Lesson 9 of 10 · 18 min
Matter waves and the Bohr orbits
Calculate the de Broglie wavelength of a moving particle, describe the evidence for electron waves, and use and to explain and solve problems about Bohr's orbits.
What you will be able to do
- Calculate the de Broglie wavelength of a particle using .
- Describe the experimental evidence that electrons behave as waves.
- Explain Bohr's allowed orbits as electron standing waves, , and show that this gives .
- Calculate the wavelength, speed and angular momentum of an electron in a Bohr orbit.
By the 1920s light had a split personality: a wave in the double slit, a stream of particles in the photoelectric effect. In 1924 a French PhD student, Louis de Broglie, asked the reverse question. If waves can behave like particles, can particles behave like waves?
He proposed that every moving particle has a wavelength, linked to its momentum by the same relation that holds for photons.
Raise the accelerating voltage (or the speed) and the electron's wavelength shrinks, because . Then switch to a proton, an alpha particle or a ball: the bigger the momentum, the shorter the wavelength. A ball's wavelength is far too small ever to detect.
Key idea
Evidence that electrons are waves
In 1927 Clinton Davisson and Lester Germer fired electrons at a nickel crystal and found strong reflections only at certain angles, a diffraction pattern just like X-rays give. At about the same time George Paget Thomson sent electrons through thin metal foil and saw diffraction rings. In both experiments the measured wavelength matched .
Diffraction is only noticeable when the wavelength is similar to the size of the gaps, and the spacing of atoms in a crystal (about ) is about the de Broglie wavelength of electrons accelerated through a hundred volts or so.
Worked example
The wavelength of an accelerated electron
An electron is accelerated from rest through a potential difference of . Calculate its de Broglie wavelength.
Step 1: Find the kinetic energy
From : the field does work on the electron.
Step 2: Find the momentum
From :
This combines and , so you don't need the speed. (It is , about 2 % of , so classical physics is fine.)
Step 3: Use the de Broglie relation
Step 4: Interpret
About , similar to the spacing of atoms in a crystal. That is why crystals diffract electrons, as Davisson and Germer found.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
()
Method
.
(or find , then ).
.
Watch out for
Using the voltage as if it were the kinetic energy in joules.
Forgetting the square root when finding the momentum.
Calculate the de Broglie wavelength of a tennis ball travelling at .
Common mistake
Getting the momentum right
- Use the mass in kilograms: for an electron.
- For a particle accelerated from rest through a potential difference , find the kinetic energy first, , then the momentum: (from ).
- This works for speeds well below . Electrons accelerated through a few thousand volts or less are fine.
De Broglie's idea also explained Bohr's mysterious rule. Picture the electron's wave wrapped round its orbit. If a whole number of wavelengths fits round the circumference, the wave joins up smoothly with itself and forms a stable standing wave. If it doesn't fit, the wave on each lap is out of step with the last and cancels itself out. So only orbits that fit a whole number of wavelengths are allowed.
An allowed orbit, : four whole wavelengths fit the circumference and the wave joins onto itself.
Not allowed: wavelengths per lap. On the second lap the wave is upside down compared with the first, so it interferes destructively with itself.
Switch on Electron as a standing wave, then move the electron between levels (up to ). Each allowed orbit holds exactly wavelengths: one for , two for , and so on, while the orbit radius grows as .
From standing waves to Bohr's rule,
Start with the standing-wave condition and substitute the de Broglie wavelength :
The left side, , is the electron's angular momentum. So Bohr's quantisation rule, which he had simply assumed in 1913, follows from treating the electron as a wave. This is why the data book lists both equations together.
Worked example
The electron's wavelength and speed in a Bohr orbit
In the Bohr model, the radius of the orbit of hydrogen is . Calculate (a) the de Broglie wavelength of the electron in this orbit and (b) the electron's speed.
Step 1: Use the standing-wave condition
Two whole wavelengths fit round the circumference of the second orbit.
Step 2: Rearrange the de Broglie relation for v
Step 3: Substitute
Step 4: Check with Bohr's rule
The same answer, as it must be, since comes from .
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) (b)
Method
.
, or directly .
Watch out for
Forgetting to divide by : the circumference holds wavelengths, not one.
Calculate the angular momentum of the electron in the orbit of a Bohr hydrogen atom.
An electron's speed is doubled (it stays well below the speed of light). What happens to its de Broglie wavelength?
Summary
Every moving particle has a de Broglie wavelength .
Electron diffraction (Davisson and Germer; G. P. Thomson) confirmed that electrons behave as waves with this wavelength.
Everyday objects have wavelengths far too small to ever show wave effects.
A Bohr orbit is allowed when a whole number of electron wavelengths fits round it: .
Substituting gives Bohr's rule, .
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.