Lesson 7 of 11 · 15 min
Total and partial sleep deprivation
Identify the physical and psychological consequences of total and partial sleep deprivation, including effects on concentration and mood, and how they inform laws and workplace safety.
What you will be able to do
- Distinguish total from partial sleep deprivation.
- Identify the physical and psychological consequences of sleep deprivation, including effects on concentration and mood.
- Explain how research on sleep deprivation is used in laws, policies and the management of risk at work.
Almost everyone has had a night of too little sleep, and the next day shows it. Psychologists distinguish two kinds of sleep loss, and they do different damage.
Total sleep deprivation
No sleep at all for a period, such as staying awake all night, or 24 hours or more.
Effects appear quickly and are severe, but one or two nights of recovery sleep largely reverse them.
Partial sleep deprivation
Less sleep than you need, usually night after night: sleeping 5 or 6 hours instead of 8 to 10.
Much more common. Effects build up gradually, and people underestimate them.
| Physical | Psychological |
|---|---|
| Tiredness and drowsiness; microsleeps | Lapses of concentration and attention; slower reaction time |
| Poorer coordination and fine motor control; hand tremor | Low, irritable or unstable mood; anxiety; poorer control of emotions |
| Drooping eyelids, blurred vision, headaches | Poorer memory and learning |
| Weaker immune response; more infections | Poorer problem-solving, judgement and decision-making; more risk-taking |
| Changes in appetite and weight gain over time | After long total deprivation: confusion, perceptual distortions and hallucinations |
Definition
Microsleep
A microsleep is a brief, unintended episode of sleep lasting from a fraction of a second to several seconds, often with the eyes open. The person usually does not notice it, which is why microsleeps behind the wheel are so dangerous.
Move through total and partial sleep deprivation and watch concentration (attention lapses) and mood.
How bad is it? In an Australian study, Dawson and Reid (1997) kept volunteers awake and tested their hand–eye coordination. After 17 hours awake their performance was as impaired as after drinking alcohol to a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of 0.05%, the legal limit for most drivers in Australia. After 24 hours awake it matched a BAC of about 0.10%.
Partial deprivation adds up. Van Dongen and colleagues (2003) restricted healthy adults to 4, 6 or 8 hours in bed a night for two weeks. Attention lapses grew night after night in the 4- and 6-hour groups; after 14 nights, the 6-hour group's attention and working memory were as impaired as after one night without sleep, and the 4-hour group's as after two nights without sleep. The 8-hour group showed no build-up. Yet the participants rated themselves only slightly sleepy: people adapt to feeling tired faster than their performance adapts.
Classify each case as total or partial sleep deprivation.
Classify each consequence of sleep deprivation as physical or psychological.
Worked example
Apply sleep deprivation research to a night-shift worker
Jordan, a nurse, wakes at 2 pm, starts a night shift at 7 pm and finishes at 7 am the next morning. Jordan then plans to drive home.
(a) How many hours has Jordan been awake at the end of the shift? (b) Use the findings of Dawson and Reid (1997) to describe Jordan's likely level of impairment. (c) Identify one physical and one psychological consequence that could make the drive dangerous, and suggest one way the hospital could reduce the risk.
Step 1: Count the hours awake
From 2 pm to 7 am: 10 hours to midnight and 7 hours after it, hours.
Step 2: Apply Dawson and Reid
After 17 hours awake, performance was as impaired as at a blood alcohol concentration of 0.05%, the legal driving limit for most drivers in Australia.
Step 3: Name the consequences
Physical: microsleeps, drooping eyelids and slower, less coordinated movements. Psychological: lapses of concentration, so Jordan may not notice a car braking ahead, and poorer judgement of their own tiredness.
Step 4: Suggest a control
The hospital could provide a rest room for a nap before driving, a taxi or shuttle home after night shifts, or rosters that limit consecutive night shifts.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 17 hours. (b) As impaired as a BAC of about 0.05%. (c) For example: microsleeps (physical) and lapses of concentration (psychological); the hospital could provide a nap room or transport home.
Method
Count the hours awake across midnight.
Link the hours to the BAC comparison.
Name consequences as physical or psychological and link each to the task.
Watch out for
Counting from the start of the shift instead of from waking.
Listing consequences without linking them to driving.
Recovery. After deprivation, the first recovery night has more NREM stage 3 than usual, and later nights more REM (the rebound you met in the restoration theory). People do not make up every lost hour; one or two good nights restore most functions after short total deprivation, but recovery from weeks of partial deprivation takes longer.
Sleep, law and the workplace. Because sleep loss impairs performance as much as alcohol, research like Dawson and Reid's is used to make and evaluate rules.
- Road transport. Under Australia's Heavy Vehicle National Law, fatigue-regulated truck and bus drivers must keep to limits on work hours and minimum rest breaks, and on longer trips record them in a work diary.
- Health care and aviation. Hospitals limit consecutive shifts and long hours for doctors and nurses, and airlines and air traffic control use fatigue risk management systems that plan rosters around the body clock.
- Workplace health and safety. Employers must manage fatigue as a hazard: assess the risk (shift length, night work, consecutive shifts), control it (rosters, breaks, napping rooms, transport home after night shifts) and monitor it.
- Evaluating policy. Sleep research is also used to check whether a rule works: for example, whether later school start times improve students' sleep, mood and attendance.
A mining company runs 12-hour night shifts. Using sleep research, suggest two ways it could reduce the risk of fatigue-related accidents, and justify each.
Exam tip
Identify, then link
When asked for consequences, say whether each is physical or psychological, and link it to the situation: "lapses in concentration mean a tired driver may not notice a car braking ahead". For concentration and mood, the syllabus's own words, give at least one example of each.
Summary
Total deprivation is no sleep for a period; partial deprivation is less sleep than needed, often over many nights.
Physical consequences include tiredness, microsleeps, poor coordination, tremor, drooping eyelids and weaker immunity; psychological ones include lapses of concentration, irritable or low mood, poorer memory and judgement.
After 17 hours awake, performance is as impaired as at a BAC of 0.05%; after 24 hours, about 0.10% (Dawson & Reid 1997).
Partial deprivation accumulates, and people underestimate how impaired they are (Van Dongen et al. 2003).
Sleep research informs fatigue laws for drivers, rostering in health care and aviation, and workplace risk management.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.