Lesson 2 of 11 · 17 min
Selective and divided attention, and how the brain focuses it
Tell selective attention from divided attention, explain when dividing attention works, and explain how the reticular formation, thalamus and cortex focus attention on a target.
What you will be able to do
- Define attention and explain why it is limited.
- Discriminate between selective and divided attention in everyday and experimental scenarios.
- Explain how task difficulty, similarity and practice affect divided attention.
- Explain how the reticular formation, the thalamus and the cortex interact to focus conscious attention on a target.
At this moment your senses are taking in far more than you notice: the pressure of your feet on the floor, background noise, the edges of the screen. You become aware of them only when you turn your attention to them. Attention is the process of focusing consciousness on some stimuli, thoughts or tasks rather than others. It is limited: you cannot attend fully to everything at once, so the brain has to select.
Selective attention
Focusing on one stimulus or task and filtering out the others.
Following your friend's voice in a noisy canteen; reading while a television is on; listening for your bus number among the announcements.
Divided attention
Sharing attention between two or more stimuli or tasks at the same time.
Taking notes while listening to a teacher; talking while walking; driving while following a navigation app's directions.
Selective attention: the cocktail party effect. In a crowded room you can follow one conversation and tune out the rest. Psychologists study this with dichotic listening: a different message plays into each ear, and the participant repeats aloud (shadows) the message in one ear. Cherry (1953) found that people could report almost nothing about the message in the unattended ear, not even when it switched language, but they noticed a change in physical features such as a man's voice becoming a woman's. Moray (1959) found that about a third of participants noticed their own name in the unattended ear.
So the unattended information is not simply blocked. It is processed a little, enough for something salient (personally important, or physically striking) to break through.
Watch two streams of words, tap the animal words in the one you attend to, and ignore the other. Then see how much of the ignored stream got through. Your results are for learning, not a diagnosis, and stay in your browser.
Classify each scenario as selective attention or divided attention.
Divided attention: when does it work? Doing two things at once is possible, but performance on one or both tasks usually falls. How much depends on three things.
- Difficulty. Two easy tasks can be shared; two demanding ones compete for the same limited capacity.
- Similarity. Tasks that use the same sense or the same kind of response interfere more. Listening to a podcast while reading is hard (both are language); listening to music while jogging is easy.
- Practice. A well-practised task becomes automatic: fast, with little conscious effort, so it leaves capacity for a second task. A new or complex task needs controlled processing, slow and effortful. An experienced driver can chat on a quiet road; a learner driver cannot.
Key idea
Automatic and controlled processes
Automatic processes need little attention, are fast and run in parallel with other tasks (reading a word, walking). Controlled processes need conscious attention, are slow and are done one at a time (solving a new problem, reversing a car into a tight space). Dividing attention works best when all but one of the tasks are automatic.
Which pair of tasks is most likely to be done together without either suffering?
How the brain focuses attention. Three structures work together to direct consciousness to a target.
- The reticular formation is a network of neurons running through the core of the brainstem (medulla, pons and midbrain). Its ascending fibres, the reticular activating system, keep the cortex awake and alert, so it sets your overall level of arousal. It also filters: repetitive, unimportant input (the hum of a fan) is damped, and new or important input (a sudden noise, your name) raises arousal.
- The thalamus, in the forebrain above the brainstem, is the relay station for every sense except smell. Sensory information passes through it on its way to the cortex, and the thalamus can amplify what is attended to and damp down what is not, like a gate.
- The cerebral cortex, especially the prefrontal cortex in the frontal lobe, decides what to attend to, according to your goals. It sends signals back down to the thalamus to strengthen the target's signals and suppress the rest.
The reticular formation, thalamus and cortex: the attention network this topic names.
How the three structures interact to focus attention.
Worked example
Explain how the brain focuses and shifts attention
During a lesson, Mia follows her teacher's explanation and is unaware of the hum of the air conditioner. When the fire alarm sounds, her attention switches to it at once.
Explain how the reticular formation, the thalamus and the cortex interact to (a) focus Mia's attention on her teacher, and (b) shift it to the alarm.
Step 1: Arousal from the reticular formation
The reticular formation in the brainstem, through the reticular activating system, keeps Mia's cortex awake and alert, so she can attend at all. It damps steady, unimportant input such as the hum of the air conditioner.
Step 2: Relay through the thalamus
Sounds from the teacher and the air conditioner both pass through the thalamus, the relay station for the senses (other than smell), on their way to the cortex.
Step 3: The cortex selects the target
Mia's cortex (prefrontal cortex) sets the goal: listen to the teacher. It signals the thalamus to amplify the teacher's voice and damp the other sounds, so the voice reaches consciousness and the hum does not. This is selective attention.
Step 4: A salient stimulus breaks through
The alarm is sudden, loud and important. The reticular formation responds to it by raising arousal, and the thalamus passes it on strongly; the cortex recognises its importance and redirects attention, now amplifying the alarm.
Unattended input is filtered, not fully blocked, so salient stimuli can still capture attention.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) The reticular formation keeps the cortex aroused and damps the steady hum; sensory signals pass through the thalamus; the cortex selects the teacher's voice and signals the thalamus to amplify it and suppress other input. (b) The sudden, important alarm raises arousal through the reticular formation, reaches the cortex through the thalamus, and the cortex shifts the target to the alarm.
Method
Give each structure its role: reticular formation (arousal, flags important input), thalamus (relays and gates), cortex (selects the target).
Show the interaction: the cortex directs the thalamus; the reticular formation sets how alert the cortex is.
Apply it to the scenario's stimuli.
Watch out for
Saying the thalamus decides what to attend to. The cortex decides; the thalamus relays and gates.
Describing each structure separately without saying how they interact.
A person's name is called across a noisy room and they turn to look, although they were absorbed in a conversation. Which structure is mainly responsible for raising their arousal in response to the salient sound?
Common mistake
The thalamus does not decide
The thalamus relays and gates information; the cortex decides what is the target and directs the thalamus. The reticular formation sets how alert the cortex is. In an "explain" answer, give each structure its role and say how they interact.
Summary
Attention focuses consciousness on some stimuli rather than others, and its capacity is limited.
Selective attention focuses on one stimulus and filters out the rest; salient information (your own name) can still break through.
Divided attention shares attention between tasks; it works best when tasks are easy, dissimilar and practised to the point of being automatic.
The reticular formation sets arousal and flags important input, the thalamus relays and gates sensory information, and the cortex selects the target and directs the thalamus to amplify it.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.