Lesson 4 of 12 · 17 min
Specialisation and the gains from trade
Show the gains when each country specialises by comparative advantage: higher world output, consumption beyond each PPC, and the range of terms of trade at which both countries gain.
What you will be able to do
- Calculate world output before and after specialisation, and the gain.
- Find the range of terms of trade at which both countries gain, and test a proposed rate.
- Show on each country's PPC that trade lets it consume beyond its own production possibilities.
- State the assumptions of the comparative advantage model and its limitations.
Knowing who has the comparative advantage is half the story. The other half is showing that specialising and trading actually leaves both countries better off, and on what terms. You will use the same illustrative table as the last lesson.
| Country | Wheat (tonnes) | Clothing (bales) | Cost of 1 wheat | Cost of 1 clothing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Australia | 120 | 60 | 0.5 clothing | 2 wheat |
| Vietnam | 40 | 40 | 1 clothing | 1 wheat |
Before trade, each country makes both goods for itself. Say Australia produces 60 wheat and 30 clothing, and Vietnam 30 wheat and 10 clothing (both on their PPCs: Australia uses half its resources on each good; Vietnam three-quarters on wheat). The world makes wheat and clothing.
After specialising, Australia makes only wheat (120) and Vietnam only clothing (40). The world now makes 120 wheat and 40 clothing: 30 more tonnes of wheat with no less clothing. That extra output is the gain from specialisation, to be shared by trading.
Key idea
The terms of trade must sit between the two opportunity costs
Australia will sell wheat only if it gets more than 0.5 clothing per wheat (what wheat costs it to make). Vietnam will buy wheat only if it pays less than 1 clothing per wheat (what wheat costs it to make itself). So both gain at any rate between the two:
At exactly 0.5, all the gain goes to Vietnam; at exactly 1, all to Australia. In the model these are called the terms of trade, the same idea as the price index you meet later in the topic.
Say they agree on 1 wheat = 0.75 clothing, and Australia exports 40 wheat for clothing.
- Australia produces 120 wheat, keeps 80 and gets 30 clothing: it consumes 80 wheat and 30 clothing. Making 30 clothing itself would have left it only 60 wheat, so it gains 20 wheat.
- Vietnam produces 40 clothing, keeps 10 and gets 40 wheat: it consumes 40 wheat and 10 clothing. Making 10 clothing itself would have left it only 30 wheat, so it gains 10 wheat.
The two gains, wheat, are exactly the extra world output.
Australia produces at P, trades along the line from P, and consumes at C, outside its own PPC. Before trade it was at B.
Which of these terms of trade would let both Australia and Vietnam gain from trading wheat for clothing?
Illustrative figures. Drag the terms of trade outside the range and watch one country's gain disappear.
Worked example
Show that specialisation and trade benefit both countries
With all their resources for a year, Australia can produce 60 units of beef or 30 units of textiles, and Indonesia 20 units of beef or 40 units of textiles (illustrative). Before trade, Australia produces 30 beef and 15 textiles, and Indonesia 10 beef and 20 textiles.
(a) Show that specialising by comparative advantage raises world output. (b) The two countries agree to trade 20 beef for 20 textiles. Show that both gain.
Step 1: Find the comparative advantages
Opportunity cost of 1 beef: Australia textiles, Indonesia textiles. Australia has the comparative advantage in beef, Indonesia in textiles.
Step 2: World output before
Beef ; textiles .
Step 3: World output after specialising
Australia makes 60 beef, Indonesia 40 textiles. World output is 60 beef and 40 textiles: 20 more beef and 5 more textiles.
Step 4: Check the terms of trade
20 beef for 20 textiles is 1 beef = 1 textile, which lies between the opportunity costs (0.5 and 2), so both can gain.
Step 5: Each country's consumption after trade
Australia: beef and 20 textiles (before: 30 and 15). Indonesia: 20 beef and textiles (before: 10 and 20).
Australia has more of both goods; Indonesia has 10 more beef and the same textiles. Neither could reach these points on its own PPC.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
World output rises from 40 beef and 35 textiles to 60 beef and 40 textiles. At 1 beef = 1 textile (between the costs of 0.5 and 2), Australia consumes 40 beef and 20 textiles instead of 30 and 15, and Indonesia 20 beef and 20 textiles instead of 10 and 20: both gain.
Method
Find the opportunity costs and comparative advantages.
Compare world output before and after full specialisation.
Check the terms of trade lie between the two opportunity costs.
Compare each country's consumption with its pre-trade point.
Watch out for
Forgetting to check that the terms of trade lie between the opportunity costs.
Comparing consumption after trade with the PPC's ends rather than with the country's point before trade.
Move each country's resources between the goods. Full specialisation is not the only allocation that gains.
Worked example
Decide whether proposed terms of trade benefit both countries
Australia needs 4 hours of labour to produce a tonne of wheat and 12 hours to make a laptop; Malaysia needs 10 hours and 15 hours (illustrative). Malaysia proposes to sell laptops to Australia at 1 laptop = 4 tonnes of wheat.
(a) Explain whether Australia should accept. (b) Find a rate at which both would gain, and calculate how many tonnes of wheat Australia saves by importing 10 laptops at that rate instead of making them.
Step 1: Each country's cost of a laptop
Australia: tonnes of wheat per laptop. Malaysia: tonnes per laptop.
Step 2: Judge the proposal
At 4 tonnes per laptop Australia would pay more than the 3 tonnes a laptop costs it to make. Australia should reject it: it gains by making its own laptops.
Step 3: The range at which both gain
Malaysia gains if it receives more than 1.5 tonnes per laptop; Australia gains if it pays less than 3. Any rate with works, for example 1 laptop = 2 tonnes of wheat.
Step 4: Australia's saving on 10 laptops
Making 10 laptops would cost Australia tonnes of wheat. Buying them at 2 tonnes each costs tonnes. Australia saves tonnes of wheat.
The saving is the gain from trade for Australia: the wheat it no longer gives up.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Reject: 4 tonnes per laptop exceeds Australia's own cost of 3 tonnes. Any rate between 1.5 and 3 tonnes per laptop benefits both; at 1 laptop = 2 tonnes, importing 10 laptops costs 20 tonnes instead of 30, saving Australia 10 tonnes of wheat.
Method
Find each country's opportunity cost of the good being traded.
The terms must lie strictly between the two costs.
The gain is the difference between the cost of making the goods and the cost of buying them.
Watch out for
Using the output-table rule on hours: the cost of a laptop here is hours for a laptop ÷ hours for wheat.
Accepting any rate below Malaysia's cost: Malaysia would not sell below 1.5.
Note
The model's assumptions
Ricardo's model is a simplification. It assumes two countries and two goods; constant opportunity costs (straight-line PPCs); full employment; resources that move freely between industries within a country but not between countries; no transport costs and no trade barriers; and that the gains are what matter, not who receives them.
Which of these is a reason the real gains from specialisation may be smaller than the model predicts? Select all that apply.
Exam tip
Show the gain with numbers
When asked to show that specialisation benefits both countries, set out world output before and after in a table, state the terms of trade you assume and check they lie between the two opportunity costs, then compare each country's consumption with what it could produce alone.
Summary
Specialising by comparative advantage raises world output; trade shares the gain.
Both countries gain only when the terms of trade lie between their two opportunity costs.
With trade, each country can consume at a point beyond its own PPC.
The model assumes constant costs, full employment, no transport costs or barriers, and immobile factors between countries; real gains are smaller and unevenly shared.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.