Feature | Classical conditioning | Operant conditioning | Social learning theory |
|---|---|---|---|
| Underlying theory | Behaviourism | Behaviourism | Social and cognitive psychology |
| Key researchers | Pavlov (1897/1902); Watson & Rayner (1920) | Thorndike; Skinner (1938, 1948) | Bandura (1961, 1965, 1977) |
| How learning happens | Association between two stimuli (NS and UCS) | Association between a behaviour and its consequence | Observing a model, and the model's consequences |
| Kind of response | Involuntary, reflexive (salivation, fear) | Voluntary (pressing a lever, studying) | Voluntary, often new and complex behaviour |
| Role of the learner | Passive: the pairing happens to them | Active: they emit behaviour and it is reinforced or punished | Active: they attend, remember and decide whether to act |
| Timing | The stimulus (NS) comes before the response | The consequence comes after the behaviour | Observation comes first; performance may be much later |
| Role of consequences | None for the learner's response | Essential: consequences change the behaviour | Expected and vicarious consequences affect performance, not learning |
| Role of thinking | Not considered | Not considered | Central: attention, memory, expectations, motivation |
Exam tip
Writing a comparison
Use one sentence per feature and a comparison word in each: "Whereas in classical conditioning the learner is passive and the response is an involuntary reflex, in operant conditioning the learner is active and the behaviour is voluntary." Then add a similarity: "Both are behaviourist and explain learning through the learner's own experience; in contrast, social learning theory adds observation and cognition." Separate descriptions of each theory, however detailed, do not earn comparison marks.
Which theory does each statement describe best?
Decide whether each scenario is classical conditioning, operant conditioning or social learning, then name its parts.
Worked example
Compare operant conditioning and social learning theory
Compare operant conditioning and social learning theory as explanations of how a teenager learns to skateboard, referring to their underlying theories.
Step 1: Choose matched features
How learning happens; whether the learner must perform the behaviour; the role of consequences; the role of thinking; the underlying theory.
Step 2: How learning happens
In operant conditioning the teenager learns by trying moves and having the ones that work reinforced (staying upright, landing a trick) and the ones that fail punished (falling). Whereas in social learning theory they learn by watching other skaters (models) and imitating them.
Step 3: Performance and consequences
Both theories give consequences a role. In operant conditioning the teenager's own consequences shape the behaviour, so it must be performed to be learnt. In social learning theory, seeing a model admired for a trick (vicarious reinforcement) motivates performing it, and a trick can be learnt by watching before it is ever tried.
Step 4: Role of thinking
Operant conditioning, as a behaviourist theory, explains learning only by observable behaviour and consequences. Social learning theory, from social and cognitive psychology, adds attention to the model, memory of the move, the ability to reproduce it, and motivation.
Step 5: Sum up
Social learning theory explains how a new trick is first learnt by watching; operant conditioning explains how practice and its consequences refine and maintain it.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Both explain the learning partly through consequences, but operant conditioning (behaviourist) requires the teenager to perform the moves and be reinforced or punished, with no role for thinking, whereas social learning theory (social and cognitive) explains learning by observing models, vicarious reinforcement and the cognitive processes of attention, retention, reproduction and motivation, and allows learning before performance.
How the theories were built. The theories did not appear separately. Skinner's operant conditioning was a response to Pavlov's: it kept his experimental method and his focus on observable behaviour, but explained the voluntary behaviour that classical conditioning could not. Bandura's social learning theory was a response to both: it kept reinforcement and punishment, but showed by experiment (the Bobo doll studies) that people also learn from models in a social context. Each theory was tested, found to leave something out, and extended. That is how science usually advances.
Key idea
Science as a human endeavour
The rest of this lesson (applications, role models and social media) is science as a human endeavour subject matter, which can be assessed in your internal assessments rather than the external exam.
| Setting | Classical conditioning | Operant conditioning | Social learning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Childrearing | A child comes to feel calm at a lullaby that has always come with being cuddled to sleep. | Praise for sharing (positive reinforcement); time-out for hitting (negative punishment: attention and play removed). | Children copy how parents speak, eat and handle anger; parents who model the behaviour they want are more effective than rules alone. |
| Schooling | A student who was humiliated in maths class feels anxious at the sight of a maths test. | Merit points, certificates and token systems reinforce effort; losing a privilege punishes disruption. | Teachers model a method before students try it; praising one student's effort in front of others (vicarious reinforcement). |
| Employment | Workers feel tense when the manager's office door closes, after many bad meetings. | Commissions, bonuses and performance pay reinforce output; docked pay for lateness. | New staff learn by watching experienced colleagues (job shadowing, mentoring). |
| Advertising and marketing | A product is paired again and again with music, celebrities or moods people already like, until the product alone brings a good feeling. | Loyalty points, "buy 9 get the 10th free" cards and app streaks reinforce buying and returning. | Influencers and actors are shown enjoying the product and being admired for it (vicarious reinforcement). |
An energy drink is advertised only with clips of a popular band on stage and cheering crowds. After seeing the ads many times, viewers feel excited when they see the can on a shelf. In classical conditioning terms, what is the can?
Role models and teenage behaviour. Musicians, actors, sportspeople and TV characters are powerful models for teenagers because they are attractive, high in status and often shown being rewarded for what they do: the conditions under which Bandura found imitation most likely. The effects can go either way. Research on films has found that young people who see more on-screen smoking are more likely to start smoking, and the US Surgeon General concluded in 2012 that such depictions cause young people to start. On the other hand, well-known people who talk about seeking help for their mental health can make it more acceptable for teenagers to do the same.
Evidence here is mostly correlational (teens who see more of a behaviour do more of it), so it cannot by itself show cause: teens who already lean towards a behaviour may seek out media that shows it. Longitudinal studies, which follow the same young people over time, and experiments strengthen the case.
Social media. Social media turns social learning into a feed. Influencers are models; likes, views and comments are visible reinforcement for the model, so followers who see a post rewarded experience vicarious reinforcement, and trends and challenges spread by modelling. The same likes directly reinforce the user's own posting (operant conditioning), and they arrive unpredictably, which keeps people checking. In one experiment, Sherman and colleagues (2016) showed adolescents photos in a mock Instagram feed: they were more likely to "like" photos shown with many likes, and seeing their own photos with many likes activated brain regions associated with reward.
A video "challenge" spreads quickly among teenagers after popular creators post themselves doing it and receive millions of views. Explain how social learning theory accounts for its spread.
Common mistake
One behaviour, more than one theory
Real behaviour often involves more than one kind of learning. Posting a selfie can be modelled on an influencer (social learning) and then kept going by likes (operant conditioning). When a question asks which theory explains a behaviour, decide from the mechanism the question describes: a pairing of stimuli, a consequence for the learner, or an observed model.
Summary
Classical and operant conditioning are behaviourist: observable behaviour, learnt from the learner's own experience of stimuli and consequences.
Social learning theory comes from social and cognitive psychology: learning by observing models, depending on attention, retention, reproduction and motivation.
Compare on matched features: how learning happens, the kind of response, how active the learner is, timing, and the roles of consequences and thinking.
Each theory extended the one before it, after experiments showed what it could not explain.
The theories are applied in parenting, schools, workplaces and advertising, and explain the influence of role models and social media.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.