Lesson 10 of 10 · 12 min
Wave–particle duality of light
Identify the evidence that supports the wave model of light and the evidence that supports the particle model, and explain why physicists need both.
What you will be able to do
- Identify evidence that supports the wave characteristics of light and explain how it does.
- Identify evidence that supports the particle characteristics of light and explain how it does.
- Describe wave–particle duality and what the double slit shows when light arrives one photon at a time.
You have now seen light behave in two ways that seem impossible to combine. In Young's double slit it spreads out and interferes like a wave. In the photoelectric effect it arrives in lumps, one photon freeing one electron, like a stream of particles. So which is it?
The honest answer is both. This lesson pulls together the evidence on each side, which is exactly what QCAA asks you to identify.
| Evidence | What is observed | Model it supports |
|---|---|---|
| Double slit interference | Bright and dark fringes; dark where light from both slits arrives | Wave: superposition, with destructive interference at the dark fringes |
| Diffraction | Light spreads round edges and through narrow gaps, more for longer wavelengths | Wave: only waves bend round obstacles comparable in size to their wavelength |
| Polarisation | Two crossed polarising filters block light completely | Wave: only transverse waves can be polarised |
| Speed of light in water | Light is slower in water than in air (Foucault, 1850) | Wave: Newton's particle model predicted it would be faster |
| Photoelectric effect | Threshold frequency, no time delay, kinetic energy set by frequency not intensity | Particle: one photon of energy frees one electron |
| Black-body radiation | The spectrum's shape fits only if energy is quantised | Particle: energy is emitted in quanta |
| Line spectra | Each atom emits only specific wavelengths | Particle: each transition emits one photon, |
Key idea
Wave–particle duality
Light shows wave behaviour when it travels and spreads (interference, diffraction, polarisation) and particle behaviour when it is emitted or absorbed (the photoelectric effect, line spectra). Neither model explains everything on its own, so physicists use both. Each is valid in its own realm.
The two pictures are linked by the photon equations, which connect particle properties (energy , momentum ) to wave properties (frequency , wavelength ):
Switch on Send photons one at a time and press Send 1 a few times: each photon lands at a single point, like a particle. Then press Send 100 a few times and watch the dots build up the interference fringes, like a wave. No photon ever lands in the middle of a dark fringe.
Select all the observations that provide evidence for the particle (photon) model of light.
Worked example
Describing wave–particle duality with evidence
Describe the wave–particle duality of light. In your answer, identify one piece of evidence that supports the wave model and one that supports the particle model, and explain how each supports it. (4 marks)
Step 1: Define the idea
Wave–particle duality means light shows wave properties in some situations and particle properties in others, so neither model alone describes all of its behaviour.
Step 2: Wave evidence, the observation
In Young's double slit experiment, light through two narrow slits forms equally spaced bright and dark fringes on a screen.
Step 3: Wave evidence, the explanation
The fringes are an interference pattern. At dark fringes, waves from the two slits arrive half a wavelength out of step and cancel. Particles cannot cancel each other, so this supports the wave model.
Name it, describe it, link it. The link earns the mark.
Step 4: Particle evidence, the observation
In the photoelectric effect, light below a threshold frequency releases no electrons, however intense it is, and above it electrons are released instantly.
Step 5: Particle evidence, the explanation
This makes sense only if light arrives as photons of energy , each giving all its energy to one electron. A photon with below the work function cannot free an electron, whatever the intensity. This supports the particle model.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Light behaves as a wave in some experiments and as a stream of particles (photons) in others; both models are needed. In Young's double slit experiment, light passing through two slits produces bright and dark fringes. The dark fringes are where waves from the two slits arrive out of phase and cancel by destructive interference, which only a wave can do. In the photoelectric effect, no electrons are emitted below a threshold frequency regardless of intensity, and emission is instant above it. This is explained if light consists of photons of energy , each giving all its energy to a single electron, so only photons with can release electrons.
Method
Define duality in one sentence.
For each model: name the evidence, state the observation, explain the link.
Watch out for
Listing evidence without explaining how it supports the model.
Calling the photoelectric effect evidence for waves because light is involved.
Very dim light is sent through a double slit, so that only one photon is in the apparatus at a time. What is observed on a sensitive screen?
Exam tip
Answering 'describe the evidence' questions
For each piece of evidence, give three things:
- Name the phenomenon (for example, the photoelectric effect).
- State what is observed (no emission below a threshold frequency, whatever the intensity).
- Link it to the model (only a photon with can free an electron, so light must come in packets).
One piece of evidence explained this way earns more marks than a list of five names.
Common mistake
Common slips with duality
- Calling the photoelectric effect wave evidence because 'light is shining on the metal'. Ask which model the observation needs: here, photons.
- Saying light 'switches' between being a wave and a particle. Both descriptions apply all the time; an experiment shows one aspect or the other.
- Naming evidence without saying how it supports the model.
Note
How the models of light have changed
Newton's particles gave way to Young's and Maxwell's waves in the 1800s, when the wave model explained interference and the speed of light in water. Around 1900, black-body radiation and the photoelectric effect challenged the wave model, and the photon was born. Neither model was thrown away: each was kept for what it explains well, and quantum electrodynamics later combined both. It is a clear example of a theory being refined, rather than simply replaced, when new evidence appears.
Summary
Wave evidence: interference (the double slit), diffraction, polarisation and the slower speed of light in water.
Particle evidence: the photoelectric effect, black-body radiation (quantised energy) and line spectra.
Light travels and spreads like a wave, but is emitted and absorbed like a particle. Both models are needed.
The photon equations and connect the particle properties to the wave properties.
Sent one photon at a time through a double slit, light arrives as single dots that build up an interference pattern.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.