Lesson 2 of 8 · 16 min
Extinction, recovery, generalisation and discrimination
Describe extinction and spontaneous recovery, tell stimulus generalisation from discrimination, and read a response-strength graph across acquisition, extinction and recovery.
What you will be able to do
- Describe extinction and spontaneous recovery in classical conditioning.
- Distinguish between stimulus generalisation and stimulus discrimination.
- Read and describe a graph of response strength across acquisition, extinction and spontaneous recovery.
- Explain what spontaneous recovery shows about what happens to a learnt association.
A conditioned response is not fixed. Pavlov's dogs went on salivating to the sound only while the sound kept predicting food. Take the food away and the response fades; give the dog a rest and it comes back; play a slightly different sound and the dog salivates anyway. These four effects are what this lesson is about, and they are the ones exam questions ask you to recognise in new situations.
Definition
Extinction
Extinction is the gradual weakening and eventual disappearance of a conditioned response when the CS is presented repeatedly without the UCS.
Definition
Spontaneous recovery
Spontaneous recovery is the reappearance of an extinguished conditioned response when the CS is presented again after a rest period, without any further pairing with the UCS. The recovered response is usually weaker than before, and extinguishes faster.
Response strength across acquisition (NS paired with UCS), extinction (CS alone) and spontaneous recovery (model data). The rest between trials 16 and 17 was 24 hours.
Read the graph in three parts. In acquisition the response grows quickly at first, then levels off as the association reaches its full strength. In extinction the sound is presented alone, so each trial weakens the response until it disappears. After a rest, the very first presentation brings the response back (spontaneous recovery), at 6 drops rather than 11, and it extinguishes again within a few trials.
Spontaneous recovery is the reason psychologists say extinction does not erase the association: the learning is suppressed by a new "the sound no longer means food" learning, and the old association can resurface. An extinguished response is also usually relearnt in fewer pairings than it took the first time.
Using the graph, what percentage of its largest acquisition value did the CR recover to on trial 17? Give your answer to the nearest whole number.
Pair the bell with food, then present it alone. Rest, and test again.
Definition
Stimulus generalisation
Stimulus generalisation is the tendency, once a CR has been learnt, to produce it to stimuli that are similar to the CS. The more similar the stimulus, the stronger the response.
Definition
Stimulus discrimination
Stimulus discrimination is the ability to tell the CS apart from similar stimuli, producing the CR to the CS but not (or much less) to the others. It is learnt when the CS is followed by the UCS and the similar stimuli never are.
A generalisation gradient (model data). The dog was conditioned to a 1000 Hz tone; the closer a test tone is to 1000 Hz, the larger the response.
Generalisation
The CR spreads to similar stimuli.
A dog conditioned to a 1000 Hz tone also salivates to 800 Hz and 1200 Hz tones.
A child bitten by a kelpie becomes afraid of all medium-sized dogs.
Discrimination
The CR is produced only to the CS.
After the 1000 Hz tone is always followed by food and the 1200 Hz tone never is, the dog salivates to 1000 Hz but not 1200 Hz.
The child is afraid of kelpies but relaxed with the family's labrador.
Jess was stung by a wasp while drinking from a can of lemonade, and now flinches at a buzzing sound. Match each later event to the process it shows.
Common mistake
Generalisation is not extinction
Both involve the CR changing, but in opposite directions. In generalisation the CR is produced to more stimuli than the original CS. In extinction the CR fades to the CS itself because the UCS stopped following it. Ask: is the learner responding to something new (generalisation), or responding less to the same thing (extinction)?
Test the similar bells after conditioning. Then keep pairing the original bell with food while the similar bells come alone.
Worked example
Describe and analyse an eyeblink conditioning curve
In a laboratory study, a tone was played just before a gentle puff of air to the eye, which makes people blink. The table shows the percentage of trials in each block of 10 on which participants blinked to the tone before the puff arrived. In blocks 7 to 12 the tone was played alone. Block 13 was run the next day, with the tone alone.
| Block | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Blinks to the tone (%) | 5 | 20 | 45 | 70 | 85 | 90 | 80 | 55 | 35 | 20 | 10 | 5 | 40 |
(a) Identify the UCS and the CR. (b) Describe the trend across blocks 1 to 12. (c) Calculate the response in block 13 as a percentage of the peak, and name the process it shows.
Conditioned blinks to the tone, by block of 10 trials (model data).
Step 1: Identify the terms
The puff of air makes people blink with no learning: it is the UCS (blinking to it is the UCR). The tone was neutral at first; blinking to the tone alone, before the puff, is the CR.
Step 2: Describe acquisition
While the tone was paired with the puff (blocks 1 to 6), the CR rose from 5% to 90% of trials. It rose fastest early (from 20% to 70% over blocks 2 to 4) and levelled off near 90%.
Step 3: Describe extinction
With the tone alone (blocks 7 to 12), the CR fell steadily from 80% to 5%, close to where it started: extinction. Percentage change from block 6 to block 12: .
Quoting a calculated change makes "the response decreased" into evidence.
Step 4: Calculate the recovery
of the peak.
Step 5: Name and interpret it
After a day's rest, with no new pairings, the CR returned to 40% of trials: spontaneous recovery. It was weaker than at the peak, and shows the association had been suppressed, not erased.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) UCS: the puff of air. CR: blinking to the tone alone. (b) The CR rose from 5% to 90% during pairing, levelling off, then fell to 5% (a 94.4% decrease) when the tone was presented alone. (c) 44.4% of the peak: spontaneous recovery.
Method
Name the terms from the procedure before reading the data.
Describe each phase with values: direction, size, where it levels off.
Percentage of the peak = value ÷ peak × 100.
Watch out for
Calling block 13 "re-acquisition". No pairing happened; the response came back after a rest.
Describing the trend without quoting values from the data.
What does spontaneous recovery suggest about extinction?
Exam tip
Describing a learning curve
When a question gives a graph of response strength by trial, describe it in phases and quote the data: "During acquisition the CR rose from 0 to 11 drops by trial 7 and then levelled off. When the CS was presented alone it fell steadily to 0 by trial 16 (extinction). After the rest it returned at 6 drops on trial 17, about 55% of its peak (spontaneous recovery), then extinguished in three trials."
Summary
Extinction: the CR weakens and disappears when the CS is presented repeatedly without the UCS.
Spontaneous recovery: after a rest, the extinguished CR returns to the CS, usually weaker, showing the association was suppressed, not erased.
Generalisation: the CR is produced to stimuli similar to the CS, more strongly the more similar they are.
Discrimination: the CR is produced to the CS but not to similar stimuli, learnt when only the CS is followed by the UCS.
On a learning curve, describe acquisition, extinction and recovery in turn, with values from the data.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.