Lesson 3 of 12 · 18 min
Absolute and comparative advantage
Use Smith's absolute advantage and Ricardo's comparative advantage to decide what each country should produce, calculating opportunity costs from output and input tables.
What you will be able to do
- Explain absolute advantage (Adam Smith) and comparative advantage (David Ricardo), and why each was developed.
- Calculate the opportunity cost of each good for each country from an output table and from an input (hours per unit) table.
- Decide which country has the absolute and the comparative advantage in each good, and justify it.
- Link comparative advantage to factor endowments.
In 1776 Adam Smith published The Wealth of Nations. Most governments of his day believed a nation grew rich by exporting as much and importing as little as possible, hoarding gold (mercantilism). Smith argued the opposite: a nation grows rich by specialising in what it does best and trading for the rest, just as a tailor buys shoes instead of making them.
Definition
Absolute advantage
A country has an absolute advantage in a good when it can produce more of it than another country with the same resources, or the same amount with fewer resources.
Illustrative figures: the most of each good each country can make with all its resources in a year.
When each country is absolutely better at a different good, the case for trade is easy to see. But what if one country is better at both? Smith's test then finds no reason to trade. In 1817 David Ricardo, in On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation, showed that trade still pays. His example had Portugal producing both wine and cloth with less labour than England, yet both gained when Portugal made wine and England made cloth. What matters is not who is better, but what each country gives up.
Definition
Comparative advantage
A country has a comparative advantage in a good when it can produce it at a lower opportunity cost than another country: it gives up less of the other good to make one more unit. Each country gains by specialising in the good of its comparative advantage and trading for the other.
| Country | Wheat (tonnes) | Clothing (bales) |
|---|---|---|
| Australia | 120 | 60 |
| Vietnam | 40 | 40 |
Australia's PPC is a straight line: every tonne of wheat costs the same half bale of clothing.
Australia can make 120 tonnes of wheat or 60 bales of clothing. Moving all its resources from clothing to wheat gains 120 wheat and loses 60 clothing, so each tonne of wheat costs bales of clothing. The cost of one bale of clothing is the reciprocal, tonnes of wheat.
Opportunity cost from an output table
Cost of one X
Divide the most of Y by the most of X: , in units of Y.
Cost of one Y
The reciprocal: , in units of X.
Compare across countries
For each good, the country with the lower opportunity cost has the comparative advantage.
Check
Each country should have the comparative advantage in exactly one good (unless their costs are equal, when there is no gain from trade).
| Country | Cost of 1 tonne of wheat | Cost of 1 bale of clothing |
|---|---|---|
| Australia | clothing | wheat |
| Vietnam | clothing | wheat |
Australia has the absolute advantage in both goods (120 > 40 and 60 > 40). But its wheat costs only 0.5 clothing against Vietnam's 1, while its clothing costs 2 wheat against Vietnam's 1. So Australia has the comparative advantage in wheat and Vietnam in clothing.
Using the same idea, a country can produce 90 tonnes of beef or 30 tonnes of wool in a year. What is the opportunity cost of one tonne of wool, in tonnes of beef?
Worked example
Find opportunity costs and advantages from an output table
Using all their resources for a year, Australia and New Zealand can produce these amounts (illustrative, thousand tonnes):
| Country | Beef | Wine |
|---|---|---|
| Australia | 80 | 40 |
| New Zealand | 30 | 20 |
(a) Calculate each country's opportunity cost of producing one unit of beef and one unit of wine. (b) Identify which country has the absolute advantage and which has the comparative advantage in each good.
Step 1: Opportunity cost of beef
Divide the most wine by the most beef. Australia: wine per beef. New Zealand: wine per beef (to 2 d.p.).
Step 2: Opportunity cost of wine
The reciprocals. Australia: beef per wine. New Zealand: beef per wine.
Step 3: Absolute advantage
Australia produces more of both goods (80 > 30 beef, 40 > 20 wine), so it has the absolute advantage in both.
Step 4: Comparative advantage
Beef: Australia's cost (0.5 wine) is lower than New Zealand's (0.67), so Australia has the comparative advantage in beef. Wine: New Zealand's cost (1.5 beef) is lower than Australia's (2), so New Zealand has the comparative advantage in wine.
Comparative advantage goes to the lower opportunity cost, even when the other country is absolutely better at that good.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Opportunity cost of beef: Australia 0.5 wine, New Zealand 0.67 wine; of wine: Australia 2 beef, New Zealand 1.5 beef. Australia has the absolute advantage in both goods, the comparative advantage in beef; New Zealand has the comparative advantage in wine.
Method
OC of 1 X = max Y ÷ max X; OC of 1 Y is its reciprocal.
Absolute advantage: the larger output.
Comparative advantage: the lower opportunity cost.
Watch out for
Dividing the wrong way round: write the units (wine per beef) to check.
Giving Australia the comparative advantage in both because it is better at both.
Input tables turn the calculation round. Exams often give the resources (hours of labour) needed to make one unit of each good. Now a smaller number means a country is better, and the opportunity cost of one X is the hours for X divided by the hours for Y: the hours spent on one X could have made that many units of Y.
| Country | Beef (1 tonne) | Textiles (1 bale) |
|---|---|---|
| Australia | 2 hours | 4 hours |
| Indonesia | 6 hours | 6 hours |
Output table
Bigger is better (absolute advantage: the larger output).
Input table
Smaller is better (absolute advantage: fewer hours).
Worked example
Work from an hours-per-unit table
The table shows the hours of labour needed to produce one unit of each good (illustrative).
| Country | Wheat (1 tonne) | Laptops (1 unit) |
|---|---|---|
| Australia | 4 hours | 12 hours |
| Malaysia | 10 hours | 15 hours |
Determine which country has the absolute and the comparative advantage in each good, showing the opportunity costs.
Step 1: Absolute advantage from inputs
Fewer hours means more efficient. Australia needs fewer hours for both wheat (4 < 10) and laptops (12 < 15), so it has the absolute advantage in both.
Step 2: Opportunity cost of one tonne of wheat
The hours spent on one tonne of wheat could have made part of a laptop. Australia: laptops. Malaysia: laptops.
In an input table the opportunity cost of one X is hours for X ÷ hours for Y: the reverse of the output-table rule.
Step 3: Opportunity cost of one laptop
Australia: tonnes of wheat. Malaysia: tonnes of wheat.
Step 4: Comparative advantage
Australia has the lower cost of wheat (0.33 < 0.67 laptops) and Malaysia the lower cost of laptops (1.5 < 3 tonnes of wheat).
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Australia has the absolute advantage in both goods. Its opportunity cost of wheat is 0.33 laptops against Malaysia's 0.67, so Australia has the comparative advantage in wheat; Malaysia's opportunity cost of a laptop is 1.5 tonnes of wheat against Australia's 3, so Malaysia has the comparative advantage in laptops.
Method
Absolute advantage: fewer hours per unit.
OC of 1 X = hours for X ÷ hours for Y.
Comparative advantage: the lower opportunity cost.
Watch out for
Using the output-table rule (Y ÷ X) on an input table, which inverts every cost.
Calling the larger number in an input table the absolute advantage.
Illustrative figures. Change the hours and watch the opportunity costs and the advantages follow.
In one day a worker in Chile can pick 12 crates of grapes or make 4 metres of fabric; a worker in Thailand can pick 6 crates of grapes or make 3 metres of fabric. Which statement is correct?
Key idea
Where comparative advantage comes from
Opportunity costs differ because countries have different factor endowments: different amounts and qualities of land, natural resources, labour and capital. Australia has vast farmland and mineral deposits and relatively few people, so land- and resource-intensive goods (wheat, beef, iron ore, coal, LNG) cost it relatively little. Countries with large, lower-wage workforces have the comparative advantage in labour-intensive manufacturing.
Common mistake
The upside-down fraction
The most common lost mark is dividing the wrong way round. Write the units every time: "Australia: 60 clothing ÷ 120 wheat = 0.5 clothing per wheat." If the units read "wheat per wheat", the fraction is upside down. In an input table, remember the formula flips.
Exam tip
Justify the advantage
A full answer names the country, the good, the type of advantage and the evidence: "Australia has the comparative advantage in wheat because its opportunity cost of a tonne of wheat (0.5 bales of clothing) is lower than Vietnam's (1 bale)."
Summary
Absolute advantage (Smith, 1776): producing more with the same resources. Comparative advantage (Ricardo, 1817): producing at a lower opportunity cost.
Output table: OC of 1 X = max Y ÷ max X. Input table: OC of 1 X = hours for X ÷ hours for Y. The OC of Y is the reciprocal.
The lower opportunity cost holds the comparative advantage; each country has it in one good unless their costs are equal.
A country with the absolute advantage in both goods still has the comparative advantage in only one.
Differences in factor endowments are why opportunity costs differ.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.