Lesson 6 of 10 · 16 min
From Rutherford's atom to Bohr's atom
Trace the model of the atom from Thomson to Rutherford to Bohr, explain the evidence and the problems that drove each change, and compare the Rutherford and Bohr models.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the Thomson, Rutherford and Bohr models of the atom and the evidence for each.
- Explain why Rutherford's model could not explain the stability of atoms or line spectra.
- State Bohr's postulates.
- Compare the Rutherford and Bohr models, giving similarities and differences.
In 1897 J. J. Thomson discovered the electron, a tiny negative particle found in every kind of atom. Atoms are neutral, so they must also contain positive charge. Thomson pictured the atom as a sphere of spread-out positive charge with electrons dotted through it, like fruit in a pudding: the plum pudding model.
A good model has to survive new evidence. This one didn't last long.
History
The gold foil experiment
In 1909 Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden, working with Ernest Rutherford, fired alpha particles at gold foil less than a thousandth of a millimetre thick. In Thomson's model the positive charge is spread thinly, so every alpha particle should pass through with at most a tiny deflection.
Most did pass straight through. But about 1 in 8000 bounced back towards the source. Rutherford said it was 'as if you fired a 15-inch shell at a piece of tissue paper and it came back and hit you'.
Alpha particle paths near one gold nucleus (not to scale). Only a particle that comes very close to the nucleus is strongly deflected.
Key idea
Rutherford's nuclear model (1911)
- Nearly all the mass and all the positive charge are concentrated in a tiny, dense nucleus, about to across, while the atom is about across.
- The atom is mostly empty space, which is why most alpha particles pass straight through.
- Electrons orbit the nucleus, held by electrostatic attraction, like planets round the Sun.
Which observation from the gold foil experiment showed that the positive charge in an atom is concentrated in a tiny, dense nucleus?
Rutherford's model explained the scattering, but it had two serious problems, both from classical physics.
Stability. An electron moving in a circle is accelerating towards the centre. You learnt in Unit 3 that an accelerating charge radiates electromagnetic waves. So an orbiting electron should steadily lose energy and spiral into the nucleus, in about . Atoms would collapse almost instantly, yet they are stable.
Spectra. As the spiralling electron's orbit shrank, the frequency of the light it gave off would change smoothly, so atoms should emit a continuous spread of colours. Instead, a hot gas of hydrogen emits only a few sharp wavelengths: a line spectrum.
Why does classical physics predict that the electrons in Rutherford's atom should spiral into the nucleus?
Definition
Bohr's postulates (1913)
Niels Bohr kept Rutherford's nucleus but added rules that broke with classical physics:
- The electron can only move in certain allowed circular orbits, called stationary states. In these orbits it does not radiate, however long it stays.
- The allowed orbits are those in which the electron's angular momentum is a whole-number multiple of : , with
- The electron emits or absorbs a single photon only when it jumps between allowed orbits. The photon's energy equals the difference in the energies of the orbits: .
| Feature | Rutherford (1911) | Bohr (1913) |
|---|---|---|
| Nucleus | Tiny, dense, positive; nearly all the mass | The same |
| Electron orbits | Any radius, like planets | Only certain allowed orbits (stationary states) |
| Electron energy | Any value (continuous) | Quantised: only certain energy levels |
| Radiation | Orbiting electrons should radiate continuously | No radiation in an allowed orbit; one photon, , per jump |
| Stability | Predicts collapse in about | Stable: the lowest orbit is the ground state |
| Spectra | Predicts a continuous spectrum | Explains the hydrogen line spectrum and the Rydberg equation |
| Limitations | Cannot explain stability or line spectra | Works only for one-electron atoms and ions; cannot explain line intensities or many-electron atoms |
Common mistake
Two ways to lose marks on atomic models
- Describing instead of comparing. Two separate paragraphs, one per model, don't answer 'compare'. Write sentences that mention both models: 'Both have…', 'In Rutherford's model…, whereas in Bohr's…'.
- Giving the wrong reason for collapse. Rutherford's atom is unstable because an orbiting electron is accelerating and so radiates energy, not because the nucleus attracts it 'too strongly'.
Worked example
Comparing the Rutherford and Bohr models
Compare the models of the atom proposed by Rutherford and Bohr. (4 marks)
Step 1: Decide what 'compare' needs
'Compare' means give similarities and differences. Four marks suggests two of each, or one similarity and three differences, each clearly linked to both models.
Step 2: Similarity 1, the nucleus
Both models have a tiny, dense, positively charged nucleus containing nearly all the atom's mass, with the electrons outside it in mostly empty space.
Step 3: Similarity 2, orbiting electrons
In both, electrons orbit the nucleus, held in circular paths by electrostatic attraction.
Step 4: Difference 1, allowed orbits and energies
In Rutherford's model an electron could orbit at any radius with any energy. In Bohr's model only certain orbits are allowed, so the electron's energy is quantised into fixed levels.
Step 5: Difference 2, radiation, stability and spectra
Rutherford's orbiting electrons should radiate continuously and spiral into the nucleus, giving unstable atoms and a continuous spectrum. Bohr's electrons do not radiate in an allowed orbit. They emit or absorb a single photon, with , only when they jump between orbits, which explains stable atoms and hydrogen's line spectrum.
The second difference is the one that shows why Bohr's model has greater explanatory power.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Both models have a tiny, dense, positive nucleus holding nearly all the atom's mass, and both have electrons orbiting it under electrostatic attraction in mostly empty space. In Rutherford's model, electrons can orbit at any radius with any energy, so they should radiate as they accelerate, spiral into the nucleus and give a continuous spectrum. In Bohr's model, electrons can occupy only certain allowed orbits with fixed, quantised energies, and do not radiate while in them. They emit or absorb one photon () only when jumping between orbits, which explains why atoms are stable and why hydrogen has a line spectrum.
Method
Give at least one similarity and one difference, using both models in each sentence.
Cover the key difference: quantised orbits and energy levels.
Link the difference to the evidence it explains (stability, line spectra).
Watch out for
Describing each model separately without actually comparing them.
Giving only differences, which 'compare' does not allow.
Select all the features of Bohr's model that were not part of Rutherford's model.
Key idea
How a theory gets replaced
Each model was kept until evidence appeared that it could not explain:
- Thomson's model could not explain large-angle alpha scattering, so it gave way to Rutherford's nuclear model.
- Rutherford's model could not explain stable atoms or line spectra. Bohr's model kept what worked (the nucleus) and added quantum rules, giving it greater explanatory power.
- Bohr's model works brilliantly for hydrogen but not for atoms with more electrons. In the 1920s it was replaced by quantum mechanics, in which electrons are described by waves and probability 'clouds' (orbitals). The idea of fixed energy levels survived.
History
Energy levels everywhere
Bohr won the 1922 Nobel Prize for his model of the atom. The idea of quantised energy levels kept spreading. In 1949 Maria Goeppert-Mayer (and, independently, J. Hans D. Jensen) showed that protons and neutrons inside the nucleus also fill energy levels, or shells. Her nuclear shell model explained why nuclei with certain 'magic numbers' of protons or neutrons (2, 8, 20, 28, 50, 82, 126) are especially stable, and won her the 1963 Nobel Prize in Physics.
Put these models of the atom in the order in which they were proposed, earliest first.
Summary
Thomson's plum pudding model was overturned by the gold foil experiment: a few alpha particles bounced back.
Rutherford's nuclear model: a tiny, dense, positive nucleus with electrons orbiting in mostly empty space.
Classical physics says orbiting (accelerating) electrons radiate and spiral inwards, so Rutherford's atom should be unstable and emit a continuous spectrum.
Bohr's postulates: allowed non-radiating orbits, , and photons emitted or absorbed only in jumps, .
Compare the models with similarities (nucleus, orbiting electrons) and differences (quantised orbits and energies, stability, line spectra).
Finished the lesson?
Try the 4 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.