Lesson 10 of 11 · 20 min
Investigating divided attention and memory: means, SD and the t-test
Replicate an aspect of Craik et al. (1996) with an independent groups experiment, then describe the results with the mean, standard deviation and error bars, and test them with an unpaired t-test.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the aim, method and main finding of Craik et al. (1996).
- Identify and operationalise the IV and DV, controlled variables and hypotheses of a class replication with independent groups.
- Calculate the mean and standard deviation, and explain what standard error and a 95% confidence interval show.
- Draw and read a column graph with error bars, and interpret an unpaired t-test: t, df, p and a conclusion.
Can you learn while doing something else? Students often study with a phone buzzing beside them. Fergus Craik and his colleagues tested what dividing attention does to memory, and their experiment is one you can run in class.
History
Craik, Govoni, Naveh-Benjamin and Anderson (1996)
Aim: to find out whether dividing attention affects memory more when information is being learnt (encoding) or when it is being remembered (retrieval).
Method: university students heard lists of words. In some conditions they learnt the words, in others they recalled them, while doing a second task at the same time: watching a screen and pressing the key that matched where a mark appeared, as fast as possible. Their memory and their speed on the second task were measured with full and with divided attention.
Findings: dividing attention while learning greatly reduced how many words were later remembered. Dividing attention during recall had a much smaller effect on memory, although it slowed the second task.
Conclusion: encoding needs attention; retrieval is more automatic and is protected at the expense of the other task.
Learn one list with full attention and one while responding to a dot. Then compare your recall with Craik et al. (1996). Your results stay in your browser and are not a diagnosis.
A class replication. Your class replicates the encoding part. Sixteen Year 11 students are randomly allocated to two groups of eight. Everyone hears the same 20 common nouns read at one word every 2 seconds, then has 2 minutes to write down as many as they can, in any order (free recall).
- Full attention group: listens to the list and does nothing else.
- Divided attention group: sorts a shuffled pack of playing cards into suits while listening.
| Feature | In this experiment |
|---|---|
| Independent variable (IV) | Attention while learning: full (listening only) or divided (sorting cards by suit while listening) |
| Dependent variable (DV) | Number of words correctly recalled out of 20 in 2 minutes of written free recall |
| Controlled variables | The same 20-word list, the same rate (one word every 2 s), the same 2-minute recall, the same room and time of day, standardised recorded instructions |
| Design | Independent groups: each student is in one condition only |
| Allocation | Random allocation (names drawn from a hat), so differences in memory ability are spread across both groups by chance |
| Null hypothesis (H₀) | There will be no difference in the mean number of words recalled by Year 11 students who learn the list with full attention and those who learn it while sorting cards. |
| Alternative hypothesis (H₁) | Year 11 students who learn the list while sorting cards will recall a different mean number of words from those who learn it with full attention. |
Note
Why independent groups here?
With repeated measures, each student would need two different lists, and the second time they would know what is coming (an order effect: practice or fatigue). Independent groups avoid order effects, but the groups may differ in memory ability, so random allocation matters. A repeated measures version is possible with two equally hard lists and counterbalancing (half do full attention first).
Match each part of the class experiment to its role.
The results. Each number is one student's score: words recalled out of 20.
| Group | Scores | Total |
|---|---|---|
| Full attention | 14, 12, 15, 11, 13, 16, 12, 15 | 108 |
| Divided attention | 9, 11, 8, 10, 12, 7, 9, 10 | 76 |
Definition
The mean and the standard deviation
The mean is the average score: . For the full attention group, words; for the divided group, words.
The standard deviation (, SD) measures how spread out the scores are around the mean: roughly the typical distance of a score from the mean.
Psychology uses this sample SD, which divides by . On a calculator it is (not ); in a spreadsheet STDEV.S.
Standard deviation by hand: the full attention group
Find the mean
.
Subtract the mean from each score
(they add to 0).
Square each deviation and add
.
Divide by n − 1
(the variance).
Take the square root
words.
For the divided attention group (9, 11, 8, 10, 12, 7, 9, 10; mean 9.5), the squared deviations add to 18. Calculate the standard deviation, to 2 decimal places.
From the sample to the population. The class is a sample. If another eight students had been in each group, the means would have come out a little differently. Two statistics say how far to trust a sample mean.
- The standard error estimates how much the mean would vary from sample to sample. Full attention: ; divided: . It shrinks as the sample grows.
- The 95% confidence interval is : a range that would contain the true population mean in 95% of samples. Full attention: , from 12.27 to 14.73 words; divided: , from 8.39 to 10.61 words.
| Group | n | Mean | SD | SE | 95% CI |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full attention | 8 | 13.50 | 1.77 | 0.63 | 12.27 to 14.73 |
| Divided attention | 8 | 9.50 | 1.60 | 0.57 | 8.39 to 10.61 |
Mean words recalled out of 20. Error bars show ±1 standard deviation.
Key idea
Reading error bars
Always say what the error bars show: SD (the spread of the scores), SE or a 95% CI (how precise the mean is). Bars that do not overlap suggest a real difference; bars that overlap a lot suggest it may be due to chance. Only a statistical test can say how likely chance is.
The t-test. The difference between the means is 4 words. Could two random groups of eight differ this much by chance, if divided attention made no difference at all? A two-sample t-test answers that. It compares the difference between the means with how much the scores vary within the groups.
Because each student was in one group, the scores are unpaired: use the unpaired (independent samples) t-test. In a spreadsheet: =T.TEST(full, divided, 2, 2) (two-tailed, equal variances).
Result: , , .
Key idea
The decision and the conclusion
Decision: , which is less than 0.05, so the difference is statistically significant. Reject the null hypothesis.
Conclusion: students who sorted cards while learning recalled significantly fewer words (mean 9.5, SD 1.60) than those who learnt with full attention (mean 13.5, SD 1.77). Dividing attention while learning reduced recall, as Craik et al. (1996) found for divided attention at encoding.
Worked example
Interpret an unpaired t-test on divided attention at recall
Another class tested divided attention at retrieval. Twenty students learnt the same 20-word list with full attention, and were then randomly allocated to recall it either with full attention or while sorting cards.
| Recall condition | n | Mean words recalled | SD |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full attention | 10 | 12.1 | 2.0 |
| Divided attention | 10 | 11.4 | 2.2 |
An unpaired t-test gave , , .
(a) Explain why an unpaired t-test was used. (b) Interpret the result. (c) Explain how the result relates to Craik et al. (1996).
Step 1: Choose the test
Each student recalled in one condition only (independent groups), so the scores are not paired: an unpaired t-test, .
Step 2: Make the decision
is greater than 0.05: the difference of 0.7 words is not significant. Retain the null hypothesis.
Step 3: Conclude
Dividing attention while recalling did not significantly reduce the number of words recalled (mean 11.4, SD 2.2, against 12.1, SD 2.0).
Step 4: Link to Craik et al.
Craik et al. (1996) found that divided attention at retrieval had only a small effect on memory, much smaller than at encoding. The class's result is consistent with this, although a small real effect could have been missed with 10 per group (a type II error).
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Independent groups: each student was in one condition, so the data are unpaired. (b) , so the 0.7-word difference is not significant; retain H₀. (c) Consistent with Craik et al. (1996): divided attention at retrieval has little effect on memory.
Method
Independent groups → unpaired; repeated measures or matched participants → paired.
Compare with 0.05 and state the decision about H₀.
Conclude in words with the means, and relate to the original study.
Watch out for
Saying the result "proves" divided attention has no effect at retrieval.
The class's data. Switch the error bars between SD, SE and the 95% CI, then edit scores and watch and .
Common mistake
Significant is not the same as proved
"" means a difference this large would be unlikely if the IV had no effect. It does not prove the hypothesis; with there is still a tiny chance the result is a fluke. Write that the results support the alternative hypothesis.
Note
Ethics in the class experiment
Students give informed consent in writing (with written permission from a parent or carer for students under 16, as QCAA's guidelines require), know they may withdraw at any time, and their scores are kept confidential (codes, not names). Explain the aim afterwards in a debriefing. Nothing in this experiment should cause harm or distress.
Summary
Craik et al. (1996) found that divided attention while learning greatly reduces memory, while divided attention during recall affects memory much less.
In the class replication the IV is full or divided attention while learning, the DV the number of words recalled; the design is independent groups with random allocation.
Mean ; the sample SD divides by ; ; 95% CI .
A column graph shows the means, with error bars labelled as SD, SE or 95% CI.
For independent groups, use the unpaired t-test; if , reject H₀ and conclude the IV had a significant effect.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.