Lesson 8 of 11 · 19 min
Sleep disorders and their treatment
Compare narcolepsy, sleep-onset insomnia, sleep apnoea and sleepwalking, and describe treatments including cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia and bright light therapy for circadian phase disorders.
What you will be able to do
- Describe narcolepsy, sleep-onset insomnia, sleep apnoea and sleepwalking: their features, when they occur in the night and their effects.
- Compare the four disorders, giving similarities and differences.
- Describe cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia and bright light therapy for circadian phase disorders, and explain how each works.
Note
If sleep is a problem for you
Many people have trouble with sleep at some time. This lesson is for understanding, not for diagnosing yourself or anyone else. If sleep problems are affecting you, talk to a GP or your school counsellor. You can also contact Kids Helpline (1800 55 1800), Lifeline (13 11 14) or headspace (headspace.org.au).
A sleep disorder is a persistent disturbance of sleep that affects how a person feels and functions during the day. Doctors diagnose them from a person's history, sleep diaries and, often, an overnight sleep study (polysomnography: EEG, EOG and EMG, with breathing and blood oxygen). Some disorders are about too little or poor-quality sleep, or sleep at the wrong times; others, the parasomnias, are unusual behaviours during sleep.
| Disorder | What happens | When | Effects during the day |
|---|---|---|---|
| Narcolepsy | A neurological disorder: overwhelming sleepiness and sudden sleep attacks; often cataplexy (sudden loss of muscle tone set off by strong emotion such as laughter), sleep paralysis and vivid dream-like images when falling asleep. Linked to a loss of neurons in the hypothalamus that keep us awake. | Any time of day; falls into REM within minutes instead of after about 90 minutes | Falling asleep in class, at work or while driving; injury from falls |
| Sleep-onset insomnia | Persistent difficulty falling asleep (lying awake for more than about 30 minutes) despite the chance to sleep. Often kept going by worry, stress, an irregular schedule, caffeine, screens, and learning to associate bed with being awake. | At the start of the night | Tiredness, poor concentration, irritability and worry about sleep |
| Sleep apnoea (obstructive) | The upper airway repeatedly collapses, so breathing stops for 10 seconds or more, many times an hour. Blood oxygen falls and the person briefly wakes to breathe, usually without remembering it. Loud snoring and gasping. More common with obesity, age and in males. | Throughout sleep | Severe daytime sleepiness, morning headaches, poor concentration; long term, higher risk of high blood pressure and heart disease |
| Sleepwalking | A parasomnia: getting up and walking (or doing other actions) while still asleep, eyes often open, hard to wake, with little or no memory afterwards. More common in children. Made more likely by sleep deprivation, stress and a family history. | NREM stage 3, so usually in the first third of the night | Usually few, but risk of injury during an episode |
Compare each disorder's hypnogram with a typical night. In which stage does each disorder show itself?
Sam, 52, snores loudly, and his partner notices that he stops breathing for several seconds at a time before gasping. Sam feels exhausted every day despite 8 hours in bed. Which disorder do these features best match?
Worked example
Compare narcolepsy and sleep apnoea
Narcolepsy and obstructive sleep apnoea both cause excessive daytime sleepiness. Compare the two disorders and their treatments.
Step 1: A similarity
Both cause excessive daytime sleepiness that affects concentration and safety (for example when driving), and both are diagnosed with a sleep study.
Step 2: The cause of the sleepiness
In sleep apnoea, the airway repeatedly collapses during sleep, breathing stops for 10 seconds or more, and the person wakes briefly many times, so sleep is broken and unrefreshing. In narcolepsy, the brain cannot keep wakefulness stable (linked to the loss of wake-promoting neurons in the hypothalamus), so sleep intrudes into the day whatever the night's sleep was like.
Step 3: Features
Sleep apnoea brings loud snoring, gasping and morning headaches; narcolepsy brings sudden sleep attacks, REM within minutes of falling asleep, and often cataplexy.
Step 4: Treatments
Sleep apnoea is treated by keeping the airway open (CPAP, weight loss, sleeping on the side); narcolepsy has no cure and is managed with scheduled naps, regular sleep and medication.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Both cause daytime sleepiness, are diagnosed by sleep studies and affect safety. In sleep apnoea the sleepiness comes from sleep broken by repeated pauses in breathing (snoring, gasping), treated with CPAP; in narcolepsy it comes from unstable control of wakefulness (sleep attacks, early REM, cataplexy), managed with naps and medication.
Method
Start with a similarity.
Compare the cause, the features and the treatment, point by point.
Watch out for
Writing two separate descriptions without linking words such as "whereas" or "both".
Common mistake
Narcolepsy is not just being tired
Many people are sleepy after a late night. Narcolepsy is a neurological disorder: sleep attacks happen however much the person has slept, and they enter REM almost immediately. Mention the early REM and, where relevant, cataplexy.
Treating sleep disorders. Treatment depends on the disorder.
- Narcolepsy: no cure; managed with regular sleep times, short scheduled daytime naps, and medications from a doctor that promote wakefulness or reduce cataplexy.
- Sleep apnoea: a CPAP machine (continuous positive airway pressure) blows air through a mask to hold the airway open; also weight loss, sleeping on the side, avoiding alcohol before bed, a mouthguard-like splint, or surgery.
- Sleepwalking: making the bedroom and house safe (locked doors and windows, no obstacles), regular and sufficient sleep and less stress, since sleep loss makes episodes more likely; gently guiding the person back to bed rather than waking them roughly.
- Sleep-onset insomnia: cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia (below), the recommended first treatment.
- Circadian phase disorders: bright light therapy (below).
Key idea
Cognitive behavioural therapy for insomnia (CBT-I)
A short structured therapy, usually 4 to 8 sessions, that changes the thoughts and behaviours that keep insomnia going.
- Stimulus control. Use the bed only for sleep. Go to bed only when sleepy; if not asleep within about 20 minutes, get up, do something calm in dim light and return when sleepy. Get up at the same time every day. The bed becomes a cue for sleep again, not for lying awake.
- Sleep restriction. Limit time in bed to about the time actually spent asleep, then lengthen it as sleep becomes efficient. Mild sleep pressure makes falling asleep easier.
- Cognitive restructuring. Challenge unhelpful beliefs such as "If I don't get eight hours I'll fail tomorrow", which cause the worry that keeps the person awake.
- Sleep hygiene and relaxation. No caffeine late in the day, no screens in bed, a dark, cool room, a wind-down routine; relaxation training for tension.
Its gains last after therapy ends, unlike sleeping tablets, which can lose their effect and are not meant for long-term use.
A therapist tells a client with sleep-onset insomnia to get out of bed if they have not fallen asleep after about 20 minutes, and to use the bed only for sleep. Which part of CBT-I is this?
Circadian phase disorders are disorders in which the body clock is out of step with the times a person needs to sleep. The most common in young people is delayed sleep–wake phase disorder: the person cannot fall asleep until very late (perhaps 2 or 3 am) and cannot wake for school or work, although they sleep normally if allowed to keep their own late hours. It is an extreme form of the adolescent shift. Older adults may have the opposite, an advanced phase. Shift work and jet lag cause temporary mismatches.
Key idea
Bright light therapy
Exposure to bright light, from a light box (often about 10 000 lux) or outdoor daylight, at a set time each day, to shift the body clock.
- For a delayed phase: bright light for about 30 minutes soon after waking, in the morning, with dim light in the evening. Light in the morning makes the SCN advance the clock, so melatonin is secreted earlier each evening and sleepiness comes earlier.
- For an advanced phase: bright light in the evening delays the clock.
The clock moves gradually, so the person also shifts their waking time step by step over days to weeks.
This teenager's melatonin rises late. Choose when to give bright light, and watch the onset of melatonin day by day.
Explain why bright light therapy for delayed sleep–wake phase disorder is given in the morning rather than the evening.
Exam tip
Comparing disorders
Compare on the same features for each disorder: what happens, when (which stage or time of night), the cause where known, and the effects during the day. Similarities count too: all four disturb sleep or daytime functioning, and sleep apnoea and narcolepsy both cause excessive daytime sleepiness, for different reasons.
Summary
Narcolepsy: sudden sleep attacks and very early REM, often with cataplexy; managed with naps, regular sleep and medication.
Sleep-onset insomnia: persistent difficulty falling asleep; treated first with CBT-I (stimulus control, sleep restriction, cognitive restructuring, sleep hygiene).
Obstructive sleep apnoea: repeated pauses in breathing of 10 seconds or more as the airway collapses; treated with CPAP and lifestyle changes.
Sleepwalking: a parasomnia in NREM stage 3, early in the night; managed by keeping the person safe and reducing sleep loss and stress.
Bright light therapy shifts the body clock: morning light advances a delayed phase; evening light delays an advanced one.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.