Lesson 5 of 11 · 16 min
Why we sleep: restoration and evolutionary theories
Compare the restoration and evolutionary theories of the purpose of sleep, weigh the evidence for each, and consider how sleep's purpose differs between humans and other animals.
What you will be able to do
- Explain the restoration theory and the evolutionary theory of sleep.
- Evaluate each theory with evidence, and compare them point by point.
- Consider how sleep could be adaptive for humans (sleeping at night as protection) and how its purpose differs from other animals'.
You will spend about a third of your life asleep. During that time you cannot eat, learn, look after your family or watch for danger. For something so costly to have survived in every animal studied, from fruit flies to whales, it must do something important. Psychologists have two main theories of why.
Restoration theory
Sleep lets the body and brain repair and replenish what waking uses up. We sleep because we need to recover.
- In NREM stage 3, growth hormone is released and the body repairs tissue, builds proteins and strengthens the immune system.
- During sleep the brain restores itself: memories are consolidated (in N3 and REM), and waste products that build up in the brain during waking are cleared.
Evolutionary theory
Sleep evolved to keep animals safe and save energy at times when being active would be dangerous or unproductive. We sleep because it helped our ancestors survive.
- An animal that is still and hidden is less likely to be eaten or injured.
- Sleep saves energy when food is hard to find.
- So each species' sleep should fit its way of life: how it feeds, and its risk from predators.
Evidence for restoration.
- Sleep rebound. After sleep deprivation, people make up mostly the deep NREM stage 3 and REM sleep they lost, not all the hours. The stages that restore, not total time, seem to matter.
- Exercise. Shapiro and colleagues (1981) found that runners slept longer, with more slow-wave sleep, for two nights after a 92 km ultramarathon.
- Deprivation harms. Without sleep, concentration, mood, memory and immune function all suffer (a later lesson), as the theory predicts.
- Waste clearance. In mice, the space between brain cells widens during sleep and waste is cleared faster than when awake (Xie et al. 2013).
Limitations. People do not sleep much less after a lazy day than after a busy one. Much bodily repair also happens during relaxed waking. And restoration alone does not explain why we sleep at night, or why species differ so much.
Average hours of sleep a day, mostly recorded in captivity (compiled from Campbell & Tobler 1984 and Siegel 2022).
Evidence for the evolutionary theory. Sleep patterns match each species' way of life.
- Grazing prey animals such as horses, cows and giraffes sleep little, in short bouts, and often standing. They must spend most of the day eating low-energy grass and staying alert to predators.
- Predators such as lions and cats sleep a lot. They eat high-energy food quickly, and little hunts them.
- Small animals with a fast metabolism, such as bats, sleep for most of the day, hidden away, saving energy between feeds.
- Dolphins sleep with one half of the brain at a time, with one eye open, so they can keep surfacing to breathe and watch for danger.
Limitations. Sleep itself is risky: a sleeping animal is less aware of predators, so it is hard to see sleep only as protection. Nearly every animal studied closely sleeps in some form, even where sleeping is dangerous, which suggests sleep does more than keep animals safe. And the theory does not explain why going without sleep impairs us, rather than just leaving us bored.
Classify each finding as evidence for the restoration theory or the evolutionary theory.
| Feature | Restoration theory | Evolutionary theory |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose of sleep | Recover: repair the body, restore the brain | Survive: stay safe and save energy |
| Why we sleep at night | Not explained | Humans see poorly in the dark, so night was the most dangerous and least productive time to be active |
| Why species differ | Not well explained | Sleep fits each species' feeding and predators |
| Effects of deprivation | Explained: what is not restored suffers | Not well explained |
| Main evidence | Rebound of N3 and REM; growth hormone in N3; effects of deprivation | Sleep patterns of prey, predators, bats and dolphins |
Worked example
Compare the restoration and evolutionary theories of sleep
Use the evidence below to compare the restoration and evolutionary theories of sleep.
- After a 92 km ultramarathon, runners slept longer and with more slow-wave sleep for two nights (Shapiro et al. 1981).
- Horses sleep about 2.9 hours a day and lions about 13.5 hours, mostly measured in captivity (Campbell & Tobler 1984; Siegel 2022).
Step 1: State each theory
The restoration theory says sleep lets the body and brain recover and repair what waking uses up. The evolutionary theory says sleep evolved to keep animals safe and save energy when activity is dangerous or unproductive.
Step 2: Link each piece of evidence to a theory
The ultramarathon runners needed more deep sleep after extreme exertion, as restoration predicts. The horse, a grazing prey animal that must eat for most of the day and watch for predators, sleeps little; the lion, a predator with a high-energy diet and few enemies, sleeps a lot, as the evolutionary theory predicts.
Step 3: Similarities
Both theories see sleep as serving survival, and both are supported by evidence. Neither alone explains everything.
Step 4: Differences
The restoration theory explains why sleep loss impairs us and why deep sleep rebounds, whereas it does not explain why species sleep such different amounts or why we sleep at night. The evolutionary theory explains those differences, whereas it does not explain why we suffer without sleep.
A comparison sets the theories side by side on the same points, rather than describing each in turn.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Both theories explain sleep as aiding survival. The restoration theory (sleep repairs and replenishes) explains the runners' extra deep sleep and the effects of deprivation but not differences between species; the evolutionary theory (sleep keeps animals safe and saves energy) explains why horses sleep little and lions a lot but not why deprivation harms us.
Method
State each theory in one sentence.
Link each piece of evidence to the theory it supports, with the reason.
Give similarities, then differences point by point, with "whereas".
Watch out for
Describing the two theories in separate paragraphs with no comparison.
Using evidence without saying which theory it supports and why.
Sleep in humans. The two theories are not rivals so much as two parts of one story: sleep may have begun as a safe way to pass the dangerous hours, and then come to serve restoration as well.
For our ancestors, sleeping at night was adaptive. Humans depend on vision and see poorly in the dark, so night was when moving about was most dangerous and least productive. Lowering consciousness for those hours, in a sheltered place, protected us and saved energy. Today we have light, locks and food at any hour, yet we still need to sleep and suffer without it, which suggests that for humans sleep's main purpose now is restoring the brain.
Human sleep differs from other animals' in other ways too. We sleep less in total than most other primates, but a larger share of our sleep is REM (Samson & Nunn 2015). Our sleep also changes greatly across the lifespan: newborns spend about half their sleep in REM, which may support the rapid growth of the brain (next lesson).
According to the evolutionary theory, why is it adaptive for humans to sleep at night rather than during the day?
Exam tip
Comparing theories
"Compare" asks for similarities and differences. Use linking words: "Both theories…", "whereas the restoration theory…, the evolutionary theory…". Name a piece of evidence for each theory and say which theory explains it better.
Summary
Restoration theory: sleep repairs the body (growth hormone in N3) and restores the brain (memory, waste clearance). Evidence: rebound of N3 and REM, longer deep sleep after heavy exercise, effects of deprivation.
Evolutionary theory: sleep keeps animals safe and saves energy when activity is dangerous or unproductive. Evidence: sleep patterns of prey, predators, bats and dolphins.
Restoration explains the costs of deprivation but not the timing of sleep or differences between species; the evolutionary theory explains those but not why we need sleep.
For humans, sleeping at night was protective; today restoration of the brain seems to be sleep's main purpose, and its pattern changes across the lifespan.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.