Lesson 11 of 12 · 16 min
Kepler's laws of planetary motion
State Kepler's three laws, use the third law to compare the orbits of planets, and see how careful data moved astronomy from an Earth-centred to a Sun-centred solar system.
What you will be able to do
- State Kepler's three laws of planetary motion.
- Use the law of areas to compare a planet's speed at different points of its orbit.
- Use to compare two orbits around the same body.
- Compare the geocentric and heliocentric models and explain why the heliocentric model was slow to be accepted.
Every day the Sun rises in the east and sets in the west, and every night the stars wheel overhead. The obvious explanation, and the accepted one for about 1400 years, is that the Earth sits still at the centre and everything else goes around it.
Overturning that idea took more than a clever alternative. It took better data than anyone had collected before, and a willingness to follow the data when it disagreed with a beautiful theory.
Geocentric model
The Earth is stationary at the centre. The Moon, Sun, planets and stars move around it. In Ptolemy's version (about 150 CE) each planet moves on a small circle (an epicycle) that rides around a larger one, to explain why planets sometimes appear to move backwards across the sky. It predicted planetary positions reasonably well for centuries.
Heliocentric model
The Sun is at the centre and the Earth is one of the planets orbiting it, spinning daily on its axis. A planet's backward loops are an effect of the Earth overtaking it (or being overtaken). Copernicus published this model in 1543, still with circular orbits. Kepler's ellipses made it far more accurate than any geocentric model.
History
How the data changed the model
- Tycho Brahe (late 1500s) measured planetary positions with the naked eye more precisely than ever before, about of a degree. He favoured a compromise model with the Earth still at the centre.
- Johannes Kepler, working from Tycho's records of Mars, found that no combination of circles fitted them: the best circular orbit missed by about of a degree. Rather than ignore the gap, he tried an ellipse, and it fitted. He published his first two laws in 1609 and the third in 1619.
- Galileo Galilei turned a telescope on the sky in 1609–1610 and saw moons orbiting Jupiter and Venus showing a full set of phases, both hard to explain if everything circles the Earth.
- Isaac Newton (1687) showed that one law of gravitation produces all three of Kepler's laws.
Note
Why acceptance was slow
Supporters of the heliocentric model faced real obstacles. It contradicted everyday experience (we do not feel the Earth moving) and the physics of the day. It predicted that nearby stars should shift slightly as the Earth orbits, and that shift (stellar parallax) was too small to measure until 1838. Copernicus's circular orbits were not more accurate than Ptolemy's. And it clashed with the religious and academic authorities of the time: in 1633 the Roman Inquisition tried Galileo, forced him to recant, and confined him to house arrest for the rest of his life.
The law of areas, with the ellipse exaggerated. The planet covers the long arc near perihelion in the same time as the short arc near aphelion, so it moves fastest when closest to the Sun.
Key idea
Kepler's three laws
- The law of orbits. Each planet moves in an ellipse with the Sun at one focus.
- The law of areas. The line joining a planet to the Sun sweeps out equal areas in equal times, so a planet moves fastest at perihelion (closest to the Sun) and slowest at aphelion (furthest).
- The law of periods. The square of a planet's orbital period is proportional to the cube of its mean distance from the Sun (the semi-major axis of its ellipse), so has the same value for every planet of the Sun.
Real planetary orbits are only slightly elliptical. The Earth's distance from the Sun varies by only about over a year, which is why the third law works well with as an average orbital radius, and why later lessons treat orbits as circles.
Watch the speed change around the orbit. Then move the planet further from the Sun: how much longer is its year when its distance doubles?
A comet follows a very elongated elliptical orbit around the Sun. Where in its orbit does it move fastest?
Using the third law as a ratio. For two bodies orbiting the same central body, . Any consistent units work: for planets of the Sun, measuring in Earth years and in astronomical units (AU, the mean Earth–Sun distance) makes the Earth's ratio exactly , so .
Worked example
Jupiter's year from Kepler's third law
Jupiter's mean distance from the Sun is , where (astronomical unit) is the mean distance from the Earth to the Sun.
Use Kepler's third law to calculate Jupiter's orbital period in Earth years.
Step 1: Compare two planets of the same star
Both planets orbit the Sun, so .
The constant depends only on the mass being orbited, so it is the same for every planet of the Sun.
Step 2: Use the Earth as the reference
With and , the right side is , so in years and astronomical units.
Step 3: Solve
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
About Earth years.
Method
Check that both bodies orbit the same central mass.
Set using any consistent units.
Solve for the unknown, taking a square root or cube root at the end.
Watch out for
Writing , which swaps the powers.
Comparing a moon of Jupiter with a planet of the Sun. Different central masses have different constants.
Mars orbits the Sun at a mean distance of . Use Kepler's third law to calculate its orbital period in Earth years, to three significant figures.
Put these steps in the development of our model of the solar system in order, earliest first.
Common mistake
Common errors with Kepler's laws
- Putting the Sun at the centre of the ellipse. It is at a focus, off-centre.
- Saying planets move at a constant speed. They speed up near the Sun and slow down far from it.
- Comparing orbits around different bodies, such as the Moon and Mars, with the third law. The ratio is only shared by objects orbiting the same central mass.
Summary
First law: planets move in ellipses with the Sun at one focus.
Second law: the line to the Sun sweeps equal areas in equal times, so planets move fastest at perihelion.
Third law: , and is the same for everything orbiting the same body.
In years and astronomical units, for the planets of the Sun.
The heliocentric model won because careful data, especially Tycho's and Kepler's, left no other explanation, despite opposition from everyday experience, the physics of the time and the authorities.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.